Health and wellbeing and wider achievement

An analysis of teachers’ practices and learners’ experiences in Scottish secondary schools

Malcolm Thorburn, Donna Dey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)
160 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

There is a heightened policy expectation in Scotland that a greater curriculum emphasis on health and wellbeing (HWB) will positively contribute to learners’ reflections on their wider achievements. However, in terms of policy enactment, relatively little is known on the interrelationship between HWB and learners’ wider achievements. To address this limitation, data was gathered from four secondary schools in East central Scotland via an online survey, eight learner group interviews and eight teacher interviews. Findings indicated that learners’ grasp of how HWB connects with their broader achievements was generally vague and imprecise. Despite many areas of positive self-reporting learners’ progress was hampered by their lack of confidence in speaking in front of others and modest sense of school belonging. In addition, the practice gains anticipated through making HWB a more central feature of all learners’ broad general education were constrained by teachers’ variable level of engagement with their new roles and responsibilities, and by logistical problems in recording learners’ achievements. Further research which collects more extensive data on the weaknesses identified and on understanding learners’ HWB experiences better would contribute to a more insightful analysis of how schools enact policy and record achievement.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)24-34
Number of pages11
JournalStudies in Educational Evaluation
Volume52
Early online date15 Dec 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Mar 2017

Fingerprint

secondary school
teacher
health
experience
school policy
general education
interview
online survey
recording
speaking
confidence
curriculum
responsibility
lack
school
Group

Keywords

  • Health and wellbeing
  • Learners experiences
  • Learning and teaching
  • Policy enactment
  • Professional practice
  • Wider achievement

Cite this

@article{8cfae412e8a646bf83347b6a0f9a03c4,
title = "Health and wellbeing and wider achievement: An analysis of teachers’ practices and learners’ experiences in Scottish secondary schools",
abstract = "There is a heightened policy expectation in Scotland that a greater curriculum emphasis on health and wellbeing (HWB) will positively contribute to learners’ reflections on their wider achievements. However, in terms of policy enactment, relatively little is known on the interrelationship between HWB and learners’ wider achievements. To address this limitation, data was gathered from four secondary schools in East central Scotland via an online survey, eight learner group interviews and eight teacher interviews. Findings indicated that learners’ grasp of how HWB connects with their broader achievements was generally vague and imprecise. Despite many areas of positive self-reporting learners’ progress was hampered by their lack of confidence in speaking in front of others and modest sense of school belonging. In addition, the practice gains anticipated through making HWB a more central feature of all learners’ broad general education were constrained by teachers’ variable level of engagement with their new roles and responsibilities, and by logistical problems in recording learners’ achievements. Further research which collects more extensive data on the weaknesses identified and on understanding learners’ HWB experiences better would contribute to a more insightful analysis of how schools enact policy and record achievement.",
keywords = "Health and wellbeing, Learners experiences, Learning and teaching, Policy enactment, Professional practice, Wider achievement",
author = "Malcolm Thorburn and Donna Dey",
note = "Funding: none.",
year = "2017",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.stueduc.2016.11.004",
language = "English",
volume = "52",
pages = "24--34",
journal = "Studies in Educational Evaluation",
issn = "0191-491X",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Health and wellbeing and wider achievement

T2 - An analysis of teachers’ practices and learners’ experiences in Scottish secondary schools

AU - Thorburn, Malcolm

AU - Dey, Donna

N1 - Funding: none.

PY - 2017/3/1

Y1 - 2017/3/1

N2 - There is a heightened policy expectation in Scotland that a greater curriculum emphasis on health and wellbeing (HWB) will positively contribute to learners’ reflections on their wider achievements. However, in terms of policy enactment, relatively little is known on the interrelationship between HWB and learners’ wider achievements. To address this limitation, data was gathered from four secondary schools in East central Scotland via an online survey, eight learner group interviews and eight teacher interviews. Findings indicated that learners’ grasp of how HWB connects with their broader achievements was generally vague and imprecise. Despite many areas of positive self-reporting learners’ progress was hampered by their lack of confidence in speaking in front of others and modest sense of school belonging. In addition, the practice gains anticipated through making HWB a more central feature of all learners’ broad general education were constrained by teachers’ variable level of engagement with their new roles and responsibilities, and by logistical problems in recording learners’ achievements. Further research which collects more extensive data on the weaknesses identified and on understanding learners’ HWB experiences better would contribute to a more insightful analysis of how schools enact policy and record achievement.

AB - There is a heightened policy expectation in Scotland that a greater curriculum emphasis on health and wellbeing (HWB) will positively contribute to learners’ reflections on their wider achievements. However, in terms of policy enactment, relatively little is known on the interrelationship between HWB and learners’ wider achievements. To address this limitation, data was gathered from four secondary schools in East central Scotland via an online survey, eight learner group interviews and eight teacher interviews. Findings indicated that learners’ grasp of how HWB connects with their broader achievements was generally vague and imprecise. Despite many areas of positive self-reporting learners’ progress was hampered by their lack of confidence in speaking in front of others and modest sense of school belonging. In addition, the practice gains anticipated through making HWB a more central feature of all learners’ broad general education were constrained by teachers’ variable level of engagement with their new roles and responsibilities, and by logistical problems in recording learners’ achievements. Further research which collects more extensive data on the weaknesses identified and on understanding learners’ HWB experiences better would contribute to a more insightful analysis of how schools enact policy and record achievement.

KW - Health and wellbeing

KW - Learners experiences

KW - Learning and teaching

KW - Policy enactment

KW - Professional practice

KW - Wider achievement

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85008418018&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.stueduc.2016.11.004

DO - 10.1016/j.stueduc.2016.11.004

M3 - Article

VL - 52

SP - 24

EP - 34

JO - Studies in Educational Evaluation

JF - Studies in Educational Evaluation

SN - 0191-491X

ER -