Improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth

a review of reviews

Alison McFadden, Joan Cameron, Linda McSwiggan, Caroline Hollins-Martin, Lindsay Siebelt, Anna Gavine, Elaine Lee

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Introduction
We conducted a systematic review of reviews to synthesise evidence relating to improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth.

Material and Methods
Publications were eligible for inclusion if they used a structured approach (i.e. had an explicit search strategy and defined inclusion/exclusion criteria) and included primary studies related to parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth of a single fetus. Searches of 13 electronic databases and the websites of SANDS and the International Stillbirth Alliance were conducted in September 2016. Two reviewers screened records independently. Reviews were critically appraised using the ROBIS tool and data relevant to care and support following stillbirth were extracted by one reviewer and checked by a second reviewer.

Results
The search produced 10,278 original records and 10,198 were excluded. The full texts of 82 papers were screened (two titles were unobtainable) and 17 reviews were included. Three reviews included health care staff as well as parent participants. Four of the reviews included qualitative studies only, three included controlled trials only and 10 included a range qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods studies. The included studies in the reviews were predominantly from high income countries with only one study from a low income country.
Three key themes reported in the included reviews were: general experiences of care and support for bereaved parents; choices and decision-making; interactions with healthcare professionals, and the effectiveness of specific interventions. While there were mixed experiences of care and support many women felt unsupported and ignored and would have liked more emotional support, support that was tailored to their individual needs, and continuity of care especially between hospital and community.
In terms of decision-making the most common theme was about the option for parents to have contact (seeing and holding) with their baby and memory-making. Other choices related to options for the birth, such as timing of induction and pain relief, post-mortem, and burial. Parents appreciated clear, sensitive information about options, presented in more than one format, with time for both parents to process the information. There was evidence that interactions with health professionals have a memorable impact on parents. Positive behaviours included staying with parents, supporting them to express concerns, treating babies as if they are alive, and honest and clear communication. There was clear need for ongoing and consistent training for health professionals to improve support offered.
Generally, there was a lack of robust evidence examining effectiveness of interventions. When trial evidence was available, e.g. for counselling interventions, results were mixed. More promising interventions appear to be those with multiple components that simultaneously target psychological, social and practical issues.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 8 Jun 2018
EventInternational Conference on Stillbirth, SIDS and Baby Survival - Technology and Innovation Centre (TIC), University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, United Kingdom
Duration: 7 Jun 20189 Jun 2018
https://ispid-isa.org/2018#.W3vAos5Kipo

Conference

ConferenceInternational Conference on Stillbirth, SIDS and Baby Survival
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityGlasgow
Period7/06/189/06/18
Internet address

Fingerprint

Stillbirth
Parents
Decision Making
Delivery of Health Care
Burial
Continuity of Patient Care
Health
Publications
Counseling
Fetus
Communication
Parturition
Databases
Psychology
Pain

