Evaluating efforts to enhance health and wellbeing: A review of policy aspirations and practice developments in Scottish secondary schools

Donna Dey, Malcolm Thorburn

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Chapter 3 highlighted the increased policy expectation there often is nowadays for schools to be a pivotal force for good in helping young people to live more stable and rewarding lives. However, as Chapter 3 also outlined, these aspirations have been supported by variable degrees of policy coherence and clarity. Accordingly, the focus in this chapter is to analyse health and wellbeing (HWB) developments in Scotland, in order to understand better in the context of one country the policy formation process, learning and teaching in HWB, the contribution of HWB towards learners’ wider achievement as well as a broader evaluation of HWB as part of Curriculum for Excellence (CFE). This review aims to provide insights into the multiple challenges which exist in and between policy guidelines and policy enactment in schools. Approaching the chapter in this way enables consideration to be taken of the ‘overall texture and rhythms of teachers’ work – the different times of year in schools and the deadening tiredness with which teachers often grapple’ (Ball et al., 2012, p. 5). The review is also timely, as since 2004, CFE – in essence, a progressive set of all-encompassing national curriculum guidelines and arrangements covering learners between 3 and 18 years – has moved from being a broad set of policy aspirations to full implementation in 2010–2011. As such, there should be in place by now a heightened emphasis on active learner engagement alongside an encouragement for teachers to make greater use of their professional autonomy and curriculum decision-making responsibility (Scottish Government, 2008). Sinnema (2016, p. 966) considers that Scotland (like New Zealand but unlike England and Australia), is one of the leading examples of where schools ‘are asked to address the challenges inherent in designing and implementing a local curriculum in a manner that also ensures they give effect to a national curriculum’. Moreover, the current period has been identified as a ‘watershed moment’ for CFE, as the first five-year cycle of programme implementation is nearing completion (OECD, 2015, p. 100). 63Thus, there is a major opportunity to evaluate whether a greater policy engagement with dynamic learning and teaching in HWB is being taken forward or not.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationWellbeing, Education and Contemporary Schooling
EditorsMalcolm Thorburn
Place of PublicationLondon
PublisherRoutledge
Number of pages15
ISBN (Electronic) 9781317211419
Publication statusPublished - 8 Aug 2017

Fingerprint

secondary school
curriculum
health
school
teacher
Teaching
OECD
learning process
New Zealand
autonomy
decision making
responsibility
evaluation
learning

Cite this

Dey, D., & Thorburn, M. (2017). Evaluating efforts to enhance health and wellbeing: A review of policy aspirations and practice developments in Scottish secondary schools. In M. Thorburn (Ed.), Wellbeing, Education and Contemporary Schooling London: Routledge.
Dey, Donna ; Thorburn, Malcolm. / Evaluating efforts to enhance health and wellbeing : A review of policy aspirations and practice developments in Scottish secondary schools. Wellbeing, Education and Contemporary Schooling. editor / Malcolm Thorburn. London : Routledge, 2017.
@inbook{2b1d16c83e464f1f8dc43ca8f4bb759f,
title = "Evaluating efforts to enhance health and wellbeing: A review of policy aspirations and practice developments in Scottish secondary schools",
abstract = "Chapter 3 highlighted the increased policy expectation there often is nowadays for schools to be a pivotal force for good in helping young people to live more stable and rewarding lives. However, as Chapter 3 also outlined, these aspirations have been supported by variable degrees of policy coherence and clarity. Accordingly, the focus in this chapter is to analyse health and wellbeing (HWB) developments in Scotland, in order to understand better in the context of one country the policy formation process, learning and teaching in HWB, the contribution of HWB towards learners’ wider achievement as well as a broader evaluation of HWB as part of Curriculum for Excellence (CFE). This review aims to provide insights into the multiple challenges which exist in and between policy guidelines and policy enactment in schools. Approaching the chapter in this way enables consideration to be taken of the ‘overall texture and rhythms of teachers’ work – the different times of year in schools and the deadening tiredness with which teachers often grapple’ (Ball et al., 2012, p. 5). The review is also timely, as since 2004, CFE – in essence, a progressive set of all-encompassing national curriculum guidelines and arrangements covering learners between 3 and 18 years – has moved from being a broad set of policy aspirations to full implementation in 2010–2011. As such, there should be in place by now a heightened emphasis on active learner engagement alongside an encouragement for teachers to make greater use of their professional autonomy and curriculum decision-making responsibility (Scottish Government, 2008). Sinnema (2016, p. 966) considers that Scotland (like New Zealand but unlike England and Australia), is one of the leading examples of where schools ‘are asked to address the challenges inherent in designing and implementing a local curriculum in a manner that also ensures they give effect to a national curriculum’. Moreover, the current period has been identified as a ‘watershed moment’ for CFE, as the first five-year cycle of programme implementation is nearing completion (OECD, 2015, p. 100). 63Thus, there is a major opportunity to evaluate whether a greater policy engagement with dynamic learning and teaching in HWB is being taken forward or not.",
author = "Donna Dey and Malcolm Thorburn",
year = "2017",
month = "8",
day = "8",
language = "English",
editor = "Malcolm Thorburn",
booktitle = "Wellbeing, Education and Contemporary Schooling",
publisher = "Routledge",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

Dey, D & Thorburn, M 2017, Evaluating efforts to enhance health and wellbeing: A review of policy aspirations and practice developments in Scottish secondary schools. in M Thorburn (ed.), Wellbeing, Education and Contemporary Schooling. Routledge, London.

