Exploiting physical defence traits for crop protection

Leaf trichomes of Rubus idaeus have deterrent effects on spider mites but not aphids

A. J. Karley (Lead / Corresponding author), C. Mitchell, C. Brookes, J. McNicol, T. O'Neill, H. Roberts, J. Graham, S. N. Johnson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Plants possess anti-herbivore defences that could be exploited for crop protection. The potential for deploying physical defence traits for more sustainable pest management (i.e. reduced pesticide application) has not been fully realised. Using a perennial crop (red raspberry, Rubus idaeus), we take the novel approach of quantifying within- and between-genotype variation in a resistance trait, leaf trichome density, to determine precisely the effect of trichomes on host plant preference and suitability for two shoot-feeding arthropods, the European large raspberry aphid (Amphorophora idaei) and two-spotted spider mite (Tetranychus urticae). Additionally, we tested whether this trait influenced searching behaviour of a generalist herbivore predator (lacewing larvae, Chrysoperla carnea). Although there was no consistent genotypic variation in R. idaeus suitability for T. urticae, our hypothesis that T. urticae would avoid high leaf trichome density was supported on certain genotypes. The deterrent effect was mainly on egg deposition rather than leaf selection by adults, with up to sixfold differences in leaf preference depending on the genotypes offered. By contrast, there was significant genotypic variation in R. idaeus suitability for A. idaei (10-fold variation in aphid abundance), but, contrary to our prediction, aphid preference and infestation levels were unrelated to leaf trichome density. Instead, A. idaei performed best on vigorous genotypes, indicating that plant tolerance traits contributed to R. idaeus suitability for aphids. Leaf trichomes had little effect on the behaviour of the beneficial control agent C. carnea larvae. We conclude that physical anti-herbivore defences, specifically leaf trichomes, could be deployed to deter particular arthropod pests. However, the mechanistic approach adopted here is necessary to avoid antagonistic effects on other pests or on natural enemies.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)159-172
Number of pages14
JournalAnnals of Applied Biology
Volume168
Issue number2
Early online date11 Nov 2015
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2016

Fingerprint

Rubus idaeus
Tetranychidae
plant protection
trichomes
Aphidoidea
Tetranychus urticae
leaves
Chrysoperla carnea
herbivores
genotype
lacewings
arthropod pests
searching behavior
larvae
raspberries
pest management
natural enemies
pesticide application
arthropods
host plants

Keywords

  • Amphorophora idaei
  • Chrysoperla carnea
  • defensive traits
  • host preference
  • integrated pest and disease management
  • leaf hairs
  • oviposition
  • plant quality
  • plant vigour
  • Tetranychus urticae
  • tolerance
  • trichomes

Cite this

Karley, A. J. ; Mitchell, C. ; Brookes, C. ; McNicol, J. ; O'Neill, T. ; Roberts, H. ; Graham, J. ; Johnson, S. N. / Exploiting physical defence traits for crop protection : Leaf trichomes of Rubus idaeus have deterrent effects on spider mites but not aphids. In: Annals of Applied Biology. 2016 ; Vol. 168, No. 2. pp. 159-172.
@article{633257c3f25d40fbb80a3c5d6ec66ffc,
title = "Exploiting physical defence traits for crop protection: Leaf trichomes of Rubus idaeus have deterrent effects on spider mites but not aphids",
abstract = "Plants possess anti-herbivore defences that could be exploited for crop protection. The potential for deploying physical defence traits for more sustainable pest management (i.e. reduced pesticide application) has not been fully realised. Using a perennial crop (red raspberry, Rubus idaeus), we take the novel approach of quantifying within- and between-genotype variation in a resistance trait, leaf trichome density, to determine precisely the effect of trichomes on host plant preference and suitability for two shoot-feeding arthropods, the European large raspberry aphid (Amphorophora idaei) and two-spotted spider mite (Tetranychus urticae). Additionally, we tested whether this trait influenced searching behaviour of a generalist herbivore predator (lacewing larvae, Chrysoperla carnea). Although there was no consistent genotypic variation in R. idaeus suitability for T. urticae, our hypothesis that T. urticae would avoid high leaf trichome density was supported on certain genotypes. The deterrent effect was mainly on egg deposition rather than leaf selection by adults, with up to sixfold differences in leaf preference depending on the genotypes offered. By contrast, there was significant genotypic variation in R. idaeus suitability for A. idaei (10-fold variation in aphid abundance), but, contrary to our prediction, aphid preference and infestation levels were unrelated to leaf trichome density. Instead, A. idaei performed best on vigorous genotypes, indicating that plant tolerance traits contributed to R. idaeus suitability for aphids. Leaf trichomes had little effect on the behaviour of the beneficial control agent C. carnea larvae. We conclude that physical anti-herbivore defences, specifically leaf trichomes, could be deployed to deter particular arthropod pests. However, the mechanistic approach adopted here is necessary to avoid antagonistic effects on other pests or on natural enemies.",
keywords = "Amphorophora idaei, Chrysoperla carnea, defensive traits, host preference, integrated pest and disease management, leaf hairs, oviposition, plant quality, plant vigour, Tetranychus urticae, tolerance, trichomes",
author = "Karley, {A. J.} and C. Mitchell and C. Brookes and J. McNicol and T. O'Neill and H. Roberts and J. Graham and Johnson, {S. N.}",
year = "2016",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1111/aab.12252",
language = "English",
volume = "168",
pages = "159--172",
journal = "Annals of Applied Biology",
issn = "0003-4746",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "2",

