Conflicting cues from vision and touch can impair spatial task performance

speculations on the role of spatial ability in reconciling frames of reference

Madeleine Keehner

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

    3 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    In "hand assisted" minimally invasive surgery, the surgeon inserts one hand into the operative site. Despite anecdotal claims that seeing their own hand via the laparoscopic camera enhances spatial understanding, a previous study using a maze-drawing task in indirect viewing conditions found that seeing one's own hand sometimes helped and sometimes hurt performance (Keehner et al., 2004). Here I present a new analysis exploring the mismatch between kinesthetic cues (knowing where the hand is) and visual cues (seeing the hand in an orientation that is incongruent with this). Seeing one's left hand as if from the right side of egocentric space (palm view) impaired performance, and this depended on spatial ability (r=-.54). Conversely, there was no relationship with spatial ability when viewing the left hand from the left side of egocentric space (back view). The view-specific nature of the confusion raises a possible role for spatial abilities in reconciling spatial frames of reference.

    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationSpatial Cognition VI. Learning, Reasoning, and Talking about Space
    Subtitle of host publicationInternational Conference Spatial Cognition 2008, Freiburg, Germany, September 15-19, 2008. Proceedings
    EditorsChristian Freksa, Nora S. Newcombe, Peter Gardenfors, Stefan Wolfl
    Place of PublicationBerlin
    PublisherSpringer
    Pages188-201
    Number of pages14
    ISBN (Print)9783540876007
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2008
    Event6th International Conference on Spatial Cognition - Schloss Reinach, Freiburg, Germany
    Duration: 15 Sep 200819 Sep 2008
    http://conference.spatial-cognition.de/sc08/

    Publication series

    NameLecture notes in computer science
    PublisherSpringer
    Volume5248

    Conference

    Conference6th International Conference on Spatial Cognition
    Abbreviated titleSC'08
    CountryGermany
    CityFreiburg
    Period15/09/0819/09/08
    Internet address

    Cite this

    Keehner, M. (2008). Conflicting cues from vision and touch can impair spatial task performance: speculations on the role of spatial ability in reconciling frames of reference. In C. Freksa, N. S. Newcombe, P. Gardenfors, & S. Wolfl (Eds.), Spatial Cognition VI. Learning, Reasoning, and Talking about Space: International Conference Spatial Cognition 2008, Freiburg, Germany, September 15-19, 2008. Proceedings (pp. 188-201). (Lecture notes in computer science; Vol. 5248). Berlin: Springer . https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-87601-4_15
    Keehner, Madeleine. / Conflicting cues from vision and touch can impair spatial task performance : speculations on the role of spatial ability in reconciling frames of reference. Spatial Cognition VI. Learning, Reasoning, and Talking about Space: International Conference Spatial Cognition 2008, Freiburg, Germany, September 15-19, 2008. Proceedings. editor / Christian Freksa ; Nora S. Newcombe ; Peter Gardenfors ; Stefan Wolfl. Berlin : Springer , 2008. pp. 188-201 (Lecture notes in computer science).
    @inproceedings{d6cc67ea3ec446aa847592ff0f9af333,
    title = "Conflicting cues from vision and touch can impair spatial task performance: speculations on the role of spatial ability in reconciling frames of reference",
    abstract = "In {"}hand assisted{"} minimally invasive surgery, the surgeon inserts one hand into the operative site. Despite anecdotal claims that seeing their own hand via the laparoscopic camera enhances spatial understanding, a previous study using a maze-drawing task in indirect viewing conditions found that seeing one's own hand sometimes helped and sometimes hurt performance (Keehner et al., 2004). Here I present a new analysis exploring the mismatch between kinesthetic cues (knowing where the hand is) and visual cues (seeing the hand in an orientation that is incongruent with this). Seeing one's left hand as if from the right side of egocentric space (palm view) impaired performance, and this depended on spatial ability (r=-.54). Conversely, there was no relationship with spatial ability when viewing the left hand from the left side of egocentric space (back view). The view-specific nature of the confusion raises a possible role for spatial abilities in reconciling spatial frames of reference.",
    author = "Madeleine Keehner",
    year = "2008",
    doi = "10.1007/978-3-540-87601-4_15",
    language = "English",
    isbn = "9783540876007",
    series = "Lecture notes in computer science",
    publisher = "Springer",
    pages = "188--201",
    editor = "Christian Freksa and Newcombe, {Nora S.} and Peter Gardenfors and Stefan Wolfl",
    booktitle = "Spatial Cognition VI. Learning, Reasoning, and Talking about Space",