Cite this

McFadden, A., Cameron, J., McSwiggan, L., Hollins-Martin, C., Siebelt, L., Gavine, A., & Lee, E. (2018). Improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth: a review of reviews. Paper presented at International Conference on Stillbirth, SIDS and Baby Survival, Glasgow, United Kingdom.
McFadden, Alison ; Cameron, Joan ; McSwiggan, Linda ; Hollins-Martin, Caroline ; Siebelt, Lindsay ; Gavine, Anna ; Lee, Elaine. / Improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth : a review of reviews. Paper presented at International Conference on Stillbirth, SIDS and Baby Survival, Glasgow, United Kingdom.
@conference{8d1957865d174d0fa0ba994ab1e946cf,
title = "Improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth: a review of reviews",
abstract = "IntroductionWe conducted a systematic review of reviews to synthesise evidence relating to improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth. Material and Methods Publications were eligible for inclusion if they used a structured approach (i.e. had an explicit search strategy and defined inclusion/exclusion criteria) and included primary studies related to parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth of a single fetus. Searches of 13 electronic databases and the websites of SANDS and the International Stillbirth Alliance were conducted in September 2016. Two reviewers screened records independently. Reviews were critically appraised using the ROBIS tool and data relevant to care and support following stillbirth were extracted by one reviewer and checked by a second reviewer. ResultsThe search produced 10,278 original records and 10,198 were excluded. The full texts of 82 papers were screened (two titles were unobtainable) and 17 reviews were included. Three reviews included health care staff as well as parent participants. Four of the reviews included qualitative studies only, three included controlled trials only and 10 included a range qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods studies. The included studies in the reviews were predominantly from high income countries with only one study from a low income country. Three key themes reported in the included reviews were: general experiences of care and support for bereaved parents; choices and decision-making; interactions with healthcare professionals, and the effectiveness of specific interventions. While there were mixed experiences of care and support many women felt unsupported and ignored and would have liked more emotional support, support that was tailored to their individual needs, and continuity of care especially between hospital and community. In terms of decision-making the most common theme was about the option for parents to have contact (seeing and holding) with their baby and memory-making. Other choices related to options for the birth, such as timing of induction and pain relief, post-mortem, and burial. Parents appreciated clear, sensitive information about options, presented in more than one format, with time for both parents to process the information. There was evidence that interactions with health professionals have a memorable impact on parents. Positive behaviours included staying with parents, supporting them to express concerns, treating babies as if they are alive, and honest and clear communication. There was clear need for ongoing and consistent training for health professionals to improve support offered.Generally, there was a lack of robust evidence examining effectiveness of interventions. When trial evidence was available, e.g. for counselling interventions, results were mixed. More promising interventions appear to be those with multiple components that simultaneously target psychological, social and practical issues.",
author = "Alison McFadden and Joan Cameron and Linda McSwiggan and Caroline Hollins-Martin and Lindsay Siebelt and Anna Gavine and Elaine Lee",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
day = "8",
language = "English",
note = "International Conference on Stillbirth, SIDS and Baby Survival ; Conference date: 07-06-2018 Through 09-06-2018",
url = "https://ispid-isa.org/2018#.W3vAos5Kipo",

}

McFadden, A, Cameron, J, McSwiggan, L, Hollins-Martin, C, Siebelt, L, Gavine, A & Lee, E 2018, 'Improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth: a review of reviews' Paper presented at International Conference on Stillbirth, SIDS and Baby Survival, Glasgow, United Kingdom, 7/06/18 - 9/06/18, .

Improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth : a review of reviews. / McFadden, Alison; Cameron, Joan; McSwiggan, Linda; Hollins-Martin, Caroline; Siebelt, Lindsay; Gavine, Anna; Lee, Elaine.

2018. Paper presented at International Conference on Stillbirth, SIDS and Baby Survival, Glasgow, United Kingdom.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth

