FiCTION Filling Children’s Teeth

Indicated or Not? Integrating Qualitative Research

Jason Rutter, Kathryn Cunningham, Richard Holmes, Anne Maguire, Nicola Innes, Gail Douglas, Jan Clarkson, Ruth Freeman, Elaine McColl, Mark Robertson, Zoe Marshman

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Objectives: The use of qualitative research in randomised controlled trials (RCTs) is increasing. Qualitative research adds value by exploring perspectives of clinicians and patients, providing insight into how the intervention was delivered, helping to explain quantitative findings and assisting with dissemination and implementation. Filling Children’s Teeth: Indicated or Not? FiCTION Trial is investigating the clinical and cost-effectiveness of 3 different approaches to managing caries in primary teeth with a qualitative component planned.

Methods: The qualitative component will compare the 3 approaches for:
1) the acceptability and associated experiences of children and parents. Specifically, to explore children and parents experiences and how caries management impacts upon their daily lives, the value placed on the management of caries by children/parents and to identify ways to improve the acceptability in future.
2) dentists’ and dental team member’s preferences. Specifically, to explore the experiences of dentists and dental team members in providing the 3 treatment strategies, whether previous experience has an impact on their preferences, to identify training needs in delivering the treatment strategies and how dentist’s experiences of the trial will shape how they manage children with caries in future.
The qualitative research will be guided by the Theoretical Domains Framework. Semi-structured interviews will be conducted with a purposive sample of children with their parents and dental team members across the UK. Child-centred participatory activities will be employed for interviews with children. Recruitment will continue until data saturation is reached. Both inductive and deductive approaches to analysis will be undertaken.

Results: As this is a protocol for ongoing research, there are no results reported.

Conclusions: The qualitative results will be used alongside the findings on the clinical and cost-effectiveness. Understanding the experience of participants and providers in RCTs is beneficial for knowledge translation and insights into patient’s preferences for treatment.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 23 Mar 2017
EventIADR General Session: 95th General Session & Exhibition of the IADR - Moscone West Convention Center, San Francisco, United States
Duration: 22 Mar 201725 Mar 2017
http://www.iadr.org/IADR/Meetings/2017IAGS (Link to IADR website)

Conference

ConferenceIADR General Session
CountryUnited States
CitySan Francisco
Period22/03/1725/03/17
Internet address

Fingerprint

Qualitative Research
Tooth
Parents
Dentists
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Randomized Controlled Trials
Interviews
Translational Medical Research
Deciduous Tooth
Patient Preference
Therapeutics
Research

Keywords

  • Caries
  • Children
  • Trials
  • Qualitative

Cite this

Rutter, J., Cunningham, K., Holmes, R., Maguire, A., Innes, N., Douglas, G., ... Marshman, Z. (2017). FiCTION Filling Children’s Teeth: Indicated or Not? Integrating Qualitative Research. Paper presented at IADR General Session, San Francisco, United States.
Rutter, Jason ; Cunningham, Kathryn ; Holmes, Richard ; Maguire, Anne ; Innes, Nicola ; Douglas, Gail ; Clarkson, Jan ; Freeman, Ruth ; McColl, Elaine ; Robertson, Mark ; Marshman, Zoe. / FiCTION Filling Children’s Teeth : Indicated or Not? Integrating Qualitative Research. Paper presented at IADR General Session, San Francisco, United States.
@conference{2a50fe44f08e49bb878f449f3069aad6,
title = "FiCTION Filling Children’s Teeth: Indicated or Not? Integrating Qualitative Research",
abstract = "Objectives: The use of qualitative research in randomised controlled trials (RCTs) is increasing. Qualitative research adds value by exploring perspectives of clinicians and patients, providing insight into how the intervention was delivered, helping to explain quantitative findings and assisting with dissemination and implementation. Filling Children’s Teeth: Indicated or Not? FiCTION Trial is investigating the clinical and cost-effectiveness of 3 different approaches to managing caries in primary teeth with a qualitative component planned.Methods: The qualitative component will compare the 3 approaches for:1) the acceptability and associated experiences of children and parents. Specifically, to explore children and parents experiences and how caries management impacts upon their daily lives, the value placed on the management of caries by children/parents and to identify ways to improve the acceptability in future.2) dentists’ and dental team member’s preferences. Specifically, to explore the experiences of dentists and dental team members in providing the 3 treatment strategies, whether previous experience has an impact on their preferences, to identify training needs in delivering the treatment strategies and how dentist’s experiences of the trial will shape how they manage children with caries in future.The qualitative research will be guided by the Theoretical Domains Framework. Semi-structured interviews will be conducted with a purposive sample of children with their parents and dental team members across the UK. Child-centred participatory activities will be employed for interviews with children. Recruitment will continue until data saturation is reached. Both inductive and deductive approaches to analysis will be undertaken.Results: As this is a protocol for ongoing research, there are no results reported.Conclusions: The qualitative results will be used alongside the findings on the clinical and cost-effectiveness. Understanding the experience of participants and providers in RCTs is beneficial for knowledge translation and insights into patient’s preferences for treatment.",
keywords = "Caries, Children, Trials, Qualitative",
author = "Jason Rutter and Kathryn Cunningham and Richard Holmes and Anne Maguire and Nicola Innes and Gail Douglas and Jan Clarkson and Ruth Freeman and Elaine McColl and Mark Robertson and Zoe Marshman",
note = "This report is independent research commissioned and funded by the National Institute for Health Research, Health Technology Assessment Programme 07/44/03. Trial number: ISRCTN 77044005. ; IADR General Session : 95th General Session & Exhibition of the IADR ; Conference date: 22-03-2017 Through 25-03-2017",
year = "2017",
month = "3",
day = "23",
language = "English",
url = "http://www.iadr.org/IADR/Meetings/2017IAGS",

}

Rutter, J, Cunningham, K, Holmes, R, Maguire, A, Innes, N, Douglas, G, Clarkson, J, Freeman, R, McColl, E, Robertson, M & Marshman, Z 2017, 'FiCTION Filling Children’s Teeth: Indicated or Not? Integrating Qualitative Research' Paper presented at IADR General Session, San Francisco, United States, 22/03/17 - 25/03/17, .

