Factors influencing nurses' judgements about self neglect cases

W Lauder, R. Ludwick, R. Zeller, J. Winchell

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    12 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    From the perspective of the practising nurse self-neglect may best be understood in terms of a set of complex and often poorly defined clinical problems in which two key clinical issues are ‘how do I judge whether this person has the capacity make decisions about their lifestyle?’ and ‘do we need to treat this person using mental health legislation?’ These are taxing questions as judging if a patient has the capacity to make decisions about their lifestyle choices is difficult for even the most experienced clinicians. Such determinations require nurses to form a judgement as to mental capacity of the patient. We do not know what patient characteristics and in what combination nurses use these when making these judgements. This factorial survey aimed to identify which patient characteristics influenced Registered Nurses’ judgements on decision-making capacity and decisions on the use of interventions which require statutory interventions in cases of self-neglect. Judgements on decision-making capacity were overwhelmingly predicted by information of the patients’ mental health status. Nurses place patients in one of three broad categories of no mental illness, minor mental illness and severe mental illness. This categorization appears to operate as a fast and frugal heuristic indicating that nurses may use mental status as a cognitive screen to work from in judging self-neglect. Although there is a correlation between the severity of mental illness and the capacity for making decisions they are not the same. This study shows the continued work that needs done in educating nurses not only about self-neglect but also about the role a patient’s mental status may have in assessment of problems.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)279-287
    Number of pages9
    JournalJournal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing
    Volume13
    Issue number3
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Jun 2006

    Fingerprint

    Nurses
    Decision Making
    Mentally Ill Persons
    Life Style
    Mental Health
    Legislation
    Health Status

    Keywords

    • Decision making
    • Factorial survey
    • Public health
    • Self-neglect
    • Squalor

    Cite this

    Lauder, W ; Ludwick, R. ; Zeller, R. ; Winchell, J. / Factors influencing nurses' judgements about self neglect cases. In: Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing. 2006 ; Vol. 13, No. 3. pp. 279-287.
    @article{35ec1911a2864e928c05b7ecbcee7c61,
    title = "Factors influencing nurses' judgements about self neglect cases",
    abstract = "From the perspective of the practising nurse self-neglect may best be understood in terms of a set of complex and often poorly defined clinical problems in which two key clinical issues are ‘how do I judge whether this person has the capacity make decisions about their lifestyle?’ and ‘do we need to treat this person using mental health legislation?’ These are taxing questions as judging if a patient has the capacity to make decisions about their lifestyle choices is difficult for even the most experienced clinicians. Such determinations require nurses to form a judgement as to mental capacity of the patient. We do not know what patient characteristics and in what combination nurses use these when making these judgements. This factorial survey aimed to identify which patient characteristics influenced Registered Nurses’ judgements on decision-making capacity and decisions on the use of interventions which require statutory interventions in cases of self-neglect. Judgements on decision-making capacity were overwhelmingly predicted by information of the patients’ mental health status. Nurses place patients in one of three broad categories of no mental illness, minor mental illness and severe mental illness. This categorization appears to operate as a fast and frugal heuristic indicating that nurses may use mental status as a cognitive screen to work from in judging self-neglect. Although there is a correlation between the severity of mental illness and the capacity for making decisions they are not the same. This study shows the continued work that needs done in educating nurses not only about self-neglect but also about the role a patient’s mental status may have in assessment of problems.",
    keywords = "Decision making, Factorial survey, Public health, Self-neglect, Squalor",
    author = "W Lauder and R. Ludwick and R. Zeller and J. Winchell",
    note = "dc.publisher: Wiley-Blackwell This study extends Lauder's social constructionist theory of self-neglect by exploring how nurses in USA make intervention decisions. Identified a core fast and frugal heuristic which suggests nurses do not make full use of all information in a given situation. Part of a methodological programme by this international research group. Research Group 2 - Psychosocial Determinants of Wellbeing in Community & Healthcare",
    year = "2006",
    month = "6",
    doi = "10.1111/j.1365-2850.2006.00948.x",
    language = "English",
    volume = "13",
    pages = "279--287",
    journal = "Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing",
    issn = "1351-0126",
    publisher = "Wiley",
    number = "3",

    }

    Factors influencing nurses' judgements about self neglect cases. / Lauder, W; Ludwick, R.; Zeller, R.; Winchell, J.

