Paradoxical effects of feedback in international online reciprocal peer tutoring

K.J. Topping, R. Dekhinet, S. Blanch, M. Corcelles, D. Duran

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    19 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    This paper reports an online reciprocal peer tutoring project for improving language competence in Spanish and English. Students aged 9-12 years from Scotland and Catalonia were matched to act as tutors in their own language and as tutees in a modern foreign language. Students were intended to improve both their first language (through helping the tutee) and a modern language (with their tutor's help). The methodology combined a quasi-experimental design and a qualitative analysis of texts. For Catalan students, pre-post test results indicated statistically significant improvements in reading comprehension (while acting as tutors) and writing (while acting as tutees). Scottish students improved only their writing (acting as tutees). Analysis of the texts showed that when more support was given, the tutor had more learning opportunities, but then there were fewer opportunities for the tutee, and vice versa. Thus the tutee learned more with less elaborated feedback, leading to fewer opportunities for tutor improvement. This paradox could be resolved by adjusting the scaffolding support given by tutors, to create a balanced interactive learning context for both members of the pair.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)225-231
    Number of pages7
    JournalComputers & Education
    Volume61
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2013

    Fingerprint

    tutor
    Students
    Feedback
    language
    student
    Design of experiments
    foreign language
    learning
    comprehension
    methodology

    Cite this

    Topping, K.J. ; Dekhinet, R. ; Blanch, S. ; Corcelles, M. ; Duran, D. / Paradoxical effects of feedback in international online reciprocal peer tutoring. In: Computers & Education. 2013 ; Vol. 61, No. 1. pp. 225-231.
    @article{1defcb04a4964fb0a64429de794c77b6,
    title = "Paradoxical effects of feedback in international online reciprocal peer tutoring",
    abstract = "This paper reports an online reciprocal peer tutoring project for improving language competence in Spanish and English. Students aged 9-12 years from Scotland and Catalonia were matched to act as tutors in their own language and as tutees in a modern foreign language. Students were intended to improve both their first language (through helping the tutee) and a modern language (with their tutor's help). The methodology combined a quasi-experimental design and a qualitative analysis of texts. For Catalan students, pre-post test results indicated statistically significant improvements in reading comprehension (while acting as tutors) and writing (while acting as tutees). Scottish students improved only their writing (acting as tutees). Analysis of the texts showed that when more support was given, the tutor had more learning opportunities, but then there were fewer opportunities for the tutee, and vice versa. Thus the tutee learned more with less elaborated feedback, leading to fewer opportunities for tutor improvement. This paradox could be resolved by adjusting the scaffolding support given by tutors, to create a balanced interactive learning context for both members of the pair.",
    author = "K.J. Topping and R. Dekhinet and S. Blanch and M. Corcelles and D. Duran",
    year = "2013",
    doi = "10.1016/j.compedu.2012.10.002",
    language = "English",
    volume = "61",
    pages = "225--231",
    journal = "Computers & Education",
    issn = "0360-1315",
    publisher = "Elsevier",
    number = "1",

    }

    Paradoxical effects of feedback in international online reciprocal peer tutoring. / Topping, K.J.; Dekhinet, R.; Blanch, S.; Corcelles, M.; Duran, D.

    In: Computers & Education, Vol. 61, No. 1, 2013, p. 225-231.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Paradoxical effects of feedback in international online reciprocal peer tutoring

    AU - Topping, K.J.

    AU - Dekhinet, R.

    AU - Blanch, S.

    AU - Corcelles, M.

    AU - Duran, D.

    PY - 2013

    Y1 - 2013

    N2 - This paper reports an online reciprocal peer tutoring project for improving language competence in Spanish and English. Students aged 9-12 years from Scotland and Catalonia were matched to act as tutors in their own language and as tutees in a modern foreign language. Students were intended to improve both their first language (through helping the tutee) and a modern language (with their tutor's help). The methodology combined a quasi-experimental design and a qualitative analysis of texts. For Catalan students, pre-post test results indicated statistically significant improvements in reading comprehension (while acting as tutors) and writing (while acting as tutees). Scottish students improved only their writing (acting as tutees). Analysis of the texts showed that when more support was given, the tutor had more learning opportunities, but then there were fewer opportunities for the tutee, and vice versa. Thus the tutee learned more with less elaborated feedback, leading to fewer opportunities for tutor improvement. This paradox could be resolved by adjusting the scaffolding support given by tutors, to create a balanced interactive learning context for both members of the pair.

    AB - This paper reports an online reciprocal peer tutoring project for improving language competence in Spanish and English. Students aged 9-12 years from Scotland and Catalonia were matched to act as tutors in their own language and as tutees in a modern foreign language. Students were intended to improve both their first language (through helping the tutee) and a modern language (with their tutor's help). The methodology combined a quasi-experimental design and a qualitative analysis of texts. For Catalan students, pre-post test results indicated statistically significant improvements in reading comprehension (while acting as tutors) and writing (while acting as tutees). Scottish students improved only their writing (acting as tutees). Analysis of the texts showed that when more support was given, the tutor had more learning opportunities, but then there were fewer opportunities for the tutee, and vice versa. Thus the tutee learned more with less elaborated feedback, leading to fewer opportunities for tutor improvement. This paradox could be resolved by adjusting the scaffolding support given by tutors, to create a balanced interactive learning context for both members of the pair.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84868514259&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.compedu.2012.10.002

    DO - 10.1016/j.compedu.2012.10.002

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:84868514259

    VL - 61

    SP - 225

    EP - 231

    JO - Computers & Education

    JF - Computers & Education

    SN - 0360-1315

    IS - 1

    ER -