Dental professionals’ experiences of managing children with carious lesions in their primary teeth – a qualitative study within the FiCTION randomised controlled trial

Zoe Marshman, Jennifer E. Kettle, Richard D. Holmes, Kathryn B. Cunningham, Ruth Freeman, Barry J. Gibson, Elaine McColl, Anne Maguire, Gail V. A. Douglas, Janet E. Clarkson, Nicola P. T. Innes (Lead / Corresponding author)

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
20 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Background: The lack of evidence for the effective management of carious lesions in children’s primary teeth has caused uncertainty for the dental profession and patients. Possible approaches include conventional and biological management alongside best practice prevention, and best practice prevention alone. The FiCTION trial assessed the effectiveness of these options, and included a qualitative study exploring dental professionals’ (DPs) experiences of delivering the different treatment arms. This paper reports on how DPs managed children with carious lesions within FiCTION and how this related to their everyday experiences of doing dentistry.

Methods: Overall, 31 DPs from FiCTION-trained dental surgeries in four regions of the UK participated in semi-structured interviews about their experiences of the three treatment arms (conventional management of carious lesions and prevention (C + P), biological management of carious lesions and prevention (B + P) or prevention alone (PA)). A theoretical framework, drawing on social practice theory (SPT), was developed for analysis.

Results: Participants discussed perceived effectiveness of, and familiarity with, the three techniques. The C + P arm was familiar, but some participants questioned the effectiveness of conventional restorations. Attitudes towards the B + P arm varied in terms of familiarity, but once DPs were introduced to the techniques, this was seen as effective. While prevention was familiar, PA was described as ineffective. DPs manage children with carious lesions day-to-day, drawing on previous experience and knowledge of the child to provide what they view as the most appropriate treatment in the best interests of each child. Randomisation undermined these normal choices. Several DPs reported deviating from the trial arms in order to treat a patient in a particular way. Participants valued evidence-based dentistry, and expect to use the results of FiCTION to inform future practice. They anticipate continuing to use the full range of treatment options, and to personally select appropriate strategies for individual children.

Conclusions: RCTs take place in the context of day-to-day practices of doing dentistry. DPs employ experiential and interpersonal knowledge to act in the best interests of their patients. Randomisation within a clinical trial can present a source of tension for DPs, which has implications for assuring individual equipoise in future trials.
Original languageEnglish
Article number64
Pages (from-to)1-16
Number of pages16
JournalBMC Oral Health
Volume20
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 4 Mar 2020

Keywords

  • Carious lesions
  • Dental caries
  • Dental professionals
  • Dentists
  • Paediatric dentistry
  • Primary care
  • Qualitative research
  • Randomised controlled trial

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Dental professionals’ experiences of managing children with carious lesions in their primary teeth – a qualitative study within the FiCTION randomised controlled trial'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

  • Research Output

    • 1 Citations
    • 1 Book
    • 1 Article

    Promoting inclusion oral-health: social interventions to reduce oral health inequities

    Freeman, R., Beaton, L., Richards, D., Rodriguez, A., Anderson, I., Humphris, G., Coles, E., Lambert, M. & Yuan, S., Mar 2020, Switzerland: Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI). 96 p.

    Research output: Book/ReportBook

    Open Access
    File
  • 11 Downloads (Pure)

    The FiCTION trial: Child oral health-related quality of life and dental anxiety across three treatment strategies for managing caries in young children

    Freeman, R., Maguire, A., Ryan, V., Wilson, N., Innes, N. P. T., Clarkson, J. E., McColl, E., Marshman, Z., Robertson, M., Abouhajar, A., Chadwick, B., Deery, C., Wong, F. & Douglas, G. V. A., 27 Apr 2020, In : Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology. 23 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  • Cite this