T2 - a review of reviews

AU - McFadden, Alison

AU - Cameron, Joan

AU - McSwiggan, Linda

AU - Hollins-Martin, Caroline

AU - Siebelt, Lindsay

AU - Gavine, Anna

AU - Lee, Elaine

PY - 2018/6/8

Y1 - 2018/6/8

N2 - IntroductionWe conducted a systematic review of reviews to synthesise evidence relating to improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth. Material and Methods Publications were eligible for inclusion if they used a structured approach (i.e. had an explicit search strategy and defined inclusion/exclusion criteria) and included primary studies related to parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth of a single fetus. Searches of 13 electronic databases and the websites of SANDS and the International Stillbirth Alliance were conducted in September 2016. Two reviewers screened records independently. Reviews were critically appraised using the ROBIS tool and data relevant to care and support following stillbirth were extracted by one reviewer and checked by a second reviewer. ResultsThe search produced 10,278 original records and 10,198 were excluded. The full texts of 82 papers were screened (two titles were unobtainable) and 17 reviews were included. Three reviews included health care staff as well as parent participants. Four of the reviews included qualitative studies only, three included controlled trials only and 10 included a range qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods studies. The included studies in the reviews were predominantly from high income countries with only one study from a low income country. Three key themes reported in the included reviews were: general experiences of care and support for bereaved parents; choices and decision-making; interactions with healthcare professionals, and the effectiveness of specific interventions. While there were mixed experiences of care and support many women felt unsupported and ignored and would have liked more emotional support, support that was tailored to their individual needs, and continuity of care especially between hospital and community. In terms of decision-making the most common theme was about the option for parents to have contact (seeing and holding) with their baby and memory-making. Other choices related to options for the birth, such as timing of induction and pain relief, post-mortem, and burial. Parents appreciated clear, sensitive information about options, presented in more than one format, with time for both parents to process the information. There was evidence that interactions with health professionals have a memorable impact on parents. Positive behaviours included staying with parents, supporting them to express concerns, treating babies as if they are alive, and honest and clear communication. There was clear need for ongoing and consistent training for health professionals to improve support offered.Generally, there was a lack of robust evidence examining effectiveness of interventions. When trial evidence was available, e.g. for counselling interventions, results were mixed. More promising interventions appear to be those with multiple components that simultaneously target psychological, social and practical issues.

AB - IntroductionWe conducted a systematic review of reviews to synthesise evidence relating to improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth. Material and Methods Publications were eligible for inclusion if they used a structured approach (i.e. had an explicit search strategy and defined inclusion/exclusion criteria) and included primary studies related to parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth of a single fetus. Searches of 13 electronic databases and the websites of SANDS and the International Stillbirth Alliance were conducted in September 2016. Two reviewers screened records independently. Reviews were critically appraised using the ROBIS tool and data relevant to care and support following stillbirth were extracted by one reviewer and checked by a second reviewer. ResultsThe search produced 10,278 original records and 10,198 were excluded. The full texts of 82 papers were screened (two titles were unobtainable) and 17 reviews were included. Three reviews included health care staff as well as parent participants. Four of the reviews included qualitative studies only, three included controlled trials only and 10 included a range qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods studies. The included studies in the reviews were predominantly from high income countries with only one study from a low income country. Three key themes reported in the included reviews were: general experiences of care and support for bereaved parents; choices and decision-making; interactions with healthcare professionals, and the effectiveness of specific interventions. While there were mixed experiences of care and support many women felt unsupported and ignored and would have liked more emotional support, support that was tailored to their individual needs, and continuity of care especially between hospital and community. In terms of decision-making the most common theme was about the option for parents to have contact (seeing and holding) with their baby and memory-making. Other choices related to options for the birth, such as timing of induction and pain relief, post-mortem, and burial. Parents appreciated clear, sensitive information about options, presented in more than one format, with time for both parents to process the information. There was evidence that interactions with health professionals have a memorable impact on parents. Positive behaviours included staying with parents, supporting them to express concerns, treating babies as if they are alive, and honest and clear communication. There was clear need for ongoing and consistent training for health professionals to improve support offered.Generally, there was a lack of robust evidence examining effectiveness of interventions. When trial evidence was available, e.g. for counselling interventions, results were mixed. More promising interventions appear to be those with multiple components that simultaneously target psychological, social and practical issues.

UR - https://ispid-isa.org/2018/conference-information/welcome-letter#.W4kVsM5KiUk

UR - https://ispid-isa.org/2018/PublishingImages/abstract-information/abstract-e-book/ISPID2018ebook.pdf

M3 - Paper

ER -

McFadden A, Cameron J, McSwiggan L, Hollins-Martin C, Siebelt L, Gavine A et al. Improving parents’ experiences of care and support following stillbirth: a review of reviews. 2018. Paper presented at International Conference on Stillbirth, SIDS and Baby Survival, Glasgow, United Kingdom.