Improving HSPF modeling accuracy from FTABLES: case study for the illinois river basin

Yanquing Lian, I-Chi Chan, Hua Xie, Misganaw Demissie

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    5 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    An application of the Hydrologic Simulation Program-FORTRAN (HSPF) model was developed for the entire Illinois River basin. During the simulation period from 1985 to 1995, simulated monthly and annual flows correlated well with observed data. However, its performance for daily flows in the lower portion of the basin was not satisfactory because of the complicated hydraulic condition of the Illinois River. In order to compensate the weakness of HSPF for flow routing, we have coupled a calibrated hydraulic model, one-dimensional unsteady flow through a full network of open channels (UNET), to improve flow routing accuracy and the overall performance of the HSPF model. In this study we intended to test how HSPF modeling accuracy can be improved from modifying function tables (FTABLES). We proposed four alternative sets of FTABLES: three (Sets B, C, and D) were based on Manning's equation and one (Set E) used the flow-stage relationship. Simulations from these four alternatives were compared to the default FTABLES (Set A) and the coupled HSPF-UNET model. A comparison showed that improving the estimation on hydraulic gradients from flood frequency analysis (Set B) or improving the computation of reach geometry from surveyed cross sections (Set C) could only improve model accuracy. However, much better modeling accuracy can be obtained by improving both reach geometry and hydraulic gradients (Set D). Using the stage-discharge relationships simulated from a hydraulic model (Set E) also provided better results. The proposed methods have been successfully applied to watershed modeling with HSPF in the Illinois River basin. This study demonstrated that better HSPF modeling accuracy can be achieved with minimum effort from representative channel geometries and hydraulic gradients.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)642-650
    Number of pages9
    JournalJournal of Hydrologic Engineering
    Volume15
    Issue number8
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2010

    Fingerprint

    Catchments
    river basin
    Rivers
    Hydraulics
    Hydraulic models
    modeling
    simulation
    hydraulics
    Geometry
    Unsteady flow
    Watersheds
    Discharge (fluid mechanics)
    routing
    geometry
    stage-discharge relationship
    programme
    flood frequency
    unsteady flow
    frequency analysis
    cross section

    Cite this

    Lian, Yanquing ; Chan, I-Chi ; Xie, Hua ; Demissie, Misganaw. / Improving HSPF modeling accuracy from FTABLES : case study for the illinois river basin. In: Journal of Hydrologic Engineering. 2010 ; Vol. 15, No. 8. pp. 642-650.
    @article{d68e49e332f2441d99b4de58e98f4d26,
    title = "Improving HSPF modeling accuracy from FTABLES: case study for the illinois river basin",
    abstract = "An application of the Hydrologic Simulation Program-FORTRAN (HSPF) model was developed for the entire Illinois River basin. During the simulation period from 1985 to 1995, simulated monthly and annual flows correlated well with observed data. However, its performance for daily flows in the lower portion of the basin was not satisfactory because of the complicated hydraulic condition of the Illinois River. In order to compensate the weakness of HSPF for flow routing, we have coupled a calibrated hydraulic model, one-dimensional unsteady flow through a full network of open channels (UNET), to improve flow routing accuracy and the overall performance of the HSPF model. In this study we intended to test how HSPF modeling accuracy can be improved from modifying function tables (FTABLES). We proposed four alternative sets of FTABLES: three (Sets B, C, and D) were based on Manning's equation and one (Set E) used the flow-stage relationship. Simulations from these four alternatives were compared to the default FTABLES (Set A) and the coupled HSPF-UNET model. A comparison showed that improving the estimation on hydraulic gradients from flood frequency analysis (Set B) or improving the computation of reach geometry from surveyed cross sections (Set C) could only improve model accuracy. However, much better modeling accuracy can be obtained by improving both reach geometry and hydraulic gradients (Set D). Using the stage-discharge relationships simulated from a hydraulic model (Set E) also provided better results. The proposed methods have been successfully applied to watershed modeling with HSPF in the Illinois River basin. This study demonstrated that better HSPF modeling accuracy can be achieved with minimum effort from representative channel geometries and hydraulic gradients.",
    author = "Yanquing Lian and I-Chi Chan and Hua Xie and Misganaw Demissie",
    year = "2010",
    month = "8",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0000222",
    language = "English",
    volume = "15",
    pages = "642--650",
    journal = "Journal of Hydrologic Engineering",
    issn = "1084-0699",
    publisher = "American Society of Civil Engineers",
    number = "8",

    }

    Improving HSPF modeling accuracy from FTABLES : case study for the illinois river basin. / Lian, Yanquing; Chan, I-Chi; Xie, Hua; Demissie, Misganaw.

