[Disability] justice dictated by the surfeit of love: Simone Weil in Nigeria

Oche Onazi (Lead / Corresponding author)

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
128 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

How is Nigeria’s failure to fulfil its obligations as a signatory of theUnited Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities to be appreciated or even resolved? Answers to this are sought through a seminal criticism of human rights, namely, Simone Weil’s 1942 essay Human Personality. Weil questioned the ability of human rights concepts to cause the powerfulto develop the emotional dispositions of empathy for those who suffer. Weil’s insights provide a convincing explanation that the indifference of Nigerian authorities towards the Convention may be accounted for by the weakness of human rights discourse to foster human capacity for empathy and care for those who suffer. Weil’s criticisms will serve as a point of departure for a particular way to circumvent this inadequacy of human rights discourse to achieve disability justice in Nigeria through other means. I argue that Weil not only grappled with, but through her concept of attention, offers a consciousness of suffering and vulnerability that is not only uncommon to existing juridical human rights approaches, but is achievable through the active
participation in the very forms of suffering and vulnerability in which amelioration is sought. To provide empirical content to this argument, I turn to a short-lived initiative of the Nigerian disability movement, which if ethico-politically refined and widely applied, can supply an action-theoretical grounding for and be combined with Weil’s work to elevate agitations for disability justice above human rights to the realm of human obligations.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-22
Number of pages22
JournalLaw and Critique
Volume28
Issue number1
Early online date26 Jul 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2017

Fingerprint

Nigeria
love
human rights
disability
justice
obligation
vulnerability
criticism
discourse
empathy
disposition
consciousness
personality
cause
human being
ability

Keywords

  • disability justice
  • human rights
  • human obligations
  • Simone Weil
  • attention
  • disability simulation

Cite this

@article{384c404448ea42a5ad916105a94cebc3,
title = "[Disability] justice dictated by the surfeit of love: Simone Weil in Nigeria",
abstract = "How is Nigeria’s failure to fulfil its obligations as a signatory of theUnited Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities to be appreciated or even resolved? Answers to this are sought through a seminal criticism of human rights, namely, Simone Weil’s 1942 essay Human Personality. Weil questioned the ability of human rights concepts to cause the powerfulto develop the emotional dispositions of empathy for those who suffer. Weil’s insights provide a convincing explanation that the indifference of Nigerian authorities towards the Convention may be accounted for by the weakness of human rights discourse to foster human capacity for empathy and care for those who suffer. Weil’s criticisms will serve as a point of departure for a particular way to circumvent this inadequacy of human rights discourse to achieve disability justice in Nigeria through other means. I argue that Weil not only grappled with, but through her concept of attention, offers a consciousness of suffering and vulnerability that is not only uncommon to existing juridical human rights approaches, but is achievable through the activeparticipation in the very forms of suffering and vulnerability in which amelioration is sought. To provide empirical content to this argument, I turn to a short-lived initiative of the Nigerian disability movement, which if ethico-politically refined and widely applied, can supply an action-theoretical grounding for and be combined with Weil’s work to elevate agitations for disability justice above human rights to the realm of human obligations.",
keywords = "disability justice, human rights, human obligations, Simone Weil, attention, disability simulation",
author = "Oche Onazi",
note = "Independent Social Research Foundation (ISRF) for the generous funding that has enabled me to complete this article, partly connected to a study on disability justice in Africa. An earlier version of this article was presented at a Special Working Group of the XXVII World Congress of the International Association for the Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy (IVR), Georgetown Law Center, 2015.",
year = "2017",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1007/s10978-016-9191-2",
language = "English",
volume = "28",
pages = "1--22",
journal = "Law and Critique",
issn = "0957-8536",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "1",

}

[Disability] justice dictated by the surfeit of love : Simone Weil in Nigeria. / Onazi, Oche (Lead / Corresponding author).

In: Law and Critique, Vol. 28, No. 1, 03.2017, p. 1-22.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - [Disability] justice dictated by the surfeit of love

T2 - Simone Weil in Nigeria

AU - Onazi, Oche

N1 - Independent Social Research Foundation (ISRF) for the generous funding that has enabled me to complete this article, partly connected to a study on disability justice in Africa. An earlier version of this article was presented at a Special Working Group of the XXVII World Congress of the International Association for the Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy (IVR), Georgetown Law Center, 2015.

PY - 2017/3

Y1 - 2017/3

N2 - How is Nigeria’s failure to fulfil its obligations as a signatory of theUnited Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities to be appreciated or even resolved? Answers to this are sought through a seminal criticism of human rights, namely, Simone Weil’s 1942 essay Human Personality. Weil questioned the ability of human rights concepts to cause the powerfulto develop the emotional dispositions of empathy for those who suffer. Weil’s insights provide a convincing explanation that the indifference of Nigerian authorities towards the Convention may be accounted for by the weakness of human rights discourse to foster human capacity for empathy and care for those who suffer. Weil’s criticisms will serve as a point of departure for a particular way to circumvent this inadequacy of human rights discourse to achieve disability justice in Nigeria through other means. I argue that Weil not only grappled with, but through her concept of attention, offers a consciousness of suffering and vulnerability that is not only uncommon to existing juridical human rights approaches, but is achievable through the activeparticipation in the very forms of suffering and vulnerability in which amelioration is sought. To provide empirical content to this argument, I turn to a short-lived initiative of the Nigerian disability movement, which if ethico-politically refined and widely applied, can supply an action-theoretical grounding for and be combined with Weil’s work to elevate agitations for disability justice above human rights to the realm of human obligations.

AB - How is Nigeria’s failure to fulfil its obligations as a signatory of theUnited Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities to be appreciated or even resolved? Answers to this are sought through a seminal criticism of human rights, namely, Simone Weil’s 1942 essay Human Personality. Weil questioned the ability of human rights concepts to cause the powerfulto develop the emotional dispositions of empathy for those who suffer. Weil’s insights provide a convincing explanation that the indifference of Nigerian authorities towards the Convention may be accounted for by the weakness of human rights discourse to foster human capacity for empathy and care for those who suffer. Weil’s criticisms will serve as a point of departure for a particular way to circumvent this inadequacy of human rights discourse to achieve disability justice in Nigeria through other means. I argue that Weil not only grappled with, but through her concept of attention, offers a consciousness of suffering and vulnerability that is not only uncommon to existing juridical human rights approaches, but is achievable through the activeparticipation in the very forms of suffering and vulnerability in which amelioration is sought. To provide empirical content to this argument, I turn to a short-lived initiative of the Nigerian disability movement, which if ethico-politically refined and widely applied, can supply an action-theoretical grounding for and be combined with Weil’s work to elevate agitations for disability justice above human rights to the realm of human obligations.

KW - disability justice

KW - human rights

KW - human obligations

KW - Simone Weil

KW - attention

KW - disability simulation

U2 - 10.1007/s10978-016-9191-2

DO - 10.1007/s10978-016-9191-2

M3 - Article

VL - 28

SP - 1

EP - 22

JO - Law and Critique

JF - Law and Critique

SN - 0957-8536

IS - 1

ER -