Applying the VR-CoDES in the dental context involving patients with complex communication needs

Yuefang Zhou, Rolf Black, Ruth Freeman, Daniel Herron, Gerry Humphris, Sandra Quinn, Lesley Scott, Annalu Waller

Research output: Contribution to conferenceAbstract

Abstract

Introduction: The Verona Coding Definitions of Emotional Sequences (VR‐CoDES) has been previously applied in the dental context.  However, we know little about how dental patients with intellectual and/or communication difficulties (ICD) express their emotional distress during their dental visits, and how dental professionals manage these emotional concerns.  This study aimed to explore (a) the applicability of the VR‐CoDES to a dental context involving patients with ICD; and
(b) whether there is a need for modification of both systems of the VR‐CoDES‐CC and the VR‐CoDES‐P for future application in a similar setting.

Methods: Fourteen dental consultations were video recorded and coded using the VR‐CoDES, assisted with the additional guidelines for the VR‐CoDES in a dental context.  Both inter‐ and intra‐coder reliabilities were checked on the seven clips where cues were observed. Frequencies of cues/concerns and responses were computed and compared between categories.

Results: Sixteen cues (eight non‐verbal, no concerns) were identified within seven of the 14 consultations.  Twenty responses were observed (12 reducing space) with four multiple responses from both dentist and nurse.  Satisfactory reliability checks were achieved: Cohen’s Kappa was 0.76 (95% CI: 0,57, 0.94) for inter‐coder and 0.88 (95% CI: 0.86, 0.95) for intra‐coder.

Discussion: When assisted with the additional guidelines, cues and responses were reliably identified using the VR‐CoDES with this special dental patient group. Additional guidance is needed to improve the coding accuracy on multiple dental professionals’ responses and its impact on patient care.  The findings have provided a useful initial step toward an ongoing exploration of how healthcare providers in general identify and mange emotional distress of patients with diverse backgrounds and conditions.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 29 Sep 2014
Event12th International Conference on Communication in Healthcare - RAI Conference Centre, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Duration: 28 Sep 20141 Oct 2014
http://www.each-conference.com/

Conference

Conference12th International Conference on Communication in Healthcare
Abbreviated titleEACH Conference 2014
CountryNetherlands
CityAmsterdam
Period28/09/141/10/14
Internet address

Fingerprint

Tooth
Communication
Cues
Referral and Consultation
Mite Infestations
Guidelines
Dentists
Surgical Instruments
Health Personnel
Patient Care
Nurses

Cite this

Zhou, Y., Black, R., Freeman, R., Herron, D., Humphris, G., Quinn, S., ... Waller, A. (2014). Applying the VR-CoDES in the dental context involving patients with complex communication needs. Abstract from 12th International Conference on Communication in Healthcare , Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Zhou, Yuefang ; Black, Rolf ; Freeman, Ruth ; Herron, Daniel ; Humphris, Gerry ; Quinn, Sandra ; Scott, Lesley ; Waller, Annalu. / Applying the VR-CoDES in the dental context involving patients with complex communication needs. Abstract from 12th International Conference on Communication in Healthcare , Amsterdam, Netherlands.
@conference{2e01309d24e9499fa21afa74f76522df,
title = "Applying the VR-CoDES in the dental context involving patients with complex communication needs",
abstract = "Introduction: The Verona Coding Definitions of Emotional Sequences (VR‐CoDES) has been previously applied in the dental context.  However, we know little about how dental patients with intellectual and/or communication difficulties (ICD) express their emotional distress during their dental visits, and how dental professionals manage these emotional concerns.  This study aimed to explore (a) the applicability of the VR‐CoDES to a dental context involving patients with ICD; and(b) whether there is a need for modification of both systems of the VR‐CoDES‐CC and the VR‐CoDES‐P for future application in a similar setting.Methods: Fourteen dental consultations were video recorded and coded using the VR‐CoDES, assisted with the additional guidelines for the VR‐CoDES in a dental context.  Both inter‐ and intra‐coder reliabilities were checked on the seven clips where cues were observed. Frequencies of cues/concerns and responses were computed and compared between categories.Results: Sixteen cues (eight non‐verbal, no concerns) were identified within seven of the 14 consultations.  Twenty responses were observed (12 reducing space) with four multiple responses from both dentist and nurse.  Satisfactory reliability checks were achieved: Cohen’s Kappa was 0.76 (95{\%} CI: 0,57, 0.94) for inter‐coder and 0.88 (95{\%} CI: 0.86, 0.95) for intra‐coder.Discussion: When assisted with the additional guidelines, cues and responses were reliably identified using the VR‐CoDES with this special dental patient group. Additional guidance is needed to improve the coding accuracy on multiple dental professionals’ responses and its impact on patient care.  The findings have provided a useful initial step toward an ongoing exploration of how healthcare providers in general identify and mange emotional distress of patients with diverse backgrounds and conditions.",
author = "Yuefang Zhou and Rolf Black and Ruth Freeman and Daniel Herron and Gerry Humphris and Sandra Quinn and Lesley Scott and Annalu Waller",
year = "2014",
month = "9",
day = "29",
language = "English",
note = "12th International Conference on Communication in Healthcare , EACH Conference 2014 ; Conference date: 28-09-2014 Through 01-10-2014",
url = "http://www.each-conference.com/",

}

Zhou, Y, Black, R, Freeman, R, Herron, D, Humphris, G, Quinn, S, Scott, L & Waller, A 2014, 'Applying the VR-CoDES in the dental context involving patients with complex communication needs' 12th International Conference on Communication in Healthcare , Amsterdam, Netherlands, 28/09/14 - 1/10/14, .

