Sliding doors: Did drama-based inter-professional education improve the tensions round person-centred nursing and social care delivery for people with dementia: A mixed method exploratory study

Lindsay Dingwall (Lead / Corresponding author), Jane Fenton, Timothy B. Kelly, John Lee

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)
170 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This educational intervention takes place when the population of older people with dementia is increasing. Health and Social care professionals must work jointly in increasingly complex contexts. Negative attitudes towards older people are cited as a contributor to poor care delivery, including the use of dismissive and/or patronising language, failing to meet fundamental needs and afford choice. ‘Sliding Doors to Personal Futures’ is a joint, drama-based, educational initiative between NHS Education Scotland and the Scottish Social Services Council, delivered using interprofessional education (IPE) towards encouraging person-centred health and social care.

This paper considers whether ‘Sliding Doors’ had an impact on social work and nursing students’ attitudes to older people, person-centred care and interprofessional collaboration. Two groups of third year students were studied; one from nursing and one from social work. A mixed methods approach was taken and attitudes and attitudinal shifts measured and discussed.


Quantitative results demonstrated that social work students made positive attitudinal shifts in some questionnaire items and collectively the social work students were more person-centred than nursing students in their care approaches. The qualitative data however, drawn from focus groups, illuminated these results and highlighted the link between the ability for a professional to be person-centred and the conceptual view of risk within the particular profession. Risk acceptance, the theoretical position of social work, may facilitate person-centred care, whereas the perceived risk-averse nature of the nursing profession may inhibit it. Students’ attempts to understand the quantitative results, without understanding the restrictions and parameters of each other’s profession, led them to revert to stereotypes and negative views of each other as practitioners.

The paper concludes that there is an important difference between nurses’ and social workers’ frames of reference. It is suggested that IPE in its current form will not impact positively on outcomes for older people, unless both professions can openly acknowledge the reality of their professional contexts and develop an understanding of each other’s professional restrictions, opportunities and aspirations.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-7
Number of pages7
JournalNurse Education Today
Volume51
Early online date21 Dec 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2017

Fingerprint

Drama
Professional Education
Nursing Care
Social Work
dementia
drama
Dementia
nursing
social work
human being
profession
Students
education
student
Nursing Students
Education
Nursing
Delivery of Health Care
Aptitude
Scotland

Keywords

  • Interprofessional education
  • Health and Social care
  • dementia education
  • person-centred care
  • attitudes towards older people
  • risk aversion

Cite this

@article{4365d088995545ecaa72cf2fa00ad11a,
title = "Sliding doors: Did drama-based inter-professional education improve the tensions round person-centred nursing and social care delivery for people with dementia: A mixed method exploratory study",
abstract = "This educational intervention takes place when the population of older people with dementia is increasing. Health and Social care professionals must work jointly in increasingly complex contexts. Negative attitudes towards older people are cited as a contributor to poor care delivery, including the use of dismissive and/or patronising language, failing to meet fundamental needs and afford choice. ‘Sliding Doors to Personal Futures’ is a joint, drama-based, educational initiative between NHS Education Scotland and the Scottish Social Services Council, delivered using interprofessional education (IPE) towards encouraging person-centred health and social care. This paper considers whether ‘Sliding Doors’ had an impact on social work and nursing students’ attitudes to older people, person-centred care and interprofessional collaboration. Two groups of third year students were studied; one from nursing and one from social work. A mixed methods approach was taken and attitudes and attitudinal shifts measured and discussed.Quantitative results demonstrated that social work students made positive attitudinal shifts in some questionnaire items and collectively the social work students were more person-centred than nursing students in their care approaches. The qualitative data however, drawn from focus groups, illuminated these results and highlighted the link between the ability for a professional to be person-centred and the conceptual view of risk within the particular profession. Risk acceptance, the theoretical position of social work, may facilitate person-centred care, whereas the perceived risk-averse nature of the nursing profession may inhibit it. Students’ attempts to understand the quantitative results, without understanding the restrictions and parameters of each other’s profession, led them to revert to stereotypes and negative views of each other as practitioners.The paper concludes that there is an important difference between nurses’ and social workers’ frames of reference. It is suggested that IPE in its current form will not impact positively on outcomes for older people, unless both professions can openly acknowledge the reality of their professional contexts and develop an understanding of each other’s professional restrictions, opportunities and aspirations.",
keywords = "Interprofessional education, Health and Social care, dementia education, person-centred care, attitudes towards older people, risk aversion",
author = "Lindsay Dingwall and Jane Fenton and Kelly, {Timothy B.} and John Lee",
note = "no funding",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1016/j.nedt.2016.12.008",
language = "English",
volume = "51",
pages = "1--7",
journal = "Nurse Education Today",
issn = "0260-6917",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Sliding doors

T2 - Did drama-based inter-professional education improve the tensions round person-centred nursing and social care delivery for people with dementia: A mixed method exploratory study

AU - Dingwall, Lindsay

AU - Fenton, Jane

AU - Kelly, Timothy B.