}

Karley, AJ, Mitchell, C, Brookes, C, McNicol, J, O'Neill, T, Roberts, H, Graham, J & Johnson, SN 2016, 'Exploiting physical defence traits for crop protection: Leaf trichomes of Rubus idaeus have deterrent effects on spider mites but not aphids', Annals of Applied Biology, vol. 168, no. 2, pp. 159-172. https://doi.org/10.1111/aab.12252

Exploiting physical defence traits for crop protection : Leaf trichomes of Rubus idaeus have deterrent effects on spider mites but not aphids. / Karley, A. J. (Lead / Corresponding author); Mitchell, C.; Brookes, C.; McNicol, J.; O'Neill, T.; Roberts, H.; Graham, J.; Johnson, S. N.

In: Annals of Applied Biology, Vol. 168, No. 2, 03.2016, p. 159-172.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Exploiting physical defence traits for crop protection

T2 - Leaf trichomes of Rubus idaeus have deterrent effects on spider mites but not aphids

AU - Karley, A. J.

AU - Mitchell, C.

AU - Brookes, C.

AU - McNicol, J.

AU - O'Neill, T.

AU - Roberts, H.

AU - Graham, J.

AU - Johnson, S. N.

PY - 2016/3

Y1 - 2016/3

N2 - Plants possess anti-herbivore defences that could be exploited for crop protection. The potential for deploying physical defence traits for more sustainable pest management (i.e. reduced pesticide application) has not been fully realised. Using a perennial crop (red raspberry, Rubus idaeus), we take the novel approach of quantifying within- and between-genotype variation in a resistance trait, leaf trichome density, to determine precisely the effect of trichomes on host plant preference and suitability for two shoot-feeding arthropods, the European large raspberry aphid (Amphorophora idaei) and two-spotted spider mite (Tetranychus urticae). Additionally, we tested whether this trait influenced searching behaviour of a generalist herbivore predator (lacewing larvae, Chrysoperla carnea). Although there was no consistent genotypic variation in R. idaeus suitability for T. urticae, our hypothesis that T. urticae would avoid high leaf trichome density was supported on certain genotypes. The deterrent effect was mainly on egg deposition rather than leaf selection by adults, with up to sixfold differences in leaf preference depending on the genotypes offered. By contrast, there was significant genotypic variation in R. idaeus suitability for A. idaei (10-fold variation in aphid abundance), but, contrary to our prediction, aphid preference and infestation levels were unrelated to leaf trichome density. Instead, A. idaei performed best on vigorous genotypes, indicating that plant tolerance traits contributed to R. idaeus suitability for aphids. Leaf trichomes had little effect on the behaviour of the beneficial control agent C. carnea larvae. We conclude that physical anti-herbivore defences, specifically leaf trichomes, could be deployed to deter particular arthropod pests. However, the mechanistic approach adopted here is necessary to avoid antagonistic effects on other pests or on natural enemies.

AB - Plants possess anti-herbivore defences that could be exploited for crop protection. The potential for deploying physical defence traits for more sustainable pest management (i.e. reduced pesticide application) has not been fully realised. Using a perennial crop (red raspberry, Rubus idaeus), we take the novel approach of quantifying within- and between-genotype variation in a resistance trait, leaf trichome density, to determine precisely the effect of trichomes on host plant preference and suitability for two shoot-feeding arthropods, the European large raspberry aphid (Amphorophora idaei) and two-spotted spider mite (Tetranychus urticae). Additionally, we tested whether this trait influenced searching behaviour of a generalist herbivore predator (lacewing larvae, Chrysoperla carnea). Although there was no consistent genotypic variation in R. idaeus suitability for T. urticae, our hypothesis that T. urticae would avoid high leaf trichome density was supported on certain genotypes. The deterrent effect was mainly on egg deposition rather than leaf selection by adults, with up to sixfold differences in leaf preference depending on the genotypes offered. By contrast, there was significant genotypic variation in R. idaeus suitability for A. idaei (10-fold variation in aphid abundance), but, contrary to our prediction, aphid preference and infestation levels were unrelated to leaf trichome density. Instead, A. idaei performed best on vigorous genotypes, indicating that plant tolerance traits contributed to R. idaeus suitability for aphids. Leaf trichomes had little effect on the behaviour of the beneficial control agent C. carnea larvae. We conclude that physical anti-herbivore defences, specifically leaf trichomes, could be deployed to deter particular arthropod pests. However, the mechanistic approach adopted here is necessary to avoid antagonistic effects on other pests or on natural enemies.

KW - Amphorophora idaei

KW - Chrysoperla carnea

KW - defensive traits

KW - host preference

KW - integrated pest and disease management

KW - leaf hairs

KW - oviposition

KW - plant quality

KW - plant vigour

KW - Tetranychus urticae

KW - tolerance

KW - trichomes

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84958767272&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/aab.12252

DO - 10.1111/aab.12252

M3 - Article

VL - 168

SP - 159

EP - 172

JO - Annals of Applied Biology

JF - Annals of Applied Biology

SN - 0003-4746

IS - 2

ER -