Discovery - University of Dundee - Online Publications

Library & Learning Centre

A Critical Discussion Game for Prohibiting Fallacies

A Critical Discussion Game for Prohibiting Fallacies

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

View graph of relations


Research units


Original languageEnglish
Number of pages25
JournalLogic and Logical Philosophy
Early online date26 Jul 2017
StateE-pub ahead of print - 26 Jul 2017


The study of fallacies is at the heart of argumentation studies. In response to Hamblin’s devastating critique of the state of the theory of fallacies in 1970, both formal dialectical and informal approaches to fallacies developed. In the current paper, we focus on an influential informal approach to fallacies, part of the pragma-dialectical theory of argumentation. Central to the pragma-dialectical method for analysing and evaluating argumentative discourse is the ideal model of a critical discussion. In this discussion model, a dialectical perspective on argumentation is combined with a pragmatic take on communicative interaction. By formalising and computationally implementing the model of a critical discussion, we take a first step in the development of software to computationally model argumentative dialogue in which fallacies are prohibited along the pragma-dialectical norms. We do this by defining the Critical Discussion Game, a formal dialogue game based on the pragma-dialectical discussion model, executable on an online user-interface which is part of a larger infrastructure of argumentation software.

Download statistics

No data available


Open Access permissions



  • Final Published Version

    Final published version, 1 MB, PDF-document

    The journal offers access to the contents in the open access system on the principles of non-exclusive license Creative Commons (CC BY-ND 3.0).


Library & Learning Centre

Contact | Accessibility | Policy