Invisible symmetries: superheroes, Grant Morrison and Isaiah Berlin’s Two concepts of liberty

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Throughout his career in comics Scottish writer Grant Morrison has interrogated concepts of liberty and power and their relationship to revolutionary action, often using the superhero as a metaphor. This paper examines liberalism in his work with reference to the ideas of political philosopher Isaiah Berlin (1909 - 1997), whose influential lecture “Two Concepts of Liberty” (1958), described the dangers of “positive liberty”, and set out the case for the virtues of “negative liberty”. Both Berlin and Morrison were profoundly influenced by the Cold War, and the philosophical and ideological arguments about the definition of freedom which arose from it. The superhero was also shaped by these debates, and Morrison’s liberalism, as expressed through his writing in this genre, owes much to the distinctions Berlin put in place. This paper argues that a greater understanding of the politics of the superhero, and Morrison’s changing attitude towards the genre and its underlying themes of identity and freedom, can be gained by applying Berlin’s schema. Indeed, several of Morrison’s key works, such as Zenith (1987 - 1993), The Invisibles (1994 - 2000), Flex Mentallo (1996), and All Star Superman (2005 - 2008), dramatise the struggle between positive and negative concepts of liberty, but his views have undergone shifts, from a rather sceptical conception of the superhero in his early work to the point where he now enshrines the superhero as the best example of liberty and aspiration.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)277-306
    Number of pages30
    JournalStudies in Comics
    Volume4
    Issue number2
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Oct 2013

    Fingerprint

    Isaiah Berlin
    Symmetry
    Invisible
    Liberty
    Superheroes
    Liberalism
    Superman
    Writer
    Aspiration
    Cold War
    Danger
    Political philosophers
    Revolution
    Conception

    Keywords

    • Grant Morrison
    • Liberty
    • Cold War
    • Comics

    Cite this

    @article{4857221424e0424db0a7caf56e4e54e5,
    title = "Invisible symmetries: superheroes, Grant Morrison and Isaiah Berlin’s Two concepts of liberty",
    abstract = "Throughout his career in comics Scottish writer Grant Morrison has interrogated concepts of liberty and power and their relationship to revolutionary action, often using the superhero as a metaphor. This paper examines liberalism in his work with reference to the ideas of political philosopher Isaiah Berlin (1909 - 1997), whose influential lecture “Two Concepts of Liberty” (1958), described the dangers of “positive liberty”, and set out the case for the virtues of “negative liberty”. Both Berlin and Morrison were profoundly influenced by the Cold War, and the philosophical and ideological arguments about the definition of freedom which arose from it. The superhero was also shaped by these debates, and Morrison’s liberalism, as expressed through his writing in this genre, owes much to the distinctions Berlin put in place. This paper argues that a greater understanding of the politics of the superhero, and Morrison’s changing attitude towards the genre and its underlying themes of identity and freedom, can be gained by applying Berlin’s schema. Indeed, several of Morrison’s key works, such as Zenith (1987 - 1993), The Invisibles (1994 - 2000), Flex Mentallo (1996), and All Star Superman (2005 - 2008), dramatise the struggle between positive and negative concepts of liberty, but his views have undergone shifts, from a rather sceptical conception of the superhero in his early work to the point where he now enshrines the superhero as the best example of liberty and aspiration.",
    keywords = "Grant Morrison, Liberty, Cold War, Comics",
    author = "Chris Murray",
    year = "2013",
    month = "10",
    doi = "10.1386/stic.4.2.277_1",
    language = "English",
    volume = "4",
    pages = "277--306",
    journal = "Studies in Comics",
    issn = "2040-3232",
    publisher = "Intellect",
    number = "2",

    }

    Invisible symmetries : superheroes, Grant Morrison and Isaiah Berlin’s Two concepts of liberty. / Murray, Chris.

    In: Studies in Comics, Vol. 4, No. 2, 10.2013, p. 277-306.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Invisible symmetries

    T2 - superheroes, Grant Morrison and Isaiah Berlin’s Two concepts of liberty

    AU - Murray, Chris

    PY - 2013/10

    Y1 - 2013/10

    N2 - Throughout his career in comics Scottish writer Grant Morrison has interrogated concepts of liberty and power and their relationship to revolutionary action, often using the superhero as a metaphor. This paper examines liberalism in his work with reference to the ideas of political philosopher Isaiah Berlin (1909 - 1997), whose influential lecture “Two Concepts of Liberty” (1958), described the dangers of “positive liberty”, and set out the case for the virtues of “negative liberty”. Both Berlin and Morrison were profoundly influenced by the Cold War, and the philosophical and ideological arguments about the definition of freedom which arose from it. The superhero was also shaped by these debates, and Morrison’s liberalism, as expressed through his writing in this genre, owes much to the distinctions Berlin put in place. This paper argues that a greater understanding of the politics of the superhero, and Morrison’s changing attitude towards the genre and its underlying themes of identity and freedom, can be gained by applying Berlin’s schema. Indeed, several of Morrison’s key works, such as Zenith (1987 - 1993), The Invisibles (1994 - 2000), Flex Mentallo (1996), and All Star Superman (2005 - 2008), dramatise the struggle between positive and negative concepts of liberty, but his views have undergone shifts, from a rather sceptical conception of the superhero in his early work to the point where he now enshrines the superhero as the best example of liberty and aspiration.

    AB - Throughout his career in comics Scottish writer Grant Morrison has interrogated concepts of liberty and power and their relationship to revolutionary action, often using the superhero as a metaphor. This paper examines liberalism in his work with reference to the ideas of political philosopher Isaiah Berlin (1909 - 1997), whose influential lecture “Two Concepts of Liberty” (1958), described the dangers of “positive liberty”, and set out the case for the virtues of “negative liberty”. Both Berlin and Morrison were profoundly influenced by the Cold War, and the philosophical and ideological arguments about the definition of freedom which arose from it. The superhero was also shaped by these debates, and Morrison’s liberalism, as expressed through his writing in this genre, owes much to the distinctions Berlin put in place. This paper argues that a greater understanding of the politics of the superhero, and Morrison’s changing attitude towards the genre and its underlying themes of identity and freedom, can be gained by applying Berlin’s schema. Indeed, several of Morrison’s key works, such as Zenith (1987 - 1993), The Invisibles (1994 - 2000), Flex Mentallo (1996), and All Star Superman (2005 - 2008), dramatise the struggle between positive and negative concepts of liberty, but his views have undergone shifts, from a rather sceptical conception of the superhero in his early work to the point where he now enshrines the superhero as the best example of liberty and aspiration.

    KW - Grant Morrison

    KW - Liberty

    KW - Cold War

    KW - Comics

    U2 - 10.1386/stic.4.2.277_1

    DO - 10.1386/stic.4.2.277_1

    M3 - Article

    VL - 4

    SP - 277

    EP - 306

    JO - Studies in Comics

    JF - Studies in Comics

    SN - 2040-3232

    IS - 2

    ER -