    }

    Keehner, M 2008, Conflicting cues from vision and touch can impair spatial task performance: speculations on the role of spatial ability in reconciling frames of reference. in C Freksa, NS Newcombe, P Gardenfors & S Wolfl (eds), Spatial Cognition VI. Learning, Reasoning, and Talking about Space: International Conference Spatial Cognition 2008, Freiburg, Germany, September 15-19, 2008. Proceedings. Lecture notes in computer science, vol. 5248, Springer , Berlin, pp. 188-201, 6th International Conference on Spatial Cognition, Freiburg, Germany, 15/09/08. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-87601-4_15

    Conflicting cues from vision and touch can impair spatial task performance : speculations on the role of spatial ability in reconciling frames of reference. / Keehner, Madeleine.

    Spatial Cognition VI. Learning, Reasoning, and Talking about Space: International Conference Spatial Cognition 2008, Freiburg, Germany, September 15-19, 2008. Proceedings. ed. / Christian Freksa; Nora S. Newcombe; Peter Gardenfors; Stefan Wolfl. Berlin : Springer , 2008. p. 188-201 (Lecture notes in computer science; Vol. 5248).

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

    TY - GEN

    T1 - Conflicting cues from vision and touch can impair spatial task performance

    T2 - speculations on the role of spatial ability in reconciling frames of reference

    AU - Keehner, Madeleine

    PY - 2008

    Y1 - 2008

    N2 - In "hand assisted" minimally invasive surgery, the surgeon inserts one hand into the operative site. Despite anecdotal claims that seeing their own hand via the laparoscopic camera enhances spatial understanding, a previous study using a maze-drawing task in indirect viewing conditions found that seeing one's own hand sometimes helped and sometimes hurt performance (Keehner et al., 2004). Here I present a new analysis exploring the mismatch between kinesthetic cues (knowing where the hand is) and visual cues (seeing the hand in an orientation that is incongruent with this). Seeing one's left hand as if from the right side of egocentric space (palm view) impaired performance, and this depended on spatial ability (r=-.54). Conversely, there was no relationship with spatial ability when viewing the left hand from the left side of egocentric space (back view). The view-specific nature of the confusion raises a possible role for spatial abilities in reconciling spatial frames of reference.

    AB - In "hand assisted" minimally invasive surgery, the surgeon inserts one hand into the operative site. Despite anecdotal claims that seeing their own hand via the laparoscopic camera enhances spatial understanding, a previous study using a maze-drawing task in indirect viewing conditions found that seeing one's own hand sometimes helped and sometimes hurt performance (Keehner et al., 2004). Here I present a new analysis exploring the mismatch between kinesthetic cues (knowing where the hand is) and visual cues (seeing the hand in an orientation that is incongruent with this). Seeing one's left hand as if from the right side of egocentric space (palm view) impaired performance, and this depended on spatial ability (r=-.54). Conversely, there was no relationship with spatial ability when viewing the left hand from the left side of egocentric space (back view). The view-specific nature of the confusion raises a possible role for spatial abilities in reconciling spatial frames of reference.

    U2 - 10.1007/978-3-540-87601-4_15

    DO - 10.1007/978-3-540-87601-4_15

    M3 - Conference contribution

    SN - 9783540876007

    T3 - Lecture notes in computer science

    SP - 188

    EP - 201

    BT - Spatial Cognition VI. Learning, Reasoning, and Talking about Space

    A2 - Freksa, Christian

    A2 - Newcombe, Nora S.

    A2 - Gardenfors, Peter

    A2 - Wolfl, Stefan

    PB - Springer

    CY - Berlin

    ER -

    Keehner M. Conflicting cues from vision and touch can impair spatial task performance: speculations on the role of spatial ability in reconciling frames of reference. In Freksa C, Newcombe NS, Gardenfors P, Wolfl S, editors, Spatial Cognition VI. Learning, Reasoning, and Talking about Space: International Conference Spatial Cognition 2008, Freiburg, Germany, September 15-19, 2008. Proceedings. Berlin: Springer . 2008. p. 188-201. (Lecture notes in computer science). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-87601-4_15