    In: Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, Vol. 15, No. 8, 01.08.2010, p. 642-650.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Improving HSPF modeling accuracy from FTABLES

    T2 - case study for the illinois river basin

    AU - Lian, Yanquing

    AU - Chan, I-Chi

    AU - Xie, Hua

    AU - Demissie, Misganaw

    PY - 2010/8/1

    Y1 - 2010/8/1

    N2 - An application of the Hydrologic Simulation Program-FORTRAN (HSPF) model was developed for the entire Illinois River basin. During the simulation period from 1985 to 1995, simulated monthly and annual flows correlated well with observed data. However, its performance for daily flows in the lower portion of the basin was not satisfactory because of the complicated hydraulic condition of the Illinois River. In order to compensate the weakness of HSPF for flow routing, we have coupled a calibrated hydraulic model, one-dimensional unsteady flow through a full network of open channels (UNET), to improve flow routing accuracy and the overall performance of the HSPF model. In this study we intended to test how HSPF modeling accuracy can be improved from modifying function tables (FTABLES). We proposed four alternative sets of FTABLES: three (Sets B, C, and D) were based on Manning's equation and one (Set E) used the flow-stage relationship. Simulations from these four alternatives were compared to the default FTABLES (Set A) and the coupled HSPF-UNET model. A comparison showed that improving the estimation on hydraulic gradients from flood frequency analysis (Set B) or improving the computation of reach geometry from surveyed cross sections (Set C) could only improve model accuracy. However, much better modeling accuracy can be obtained by improving both reach geometry and hydraulic gradients (Set D). Using the stage-discharge relationships simulated from a hydraulic model (Set E) also provided better results. The proposed methods have been successfully applied to watershed modeling with HSPF in the Illinois River basin. This study demonstrated that better HSPF modeling accuracy can be achieved with minimum effort from representative channel geometries and hydraulic gradients.

    AB - An application of the Hydrologic Simulation Program-FORTRAN (HSPF) model was developed for the entire Illinois River basin. During the simulation period from 1985 to 1995, simulated monthly and annual flows correlated well with observed data. However, its performance for daily flows in the lower portion of the basin was not satisfactory because of the complicated hydraulic condition of the Illinois River. In order to compensate the weakness of HSPF for flow routing, we have coupled a calibrated hydraulic model, one-dimensional unsteady flow through a full network of open channels (UNET), to improve flow routing accuracy and the overall performance of the HSPF model. In this study we intended to test how HSPF modeling accuracy can be improved from modifying function tables (FTABLES). We proposed four alternative sets of FTABLES: three (Sets B, C, and D) were based on Manning's equation and one (Set E) used the flow-stage relationship. Simulations from these four alternatives were compared to the default FTABLES (Set A) and the coupled HSPF-UNET model. A comparison showed that improving the estimation on hydraulic gradients from flood frequency analysis (Set B) or improving the computation of reach geometry from surveyed cross sections (Set C) could only improve model accuracy. However, much better modeling accuracy can be obtained by improving both reach geometry and hydraulic gradients (Set D). Using the stage-discharge relationships simulated from a hydraulic model (Set E) also provided better results. The proposed methods have been successfully applied to watershed modeling with HSPF in the Illinois River basin. This study demonstrated that better HSPF modeling accuracy can be achieved with minimum effort from representative channel geometries and hydraulic gradients.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77955605961&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0000222

    DO - 10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0000222

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:77955605961

    VL - 15

    SP - 642

    EP - 650

    JO - Journal of Hydrologic Engineering

    JF - Journal of Hydrologic Engineering

    SN - 1084-0699

    IS - 8

    ER -