FiCTION Filling Children’s Teeth : Indicated or Not? Integrating Qualitative Research. / Rutter, Jason; Cunningham, Kathryn; Holmes, Richard ; Maguire, Anne ; Innes, Nicola; Douglas, Gail ; Clarkson, Jan; Freeman, Ruth; McColl, Elaine; Robertson, Mark; Marshman, Zoe.

2017. Paper presented at IADR General Session, San Francisco, United States.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - FiCTION Filling Children’s Teeth

T2 - Indicated or Not? Integrating Qualitative Research

AU - Rutter, Jason

AU - Cunningham, Kathryn

AU - Holmes, Richard

AU - Maguire, Anne

AU - Innes, Nicola

AU - Douglas, Gail

AU - Clarkson, Jan

AU - Freeman, Ruth

AU - McColl, Elaine

AU - Robertson, Mark

AU - Marshman, Zoe

N1 - This report is independent research commissioned and funded by the National Institute for Health Research, Health Technology Assessment Programme 07/44/03. Trial number: ISRCTN 77044005.

PY - 2017/3/23

Y1 - 2017/3/23

N2 - Objectives: The use of qualitative research in randomised controlled trials (RCTs) is increasing. Qualitative research adds value by exploring perspectives of clinicians and patients, providing insight into how the intervention was delivered, helping to explain quantitative findings and assisting with dissemination and implementation. Filling Children’s Teeth: Indicated or Not? FiCTION Trial is investigating the clinical and cost-effectiveness of 3 different approaches to managing caries in primary teeth with a qualitative component planned.Methods: The qualitative component will compare the 3 approaches for:1) the acceptability and associated experiences of children and parents. Specifically, to explore children and parents experiences and how caries management impacts upon their daily lives, the value placed on the management of caries by children/parents and to identify ways to improve the acceptability in future.2) dentists’ and dental team member’s preferences. Specifically, to explore the experiences of dentists and dental team members in providing the 3 treatment strategies, whether previous experience has an impact on their preferences, to identify training needs in delivering the treatment strategies and how dentist’s experiences of the trial will shape how they manage children with caries in future.The qualitative research will be guided by the Theoretical Domains Framework. Semi-structured interviews will be conducted with a purposive sample of children with their parents and dental team members across the UK. Child-centred participatory activities will be employed for interviews with children. Recruitment will continue until data saturation is reached. Both inductive and deductive approaches to analysis will be undertaken.Results: As this is a protocol for ongoing research, there are no results reported.Conclusions: The qualitative results will be used alongside the findings on the clinical and cost-effectiveness. Understanding the experience of participants and providers in RCTs is beneficial for knowledge translation and insights into patient’s preferences for treatment.

AB - Objectives: The use of qualitative research in randomised controlled trials (RCTs) is increasing. Qualitative research adds value by exploring perspectives of clinicians and patients, providing insight into how the intervention was delivered, helping to explain quantitative findings and assisting with dissemination and implementation. Filling Children’s Teeth: Indicated or Not? FiCTION Trial is investigating the clinical and cost-effectiveness of 3 different approaches to managing caries in primary teeth with a qualitative component planned.Methods: The qualitative component will compare the 3 approaches for:1) the acceptability and associated experiences of children and parents. Specifically, to explore children and parents experiences and how caries management impacts upon their daily lives, the value placed on the management of caries by children/parents and to identify ways to improve the acceptability in future.2) dentists’ and dental team member’s preferences. Specifically, to explore the experiences of dentists and dental team members in providing the 3 treatment strategies, whether previous experience has an impact on their preferences, to identify training needs in delivering the treatment strategies and how dentist’s experiences of the trial will shape how they manage children with caries in future.The qualitative research will be guided by the Theoretical Domains Framework. Semi-structured interviews will be conducted with a purposive sample of children with their parents and dental team members across the UK. Child-centred participatory activities will be employed for interviews with children. Recruitment will continue until data saturation is reached. Both inductive and deductive approaches to analysis will be undertaken.Results: As this is a protocol for ongoing research, there are no results reported.Conclusions: The qualitative results will be used alongside the findings on the clinical and cost-effectiveness. Understanding the experience of participants and providers in RCTs is beneficial for knowledge translation and insights into patient’s preferences for treatment.

KW - Caries

KW - Children

KW - Trials

KW - Qualitative

UR - https://iadr2017.zerista.com/event?owner=other&owner_id=1447526&terms=fiction+filling+children%27s+teeth&event_page=1&event_order=start

M3 - Paper

ER -

Rutter J, Cunningham K, Holmes R, Maguire A, Innes N, Douglas G et al. FiCTION Filling Children’s Teeth: Indicated or Not? Integrating Qualitative Research. 2017. Paper presented at IADR General Session, San Francisco, United States.