Hatescape? A relational geography of disability hate crime, exclusion and belonging in the city

Edward Hall (Lead / Corresponding author), Ellie Bates

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Disabled people experience significant social discrimination and spatial exclusion in their everyday lives in the city. In recent years, discriminatory acts have increasingly been labelled as ‘hate crimes’. We argue that hate crime’s association with harassment and violence has obscured the more common prejudicial attitudes and actions, which create anxiety and fear. Further, the paper seeks to shift the disability hate crime discourse from its present focus on individual victimisation, to the micro and local spaces, social relations and wider socio-political contexts, within which these acts emerge. We set out a critique of hate crime discourse, offering instead a relational interpretation of people’s experiences of place, drawing on aspects of non-representational theory. We argue that everyday movements through the city and encounters with others, produce senses of anxiety and precarity, as well as experiences of belonging, in the context of structural disablist attitudes. The paper draws on a collaborative research project in a city centre in Scotland, using a methodology of walking interviews and focus groups. The findings are presented in four themes, illustrated by qualitative GIS mapping: i) recorded and experienced hate crime and harassment in the city; ii) routes into and mobility within the city; iii) spaces of fear and anxiety, and inclusion and welcome; and iv) encounters and relations with others. We conclude by arguing that a relational approach, examining the dynamic unfolding or emergence of people’s embodied and emotional experiences and encounters (both negative and positive), in a range of contexts, is a significant contribution to the hate crime debate.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)100-110
Number of pages11
JournalGeoforum
Volume101
Early online date9 Mar 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2019

Fingerprint

hate crime
exclusion
disability
geography
anxiety
experience
social discrimination
discourse
city center
victimization
Social Relations
everyday life
Geographical Information System
research project
inclusion
violence
interpretation
present
methodology
interview

Keywords

  • Belonging
  • Disability
  • Hate crime
  • Learning disability
  • Relational
  • Social exclusion

Cite this

@article{d0a9642db9a844dc83f7ff6a0feb693d,
title = "Hatescape? A relational geography of disability hate crime, exclusion and belonging in the city",
abstract = "Disabled people experience significant social discrimination and spatial exclusion in their everyday lives in the city. In recent years, discriminatory acts have increasingly been labelled as ‘hate crimes’. We argue that hate crime’s association with harassment and violence has obscured the more common prejudicial attitudes and actions, which create anxiety and fear. Further, the paper seeks to shift the disability hate crime discourse from its present focus on individual victimisation, to the micro and local spaces, social relations and wider socio-political contexts, within which these acts emerge. We set out a critique of hate crime discourse, offering instead a relational interpretation of people’s experiences of place, drawing on aspects of non-representational theory. We argue that everyday movements through the city and encounters with others, produce senses of anxiety and precarity, as well as experiences of belonging, in the context of structural disablist attitudes. The paper draws on a collaborative research project in a city centre in Scotland, using a methodology of walking interviews and focus groups. The findings are presented in four themes, illustrated by qualitative GIS mapping: i) recorded and experienced hate crime and harassment in the city; ii) routes into and mobility within the city; iii) spaces of fear and anxiety, and inclusion and welcome; and iv) encounters and relations with others. We conclude by arguing that a relational approach, examining the dynamic unfolding or emergence of people’s embodied and emotional experiences and encounters (both negative and positive), in a range of contexts, is a significant contribution to the hate crime debate.",
keywords = "Belonging, Disability, Hate crime, Learning disability, Relational, Social exclusion",
author = "Edward Hall and Ellie Bates",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.geoforum.2019.02.024",
language = "English",
volume = "101",
pages = "100--110",
journal = "Geoforum",
issn = "0016-7185",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Hatescape? A relational geography of disability hate crime, exclusion and belonging in the city. / Hall, Edward (Lead / Corresponding author); Bates, Ellie.

In: Geoforum, Vol. 101, 05.2019, p. 100-110.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Hatescape? A relational geography of disability hate crime, exclusion and belonging in the city

AU - Hall, Edward

AU - Bates, Ellie

PY - 2019/5

Y1 - 2019/5

N2 - Disabled people experience significant social discrimination and spatial exclusion in their everyday lives in the city. In recent years, discriminatory acts have increasingly been labelled as ‘hate crimes’. We argue that hate crime’s association with harassment and violence has obscured the more common prejudicial attitudes and actions, which create anxiety and fear. Further, the paper seeks to shift the disability hate crime discourse from its present focus on individual victimisation, to the micro and local spaces, social relations and wider socio-political contexts, within which these acts emerge. We set out a critique of hate crime discourse, offering instead a relational interpretation of people’s experiences of place, drawing on aspects of non-representational theory. We argue that everyday movements through the city and encounters with others, produce senses of anxiety and precarity, as well as experiences of belonging, in the context of structural disablist attitudes. The paper draws on a collaborative research project in a city centre in Scotland, using a methodology of walking interviews and focus groups. The findings are presented in four themes, illustrated by qualitative GIS mapping: i) recorded and experienced hate crime and harassment in the city; ii) routes into and mobility within the city; iii) spaces of fear and anxiety, and inclusion and welcome; and iv) encounters and relations with others. We conclude by arguing that a relational approach, examining the dynamic unfolding or emergence of people’s embodied and emotional experiences and encounters (both negative and positive), in a range of contexts, is a significant contribution to the hate crime debate.

AB - Disabled people experience significant social discrimination and spatial exclusion in their everyday lives in the city. In recent years, discriminatory acts have increasingly been labelled as ‘hate crimes’. We argue that hate crime’s association with harassment and violence has obscured the more common prejudicial attitudes and actions, which create anxiety and fear. Further, the paper seeks to shift the disability hate crime discourse from its present focus on individual victimisation, to the micro and local spaces, social relations and wider socio-political contexts, within which these acts emerge. We set out a critique of hate crime discourse, offering instead a relational interpretation of people’s experiences of place, drawing on aspects of non-representational theory. We argue that everyday movements through the city and encounters with others, produce senses of anxiety and precarity, as well as experiences of belonging, in the context of structural disablist attitudes. The paper draws on a collaborative research project in a city centre in Scotland, using a methodology of walking interviews and focus groups. The findings are presented in four themes, illustrated by qualitative GIS mapping: i) recorded and experienced hate crime and harassment in the city; ii) routes into and mobility within the city; iii) spaces of fear and anxiety, and inclusion and welcome; and iv) encounters and relations with others. We conclude by arguing that a relational approach, examining the dynamic unfolding or emergence of people’s embodied and emotional experiences and encounters (both negative and positive), in a range of contexts, is a significant contribution to the hate crime debate.

KW - Belonging

KW - Disability

KW - Hate crime

KW - Learning disability

KW - Relational

KW - Social exclusion

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85062570574&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.geoforum.2019.02.024

DO - 10.1016/j.geoforum.2019.02.024

M3 - Article

VL - 101

SP - 100

EP - 110

JO - Geoforum

JF - Geoforum

SN - 0016-7185

ER -