Exploring the linkages between multifunctional forestry goals and the legacy of spruce plantations in Scotland

Maria Nijnik, Albert Nijnik, Iain Brown

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    8 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    This paper explores the ecosystem services associated with woodlands, as they are viewed by individuals in Scotland, with the idea to reconcile objectives for multifunctionality with the legacy of past forestry systems that were not designed with multifunctionality in mind. Research follows a semi-qualitative route and applies the Q method to identify and explain a range of attitudes among the general public and forestry-associated stakeholders regarding the functional future of forestry in Scotland. Four distinctive groups of attitudes were identified and key factors influencing the attitudinal diversity were explained. Despite the uncovered attitudinal heterogeneity, all groups of attitudes have strong emphasis on native woodland regeneration and on improvement of aesthetic values of woodlands but differ concerning afforestation. An improved under-standing of what people think provided an indication of their recognition of ecosystem services types and the trade-offs between these, opportunities available, and factors that can hamper forestry development (e.g., concerning the aspiration of increasing Scotland’s forest cover to 25%). Findings suggest that the productivists’ position (for which the economic objectives are important) remains strong in Scotland. Results (compared with those in several other countries) demonstrate comparability between public and stakeholder perspectives in support of the multifunctional forestry, and this has distinct policy relevance and implications for decision-making.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)1247-1254
    Number of pages8
    JournalCanadian Journal of Forest Research
    Volume46
    Issue number10
    Early online date19 Oct 2016
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2016

    Fingerprint

    Scotland
    Picea
    forestry
    plantation
    plantations
    woodlands
    woodland
    ecosystem services
    stakeholders
    ecosystem service
    forestry development
    stakeholder
    aesthetics
    afforestation
    decision making
    forest cover
    esthetics
    economics
    regeneration
    methodology

    Keywords

    • Attitudinal diversity
    • Ecosystem services
    • Q method
    • Stakeholders
    • Woodlands

    Cite this

    @article{cb02e3702a4446d99e4e73272363e2d8,
    title = "Exploring the linkages between multifunctional forestry goals and the legacy of spruce plantations in Scotland",
    abstract = "This paper explores the ecosystem services associated with woodlands, as they are viewed by individuals in Scotland, with the idea to reconcile objectives for multifunctionality with the legacy of past forestry systems that were not designed with multifunctionality in mind. Research follows a semi-qualitative route and applies the Q method to identify and explain a range of attitudes among the general public and forestry-associated stakeholders regarding the functional future of forestry in Scotland. Four distinctive groups of attitudes were identified and key factors influencing the attitudinal diversity were explained. Despite the uncovered attitudinal heterogeneity, all groups of attitudes have strong emphasis on native woodland regeneration and on improvement of aesthetic values of woodlands but differ concerning afforestation. An improved under-standing of what people think provided an indication of their recognition of ecosystem services types and the trade-offs between these, opportunities available, and factors that can hamper forestry development (e.g., concerning the aspiration of increasing Scotland’s forest cover to 25{\%}). Findings suggest that the productivists’ position (for which the economic objectives are important) remains strong in Scotland. Results (compared with those in several other countries) demonstrate comparability between public and stakeholder perspectives in support of the multifunctional forestry, and this has distinct policy relevance and implications for decision-making.",
    keywords = "Attitudinal diversity, Ecosystem services, Q method, Stakeholders, Woodlands",
    author = "Maria Nijnik and Albert Nijnik and Iain Brown",
    year = "2016",
    doi = "10.1139/cjfr-2015-0399",
    language = "English",
    volume = "46",
    pages = "1247--1254",
    journal = "Canadian Journal of Forest Research",
    issn = "0045-5067",
    publisher = "NRC Research Press",
    number = "10",

    }

    Exploring the linkages between multifunctional forestry goals and the legacy of spruce plantations in Scotland. / Nijnik, Maria; Nijnik, Albert; Brown, Iain.

    In: Canadian Journal of Forest Research, Vol. 46, No. 10, 2016, p. 1247-1254.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Exploring the linkages between multifunctional forestry goals and the legacy of spruce plantations in Scotland

    AU - Nijnik, Maria

    AU - Nijnik, Albert

    AU - Brown, Iain

    PY - 2016

    Y1 - 2016

    N2 - This paper explores the ecosystem services associated with woodlands, as they are viewed by individuals in Scotland, with the idea to reconcile objectives for multifunctionality with the legacy of past forestry systems that were not designed with multifunctionality in mind. Research follows a semi-qualitative route and applies the Q method to identify and explain a range of attitudes among the general public and forestry-associated stakeholders regarding the functional future of forestry in Scotland. Four distinctive groups of attitudes were identified and key factors influencing the attitudinal diversity were explained. Despite the uncovered attitudinal heterogeneity, all groups of attitudes have strong emphasis on native woodland regeneration and on improvement of aesthetic values of woodlands but differ concerning afforestation. An improved under-standing of what people think provided an indication of their recognition of ecosystem services types and the trade-offs between these, opportunities available, and factors that can hamper forestry development (e.g., concerning the aspiration of increasing Scotland’s forest cover to 25%). Findings suggest that the productivists’ position (for which the economic objectives are important) remains strong in Scotland. Results (compared with those in several other countries) demonstrate comparability between public and stakeholder perspectives in support of the multifunctional forestry, and this has distinct policy relevance and implications for decision-making.

    AB - This paper explores the ecosystem services associated with woodlands, as they are viewed by individuals in Scotland, with the idea to reconcile objectives for multifunctionality with the legacy of past forestry systems that were not designed with multifunctionality in mind. Research follows a semi-qualitative route and applies the Q method to identify and explain a range of attitudes among the general public and forestry-associated stakeholders regarding the functional future of forestry in Scotland. Four distinctive groups of attitudes were identified and key factors influencing the attitudinal diversity were explained. Despite the uncovered attitudinal heterogeneity, all groups of attitudes have strong emphasis on native woodland regeneration and on improvement of aesthetic values of woodlands but differ concerning afforestation. An improved under-standing of what people think provided an indication of their recognition of ecosystem services types and the trade-offs between these, opportunities available, and factors that can hamper forestry development (e.g., concerning the aspiration of increasing Scotland’s forest cover to 25%). Findings suggest that the productivists’ position (for which the economic objectives are important) remains strong in Scotland. Results (compared with those in several other countries) demonstrate comparability between public and stakeholder perspectives in support of the multifunctional forestry, and this has distinct policy relevance and implications for decision-making.

    KW - Attitudinal diversity

    KW - Ecosystem services

    KW - Q method

    KW - Stakeholders

    KW - Woodlands

    U2 - 10.1139/cjfr-2015-0399

    DO - 10.1139/cjfr-2015-0399

    M3 - Article

    VL - 46

    SP - 1247

    EP - 1254

    JO - Canadian Journal of Forest Research

    JF - Canadian Journal of Forest Research

    SN - 0045-5067

    IS - 10

    ER -