AU - Lee, John

N1 - no funding

PY - 2017/4

Y1 - 2017/4

N2 - This educational intervention takes place when the population of older people with dementia is increasing. Health and Social care professionals must work jointly in increasingly complex contexts. Negative attitudes towards older people are cited as a contributor to poor care delivery, including the use of dismissive and/or patronising language, failing to meet fundamental needs and afford choice. ‘Sliding Doors to Personal Futures’ is a joint, drama-based, educational initiative between NHS Education Scotland and the Scottish Social Services Council, delivered using interprofessional education (IPE) towards encouraging person-centred health and social care. This paper considers whether ‘Sliding Doors’ had an impact on social work and nursing students’ attitudes to older people, person-centred care and interprofessional collaboration. Two groups of third year students were studied; one from nursing and one from social work. A mixed methods approach was taken and attitudes and attitudinal shifts measured and discussed.Quantitative results demonstrated that social work students made positive attitudinal shifts in some questionnaire items and collectively the social work students were more person-centred than nursing students in their care approaches. The qualitative data however, drawn from focus groups, illuminated these results and highlighted the link between the ability for a professional to be person-centred and the conceptual view of risk within the particular profession. Risk acceptance, the theoretical position of social work, may facilitate person-centred care, whereas the perceived risk-averse nature of the nursing profession may inhibit it. Students’ attempts to understand the quantitative results, without understanding the restrictions and parameters of each other’s profession, led them to revert to stereotypes and negative views of each other as practitioners.The paper concludes that there is an important difference between nurses’ and social workers’ frames of reference. It is suggested that IPE in its current form will not impact positively on outcomes for older people, unless both professions can openly acknowledge the reality of their professional contexts and develop an understanding of each other’s professional restrictions, opportunities and aspirations.

AB - This educational intervention takes place when the population of older people with dementia is increasing. Health and Social care professionals must work jointly in increasingly complex contexts. Negative attitudes towards older people are cited as a contributor to poor care delivery, including the use of dismissive and/or patronising language, failing to meet fundamental needs and afford choice. ‘Sliding Doors to Personal Futures’ is a joint, drama-based, educational initiative between NHS Education Scotland and the Scottish Social Services Council, delivered using interprofessional education (IPE) towards encouraging person-centred health and social care. This paper considers whether ‘Sliding Doors’ had an impact on social work and nursing students’ attitudes to older people, person-centred care and interprofessional collaboration. Two groups of third year students were studied; one from nursing and one from social work. A mixed methods approach was taken and attitudes and attitudinal shifts measured and discussed.Quantitative results demonstrated that social work students made positive attitudinal shifts in some questionnaire items and collectively the social work students were more person-centred than nursing students in their care approaches. The qualitative data however, drawn from focus groups, illuminated these results and highlighted the link between the ability for a professional to be person-centred and the conceptual view of risk within the particular profession. Risk acceptance, the theoretical position of social work, may facilitate person-centred care, whereas the perceived risk-averse nature of the nursing profession may inhibit it. Students’ attempts to understand the quantitative results, without understanding the restrictions and parameters of each other’s profession, led them to revert to stereotypes and negative views of each other as practitioners.The paper concludes that there is an important difference between nurses’ and social workers’ frames of reference. It is suggested that IPE in its current form will not impact positively on outcomes for older people, unless both professions can openly acknowledge the reality of their professional contexts and develop an understanding of each other’s professional restrictions, opportunities and aspirations.

KW - Interprofessional education

KW - Health and Social care

KW - dementia education

KW - person-centred care

KW - attitudes towards older people

KW - risk aversion

U2 - 10.1016/j.nedt.2016.12.008

DO - 10.1016/j.nedt.2016.12.008

M3 - Article

C2 - 28088047

VL - 51

SP - 1

EP - 7

JO - Nurse Education Today

JF - Nurse Education Today

SN - 0260-6917

ER -