On the accuracy of framing-rate measurements in ultra-high speed rotating mirror cameras

Michael Conneely, Hans O. Rolfsnes, Charles Main, David McGloin, Paul A. Campbell

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    6 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Rotating mirror systems based on the Miller Principle are a mainstay modality for ultra-high speed imaging within the range 1-25 million frames per second. Importantly, the true temporal accuracy of observations recorded in such cameras is sensitive to the framing rate that the system directly associates with each individual data acquisition. The purpose for the present investigation was to examine the validity of such system-reported frame rates in a widely used commercial system (a Cordin 550-62 model) by independently measuring the framing rate at the instant of triggering. Here, we found a small but significant difference between such measurements: the average discrepancy (over the entire spectrum of frame rates used) was found to be 0.66 +/- 0.48%, with a maximum difference of 2.33%. The principal reason for this discrepancy was traced to non-optimized sampling of the mirror rotation rate within the system protocol. This paper thus serves three purposes: (i) we highlight a straightforward diagnostic approach to facilitate scrutiny of rotating-mirror system integrity; (ii) we raise awareness of the intrinsic errors associated with data previously acquired with this particular system and model; and (iii), we recommend that future control routines address the sampling issue by implementing real-time measurement at the instant of triggering. (C) 2011 Optical Society of America

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)16432-16437
    Number of pages6
    JournalOptics Express
    Volume19
    Issue number17
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 15 Aug 2011

    Keywords

    • FRAMES
    • BRANDARIS-128

    Cite this

    Conneely, Michael ; Rolfsnes, Hans O. ; Main, Charles ; McGloin, David ; Campbell, Paul A. / On the accuracy of framing-rate measurements in ultra-high speed rotating mirror cameras. In: Optics Express. 2011 ; Vol. 19, No. 17. pp. 16432-16437.
    @article{e03bc77e14a1476482204e6416aa1a92,
    title = "On the accuracy of framing-rate measurements in ultra-high speed rotating mirror cameras",
    abstract = "Rotating mirror systems based on the Miller Principle are a mainstay modality for ultra-high speed imaging within the range 1-25 million frames per second. Importantly, the true temporal accuracy of observations recorded in such cameras is sensitive to the framing rate that the system directly associates with each individual data acquisition. The purpose for the present investigation was to examine the validity of such system-reported frame rates in a widely used commercial system (a Cordin 550-62 model) by independently measuring the framing rate at the instant of triggering. Here, we found a small but significant difference between such measurements: the average discrepancy (over the entire spectrum of frame rates used) was found to be 0.66 +/- 0.48{\%}, with a maximum difference of 2.33{\%}. The principal reason for this discrepancy was traced to non-optimized sampling of the mirror rotation rate within the system protocol. This paper thus serves three purposes: (i) we highlight a straightforward diagnostic approach to facilitate scrutiny of rotating-mirror system integrity; (ii) we raise awareness of the intrinsic errors associated with data previously acquired with this particular system and model; and (iii), we recommend that future control routines address the sampling issue by implementing real-time measurement at the instant of triggering. (C) 2011 Optical Society of America",
    keywords = "FRAMES, BRANDARIS-128",
    author = "Michael Conneely and Rolfsnes, {Hans O.} and Charles Main and David McGloin and Campbell, {Paul A.}",
    year = "2011",
    month = "8",
    day = "15",
    doi = "10.1364/OE.19.016432",
    language = "English",
    volume = "19",
    pages = "16432--16437",
    journal = "Optics Express",
    issn = "1094-4087",
    publisher = "Optical Society of America",
    number = "17",

    }

    On the accuracy of framing-rate measurements in ultra-high speed rotating mirror cameras. / Conneely, Michael; Rolfsnes, Hans O.; Main, Charles; McGloin, David; Campbell, Paul A.

    In: Optics Express, Vol. 19, No. 17, 15.08.2011, p. 16432-16437.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - On the accuracy of framing-rate measurements in ultra-high speed rotating mirror cameras

    AU - Conneely, Michael

    AU - Rolfsnes, Hans O.

    AU - Main, Charles

    AU - McGloin, David

    AU - Campbell, Paul A.

    PY - 2011/8/15

    Y1 - 2011/8/15

    N2 - Rotating mirror systems based on the Miller Principle are a mainstay modality for ultra-high speed imaging within the range 1-25 million frames per second. Importantly, the true temporal accuracy of observations recorded in such cameras is sensitive to the framing rate that the system directly associates with each individual data acquisition. The purpose for the present investigation was to examine the validity of such system-reported frame rates in a widely used commercial system (a Cordin 550-62 model) by independently measuring the framing rate at the instant of triggering. Here, we found a small but significant difference between such measurements: the average discrepancy (over the entire spectrum of frame rates used) was found to be 0.66 +/- 0.48%, with a maximum difference of 2.33%. The principal reason for this discrepancy was traced to non-optimized sampling of the mirror rotation rate within the system protocol. This paper thus serves three purposes: (i) we highlight a straightforward diagnostic approach to facilitate scrutiny of rotating-mirror system integrity; (ii) we raise awareness of the intrinsic errors associated with data previously acquired with this particular system and model; and (iii), we recommend that future control routines address the sampling issue by implementing real-time measurement at the instant of triggering. (C) 2011 Optical Society of America

    AB - Rotating mirror systems based on the Miller Principle are a mainstay modality for ultra-high speed imaging within the range 1-25 million frames per second. Importantly, the true temporal accuracy of observations recorded in such cameras is sensitive to the framing rate that the system directly associates with each individual data acquisition. The purpose for the present investigation was to examine the validity of such system-reported frame rates in a widely used commercial system (a Cordin 550-62 model) by independently measuring the framing rate at the instant of triggering. Here, we found a small but significant difference between such measurements: the average discrepancy (over the entire spectrum of frame rates used) was found to be 0.66 +/- 0.48%, with a maximum difference of 2.33%. The principal reason for this discrepancy was traced to non-optimized sampling of the mirror rotation rate within the system protocol. This paper thus serves three purposes: (i) we highlight a straightforward diagnostic approach to facilitate scrutiny of rotating-mirror system integrity; (ii) we raise awareness of the intrinsic errors associated with data previously acquired with this particular system and model; and (iii), we recommend that future control routines address the sampling issue by implementing real-time measurement at the instant of triggering. (C) 2011 Optical Society of America

    KW - FRAMES

    KW - BRANDARIS-128

    U2 - 10.1364/OE.19.016432

    DO - 10.1364/OE.19.016432

    M3 - Article

    VL - 19

    SP - 16432

    EP - 16437

    JO - Optics Express

    JF - Optics Express

    SN - 1094-4087

    IS - 17

    ER -