Evaluating efforts to enhance health and wellbeing : A review of policy aspirations and practice developments in Scottish secondary schools. / Dey, Donna; Thorburn, Malcolm.

Wellbeing, Education and Contemporary Schooling. ed. / Malcolm Thorburn. London : Routledge, 2017.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

TY - CHAP

T1 - Evaluating efforts to enhance health and wellbeing

T2 - A review of policy aspirations and practice developments in Scottish secondary schools

AU - Dey, Donna

AU - Thorburn, Malcolm

PY - 2017/8/8

Y1 - 2017/8/8

N2 - Chapter 3 highlighted the increased policy expectation there often is nowadays for schools to be a pivotal force for good in helping young people to live more stable and rewarding lives. However, as Chapter 3 also outlined, these aspirations have been supported by variable degrees of policy coherence and clarity. Accordingly, the focus in this chapter is to analyse health and wellbeing (HWB) developments in Scotland, in order to understand better in the context of one country the policy formation process, learning and teaching in HWB, the contribution of HWB towards learners’ wider achievement as well as a broader evaluation of HWB as part of Curriculum for Excellence (CFE). This review aims to provide insights into the multiple challenges which exist in and between policy guidelines and policy enactment in schools. Approaching the chapter in this way enables consideration to be taken of the ‘overall texture and rhythms of teachers’ work – the different times of year in schools and the deadening tiredness with which teachers often grapple’ (Ball et al., 2012, p. 5). The review is also timely, as since 2004, CFE – in essence, a progressive set of all-encompassing national curriculum guidelines and arrangements covering learners between 3 and 18 years – has moved from being a broad set of policy aspirations to full implementation in 2010–2011. As such, there should be in place by now a heightened emphasis on active learner engagement alongside an encouragement for teachers to make greater use of their professional autonomy and curriculum decision-making responsibility (Scottish Government, 2008). Sinnema (2016, p. 966) considers that Scotland (like New Zealand but unlike England and Australia), is one of the leading examples of where schools ‘are asked to address the challenges inherent in designing and implementing a local curriculum in a manner that also ensures they give effect to a national curriculum’. Moreover, the current period has been identified as a ‘watershed moment’ for CFE, as the first five-year cycle of programme implementation is nearing completion (OECD, 2015, p. 100). 63Thus, there is a major opportunity to evaluate whether a greater policy engagement with dynamic learning and teaching in HWB is being taken forward or not.

AB - Chapter 3 highlighted the increased policy expectation there often is nowadays for schools to be a pivotal force for good in helping young people to live more stable and rewarding lives. However, as Chapter 3 also outlined, these aspirations have been supported by variable degrees of policy coherence and clarity. Accordingly, the focus in this chapter is to analyse health and wellbeing (HWB) developments in Scotland, in order to understand better in the context of one country the policy formation process, learning and teaching in HWB, the contribution of HWB towards learners’ wider achievement as well as a broader evaluation of HWB as part of Curriculum for Excellence (CFE). This review aims to provide insights into the multiple challenges which exist in and between policy guidelines and policy enactment in schools. Approaching the chapter in this way enables consideration to be taken of the ‘overall texture and rhythms of teachers’ work – the different times of year in schools and the deadening tiredness with which teachers often grapple’ (Ball et al., 2012, p. 5). The review is also timely, as since 2004, CFE – in essence, a progressive set of all-encompassing national curriculum guidelines and arrangements covering learners between 3 and 18 years – has moved from being a broad set of policy aspirations to full implementation in 2010–2011. As such, there should be in place by now a heightened emphasis on active learner engagement alongside an encouragement for teachers to make greater use of their professional autonomy and curriculum decision-making responsibility (Scottish Government, 2008). Sinnema (2016, p. 966) considers that Scotland (like New Zealand but unlike England and Australia), is one of the leading examples of where schools ‘are asked to address the challenges inherent in designing and implementing a local curriculum in a manner that also ensures they give effect to a national curriculum’. Moreover, the current period has been identified as a ‘watershed moment’ for CFE, as the first five-year cycle of programme implementation is nearing completion (OECD, 2015, p. 100). 63Thus, there is a major opportunity to evaluate whether a greater policy engagement with dynamic learning and teaching in HWB is being taken forward or not.

M3 - Chapter (peer-reviewed)

BT - Wellbeing, Education and Contemporary Schooling

A2 - Thorburn, Malcolm

PB - Routledge

CY - London

ER -

Dey D, Thorburn M. Evaluating efforts to enhance health and wellbeing: A review of policy aspirations and practice developments in Scottish secondary schools. In Thorburn M, editor, Wellbeing, Education and Contemporary Schooling. London: Routledge. 2017