A 'Failed Experiment'? Public Ownership and the Narratives of Post-war Britain

TY - JOUR

T1 - A 'Failed Experiment'?

T2 - Public Ownership and the Narratives of Post-war Britain

AU - Tomlinson, Jim

PY - 2008/8

Y1 - 2008/8

N2 - Public ownership was a key part of Labour politics and British economic Organisation for much of the twentieth century, but may now be regarded as a historical episode, rather than a feature of contemporary life. How is this episode to be evaluated by historians? One route is to incorporate it in the dominant 'decline' narrative, and refer to public ownership as a 'failed experiment'. This paper argues against such an approach, suggesting that the decline narrative is unhelpful and outmoded, and leads to a one-dimensional and overly normative approach. Instead, it is argued that public ownership needs to be analysed as closely rooted in a specific historical context (the 1930s and 1940s) but which came to be deployed in a wholly different one (the 19505 to 1970s). In that latter period its role was not as part of a socialist planned economy, as envisaged by its early advocates, but rather as element of a 'social democratic' economy, in which it played a diverse, unexpected role in underpinning the post-war settlement.

AB - Public ownership was a key part of Labour politics and British economic Organisation for much of the twentieth century, but may now be regarded as a historical episode, rather than a feature of contemporary life. How is this episode to be evaluated by historians? One route is to incorporate it in the dominant 'decline' narrative, and refer to public ownership as a 'failed experiment'. This paper argues against such an approach, suggesting that the decline narrative is unhelpful and outmoded, and leads to a one-dimensional and overly normative approach. Instead, it is argued that public ownership needs to be analysed as closely rooted in a specific historical context (the 1930s and 1940s) but which came to be deployed in a wholly different one (the 19505 to 1970s). In that latter period its role was not as part of a socialist planned economy, as envisaged by its early advocates, but rather as element of a 'social democratic' economy, in which it played a diverse, unexpected role in underpinning the post-war settlement.

KW - Public ownership

KW - Labour history

KW - British history

U2 - 10.1179/174581808X324289

DO - 10.1179/174581808X324289

M3 - Article

SN - 0961-5652

VL - 73

SP - 228

EP - 243

JO - Labour History Review

JF - Labour History Review

IS - 2

ER -