Midfrontal theta and pupil dilation parametrically track subjective conflict (but also surprise) during intertemporal choice

Hause Lin (Lead / Corresponding author), Blair Saunders, Cendri Hutcherson, Michael Inzlicht

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)
158 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Many everyday choices are based on personal, subjective preferences. When choosing between two options, we often feel conflicted, especially when trading off costs and benefits occurring at different times (e.g., saving for later versus spending now). Although previous work has investigated the neurophysiological basis of conflict during inhibitory control tasks, less is known about subjective conflict resulting from competing subjective preferences. In this pre-registered study, we investigated subjective conflict during intertemporal choice, whereby participants chose between smaller immediate versus larger delayed rewards (e.g., $15 today vs. $22 in 30 days). We used economic modeling to parametrically vary eleven different levels of conflict, and recorded EEG data and pupil dilation. Midfrontal theta power, derived from EEG, correlated with pupil responses, and our results suggest that these signals track different gradations of subjective conflict. Unexpectedly, both signals were also maximally enhanced when decisions were surprisingly easy. Therefore, these signals may track events requiring increased attention and adaptive shifts in behavioral responses, with subjective conflict being only one type of such event. Our results suggest that the neural systems underlying midfrontal theta and pupil responses interact when weighing costs and benefits during intertemporal choice. Thus, understanding these interactions might elucidate how individuals resolve self-control conflicts.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)838-852
Number of pages15
JournalNeuroImage
Volume172
Early online date28 Oct 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 May 2018

Fingerprint

Pupil
Dilatation
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Electroencephalography
Conflict (Psychology)
Reward
Economics

Keywords

  • Intertemporal choice
  • Self-control
  • Value-guided choice
  • Conflict
  • Theta oscillations
  • Pupil dilation

Cite this

@article{c404d52a4ed848db8f956bfc464581b4,
title = "Midfrontal theta and pupil dilation parametrically track subjective conflict (but also surprise) during intertemporal choice",
abstract = "Many everyday choices are based on personal, subjective preferences. When choosing between two options, we often feel conflicted, especially when trading off costs and benefits occurring at different times (e.g., saving for later versus spending now). Although previous work has investigated the neurophysiological basis of conflict during inhibitory control tasks, less is known about subjective conflict resulting from competing subjective preferences. In this pre-registered study, we investigated subjective conflict during intertemporal choice, whereby participants chose between smaller immediate versus larger delayed rewards (e.g., $15 today vs. $22 in 30 days). We used economic modeling to parametrically vary eleven different levels of conflict, and recorded EEG data and pupil dilation. Midfrontal theta power, derived from EEG, correlated with pupil responses, and our results suggest that these signals track different gradations of subjective conflict. Unexpectedly, both signals were also maximally enhanced when decisions were surprisingly easy. Therefore, these signals may track events requiring increased attention and adaptive shifts in behavioral responses, with subjective conflict being only one type of such event. Our results suggest that the neural systems underlying midfrontal theta and pupil responses interact when weighing costs and benefits during intertemporal choice. Thus, understanding these interactions might elucidate how individuals resolve self-control conflicts.",
keywords = "Intertemporal choice, Self-control, Value-guided choice, Conflict, Theta oscillations, Pupil dilation",
author = "Hause Lin and Blair Saunders and Cendri Hutcherson and Michael Inzlicht",
note = "{\circledC} 2017 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.055",
language = "English",
volume = "172",
pages = "838--852",
journal = "NeuroImage",
issn = "1053-8119",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Midfrontal theta and pupil dilation parametrically track subjective conflict (but also surprise) during intertemporal choice. / Lin, Hause (Lead / Corresponding author); Saunders, Blair; Hutcherson, Cendri; Inzlicht, Michael.

In: NeuroImage, Vol. 172, 15.05.2018, p. 838-852.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Midfrontal theta and pupil dilation parametrically track subjective conflict (but also surprise) during intertemporal choice

AU - Lin, Hause

AU - Saunders, Blair

AU - Hutcherson, Cendri

AU - Inzlicht, Michael

N1 - © 2017 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

PY - 2018/5/15

Y1 - 2018/5/15

N2 - Many everyday choices are based on personal, subjective preferences. When choosing between two options, we often feel conflicted, especially when trading off costs and benefits occurring at different times (e.g., saving for later versus spending now). Although previous work has investigated the neurophysiological basis of conflict during inhibitory control tasks, less is known about subjective conflict resulting from competing subjective preferences. In this pre-registered study, we investigated subjective conflict during intertemporal choice, whereby participants chose between smaller immediate versus larger delayed rewards (e.g., $15 today vs. $22 in 30 days). We used economic modeling to parametrically vary eleven different levels of conflict, and recorded EEG data and pupil dilation. Midfrontal theta power, derived from EEG, correlated with pupil responses, and our results suggest that these signals track different gradations of subjective conflict. Unexpectedly, both signals were also maximally enhanced when decisions were surprisingly easy. Therefore, these signals may track events requiring increased attention and adaptive shifts in behavioral responses, with subjective conflict being only one type of such event. Our results suggest that the neural systems underlying midfrontal theta and pupil responses interact when weighing costs and benefits during intertemporal choice. Thus, understanding these interactions might elucidate how individuals resolve self-control conflicts.

AB - Many everyday choices are based on personal, subjective preferences. When choosing between two options, we often feel conflicted, especially when trading off costs and benefits occurring at different times (e.g., saving for later versus spending now). Although previous work has investigated the neurophysiological basis of conflict during inhibitory control tasks, less is known about subjective conflict resulting from competing subjective preferences. In this pre-registered study, we investigated subjective conflict during intertemporal choice, whereby participants chose between smaller immediate versus larger delayed rewards (e.g., $15 today vs. $22 in 30 days). We used economic modeling to parametrically vary eleven different levels of conflict, and recorded EEG data and pupil dilation. Midfrontal theta power, derived from EEG, correlated with pupil responses, and our results suggest that these signals track different gradations of subjective conflict. Unexpectedly, both signals were also maximally enhanced when decisions were surprisingly easy. Therefore, these signals may track events requiring increased attention and adaptive shifts in behavioral responses, with subjective conflict being only one type of such event. Our results suggest that the neural systems underlying midfrontal theta and pupil responses interact when weighing costs and benefits during intertemporal choice. Thus, understanding these interactions might elucidate how individuals resolve self-control conflicts.

KW - Intertemporal choice

KW - Self-control

KW - Value-guided choice

KW - Conflict

KW - Theta oscillations

KW - Pupil dilation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85035062658&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.055

DO - 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.055

M3 - Article

C2 - 29107773

VL - 172

SP - 838

EP - 852

JO - NeuroImage

JF - NeuroImage

SN - 1053-8119

ER -