Institutionalisation of Emerging Norms of Customary International Law through Resolutions and Operational Activities of the Political and Subsidiary Organs of the United Nations

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

44 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The paper looks at resolutions and operational activities of the UN as parts of processes of institutionalisation of nascent norms of CIL. It argues that institutionalisation clarifies the scope of the norm and of its application; and improves mechanisms of persuasion and compliance with the norm, thereby increasing social pressure on resilient States. Hence, institutionalised norms have a higher potential to affect both the behaviour and attitude of States than non-institutionalised norms. Crucially, the paper argues that UN resolutions and activities foster processes of institutionalisation of new norms. Although the work acknowledges that is not possible to foresee whether a norm will crystallise as CIL, it suggests that its potential increases if it matches and draws on the normative framework provided by the UN Charter; if it does not excessively challenge the predominant expectations of States, and if UN organs work together in promoting it.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)254-290
Number of pages36
JournalInternational Organizations Law Review
Volume14
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2017

Fingerprint

institutionalization
international law
UNO
persuasion
charter
International law
Subsidiaries
United Nations
Institutionalization

Keywords

  • constructivism
  • international organizations
  • customary international law
  • United Nations
  • International Law Commission
  • institutions

Cite this

@article{89c8eb0f22e14c0497726fac9166c6b3,
title = "Institutionalisation of Emerging Norms of Customary International Law through Resolutions and Operational Activities of the Political and Subsidiary Organs of the United Nations",
abstract = "The paper looks at resolutions and operational activities of the UN as parts of processes of institutionalisation of nascent norms of CIL. It argues that institutionalisation clarifies the scope of the norm and of its application; and improves mechanisms of persuasion and compliance with the norm, thereby increasing social pressure on resilient States. Hence, institutionalised norms have a higher potential to affect both the behaviour and attitude of States than non-institutionalised norms. Crucially, the paper argues that UN resolutions and activities foster processes of institutionalisation of new norms. Although the work acknowledges that is not possible to foresee whether a norm will crystallise as CIL, it suggests that its potential increases if it matches and draws on the normative framework provided by the UN Charter; if it does not excessively challenge the predominant expectations of States, and if UN organs work together in promoting it.",
keywords = "constructivism, international organizations, customary international law, United Nations, International Law Commission, institutions",
author = "Sufyan Droubi",
note = "The research in connection with this article is funded by the S{\~a}o Paulo Research Foundation—fapesp (grant 2015/24219-7)",
year = "2017",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1163/15723747-01402002",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "254--290",
journal = "International Organizations Law Review",
issn = "1572-3739",
publisher = "Brill Academic Publishers",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Institutionalisation of Emerging Norms of Customary International Law through Resolutions and Operational Activities of the Political and Subsidiary Organs of the United Nations

AU - Droubi, Sufyan

N1 - The research in connection with this article is funded by the São Paulo Research Foundation—fapesp (grant 2015/24219-7)

PY - 2017/8

Y1 - 2017/8

N2 - The paper looks at resolutions and operational activities of the UN as parts of processes of institutionalisation of nascent norms of CIL. It argues that institutionalisation clarifies the scope of the norm and of its application; and improves mechanisms of persuasion and compliance with the norm, thereby increasing social pressure on resilient States. Hence, institutionalised norms have a higher potential to affect both the behaviour and attitude of States than non-institutionalised norms. Crucially, the paper argues that UN resolutions and activities foster processes of institutionalisation of new norms. Although the work acknowledges that is not possible to foresee whether a norm will crystallise as CIL, it suggests that its potential increases if it matches and draws on the normative framework provided by the UN Charter; if it does not excessively challenge the predominant expectations of States, and if UN organs work together in promoting it.

AB - The paper looks at resolutions and operational activities of the UN as parts of processes of institutionalisation of nascent norms of CIL. It argues that institutionalisation clarifies the scope of the norm and of its application; and improves mechanisms of persuasion and compliance with the norm, thereby increasing social pressure on resilient States. Hence, institutionalised norms have a higher potential to affect both the behaviour and attitude of States than non-institutionalised norms. Crucially, the paper argues that UN resolutions and activities foster processes of institutionalisation of new norms. Although the work acknowledges that is not possible to foresee whether a norm will crystallise as CIL, it suggests that its potential increases if it matches and draws on the normative framework provided by the UN Charter; if it does not excessively challenge the predominant expectations of States, and if UN organs work together in promoting it.

KW - constructivism

KW - international organizations

KW - customary international law

KW - United Nations

KW - International Law Commission

KW - institutions

U2 - 10.1163/15723747-01402002

DO - 10.1163/15723747-01402002

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 254

EP - 290

JO - International Organizations Law Review

JF - International Organizations Law Review

SN - 1572-3739

IS - 2

ER -