Applying the VR-CoDES in the dental context involving patients with complex communication needs. / Zhou, Yuefang; Black, Rolf; Freeman, Ruth; Herron, Daniel; Humphris, Gerry; Quinn, Sandra; Scott, Lesley; Waller, Annalu.

2014. Abstract from 12th International Conference on Communication in Healthcare , Amsterdam, Netherlands.

Research output: Contribution to conferenceAbstract

TY - CONF

T1 - Applying the VR-CoDES in the dental context involving patients with complex communication needs

AU - Zhou, Yuefang

AU - Black, Rolf

AU - Freeman, Ruth

AU - Herron, Daniel

AU - Humphris, Gerry

AU - Quinn, Sandra

AU - Scott, Lesley

AU - Waller, Annalu

PY - 2014/9/29

Y1 - 2014/9/29

N2 - Introduction: The Verona Coding Definitions of Emotional Sequences (VR‐CoDES) has been previously applied in the dental context.  However, we know little about how dental patients with intellectual and/or communication difficulties (ICD) express their emotional distress during their dental visits, and how dental professionals manage these emotional concerns.  This study aimed to explore (a) the applicability of the VR‐CoDES to a dental context involving patients with ICD; and(b) whether there is a need for modification of both systems of the VR‐CoDES‐CC and the VR‐CoDES‐P for future application in a similar setting.Methods: Fourteen dental consultations were video recorded and coded using the VR‐CoDES, assisted with the additional guidelines for the VR‐CoDES in a dental context.  Both inter‐ and intra‐coder reliabilities were checked on the seven clips where cues were observed. Frequencies of cues/concerns and responses were computed and compared between categories.Results: Sixteen cues (eight non‐verbal, no concerns) were identified within seven of the 14 consultations.  Twenty responses were observed (12 reducing space) with four multiple responses from both dentist and nurse.  Satisfactory reliability checks were achieved: Cohen’s Kappa was 0.76 (95% CI: 0,57, 0.94) for inter‐coder and 0.88 (95% CI: 0.86, 0.95) for intra‐coder.Discussion: When assisted with the additional guidelines, cues and responses were reliably identified using the VR‐CoDES with this special dental patient group. Additional guidance is needed to improve the coding accuracy on multiple dental professionals’ responses and its impact on patient care.  The findings have provided a useful initial step toward an ongoing exploration of how healthcare providers in general identify and mange emotional distress of patients with diverse backgrounds and conditions.

AB - Introduction: The Verona Coding Definitions of Emotional Sequences (VR‐CoDES) has been previously applied in the dental context.  However, we know little about how dental patients with intellectual and/or communication difficulties (ICD) express their emotional distress during their dental visits, and how dental professionals manage these emotional concerns.  This study aimed to explore (a) the applicability of the VR‐CoDES to a dental context involving patients with ICD; and(b) whether there is a need for modification of both systems of the VR‐CoDES‐CC and the VR‐CoDES‐P for future application in a similar setting.Methods: Fourteen dental consultations were video recorded and coded using the VR‐CoDES, assisted with the additional guidelines for the VR‐CoDES in a dental context.  Both inter‐ and intra‐coder reliabilities were checked on the seven clips where cues were observed. Frequencies of cues/concerns and responses were computed and compared between categories.Results: Sixteen cues (eight non‐verbal, no concerns) were identified within seven of the 14 consultations.  Twenty responses were observed (12 reducing space) with four multiple responses from both dentist and nurse.  Satisfactory reliability checks were achieved: Cohen’s Kappa was 0.76 (95% CI: 0,57, 0.94) for inter‐coder and 0.88 (95% CI: 0.86, 0.95) for intra‐coder.Discussion: When assisted with the additional guidelines, cues and responses were reliably identified using the VR‐CoDES with this special dental patient group. Additional guidance is needed to improve the coding accuracy on multiple dental professionals’ responses and its impact on patient care.  The findings have provided a useful initial step toward an ongoing exploration of how healthcare providers in general identify and mange emotional distress of patients with diverse backgrounds and conditions.

UR - http://www.each.eu/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/EACH_Amsterdam_2014_Abstracts1.pdf?x89617

M3 - Abstract

ER -

Zhou Y, Black R, Freeman R, Herron D, Humphris G, Quinn S et al. Applying the VR-CoDES in the dental context involving patients with complex communication needs. 2014. Abstract from 12th International Conference on Communication in Healthcare , Amsterdam, Netherlands.