    In: Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, Vol. 13, No. 3, 06.2006, p. 279-287.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Factors influencing nurses' judgements about self neglect cases

    AU - Lauder, W

    AU - Ludwick, R.

    AU - Zeller, R.

    AU - Winchell, J.

    N1 - dc.publisher: Wiley-Blackwell This study extends Lauder's social constructionist theory of self-neglect by exploring how nurses in USA make intervention decisions. Identified a core fast and frugal heuristic which suggests nurses do not make full use of all information in a given situation. Part of a methodological programme by this international research group. Research Group 2 - Psychosocial Determinants of Wellbeing in Community & Healthcare

    PY - 2006/6

    Y1 - 2006/6

    N2 - From the perspective of the practising nurse self-neglect may best be understood in terms of a set of complex and often poorly defined clinical problems in which two key clinical issues are ‘how do I judge whether this person has the capacity make decisions about their lifestyle?’ and ‘do we need to treat this person using mental health legislation?’ These are taxing questions as judging if a patient has the capacity to make decisions about their lifestyle choices is difficult for even the most experienced clinicians. Such determinations require nurses to form a judgement as to mental capacity of the patient. We do not know what patient characteristics and in what combination nurses use these when making these judgements. This factorial survey aimed to identify which patient characteristics influenced Registered Nurses’ judgements on decision-making capacity and decisions on the use of interventions which require statutory interventions in cases of self-neglect. Judgements on decision-making capacity were overwhelmingly predicted by information of the patients’ mental health status. Nurses place patients in one of three broad categories of no mental illness, minor mental illness and severe mental illness. This categorization appears to operate as a fast and frugal heuristic indicating that nurses may use mental status as a cognitive screen to work from in judging self-neglect. Although there is a correlation between the severity of mental illness and the capacity for making decisions they are not the same. This study shows the continued work that needs done in educating nurses not only about self-neglect but also about the role a patient’s mental status may have in assessment of problems.

    AB - From the perspective of the practising nurse self-neglect may best be understood in terms of a set of complex and often poorly defined clinical problems in which two key clinical issues are ‘how do I judge whether this person has the capacity make decisions about their lifestyle?’ and ‘do we need to treat this person using mental health legislation?’ These are taxing questions as judging if a patient has the capacity to make decisions about their lifestyle choices is difficult for even the most experienced clinicians. Such determinations require nurses to form a judgement as to mental capacity of the patient. We do not know what patient characteristics and in what combination nurses use these when making these judgements. This factorial survey aimed to identify which patient characteristics influenced Registered Nurses’ judgements on decision-making capacity and decisions on the use of interventions which require statutory interventions in cases of self-neglect. Judgements on decision-making capacity were overwhelmingly predicted by information of the patients’ mental health status. Nurses place patients in one of three broad categories of no mental illness, minor mental illness and severe mental illness. This categorization appears to operate as a fast and frugal heuristic indicating that nurses may use mental status as a cognitive screen to work from in judging self-neglect. Although there is a correlation between the severity of mental illness and the capacity for making decisions they are not the same. This study shows the continued work that needs done in educating nurses not only about self-neglect but also about the role a patient’s mental status may have in assessment of problems.

    KW - Decision making

    KW - Factorial survey

    KW - Public health

    KW - Self-neglect

    KW - Squalor

    U2 - 10.1111/j.1365-2850.2006.00948.x

    DO - 10.1111/j.1365-2850.2006.00948.x

    M3 - Article

    VL - 13

    SP - 279

    EP - 287

    JO - Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing

    JF - Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing

    SN - 1351-0126

    IS - 3

    ER -