Southern Irish nationalism as a Historiographical Problem

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    16 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    To what extent has the recent war in Northern Ireland influenced Irish historiography ? Examining the nomenclature, periodization, and the use of democracy and state legitimization as interpretative tools in the historicization of the Irish Civil War (1922–3), the influence of a southern nationalist ideology is apparent. A dominating southern nationalist interest represented the revolutionary political elite’s realpolitik after 1920, though its pan-nationalist rhetoric obscured this. Ignoring southern nationalism as a cogent influence has led to the misrepresentation of nationalism as ethnically homogeneous in twentiethcentury Ireland. Once this is identified, historiographical and methodological problems are illuminated, which may be demonstrated in historians’ work on the revolutionary period (c. 1912–23). Following the northern crisis’s emergence in the late 1960s, the Republic’s Irish governments required a revised public history that could reconcile the state’s violent and revolutionary origins with its counterinsurgency against militarist-republicanism. At the same time many historians adopted constitutional, later democratic, state formation narratives for the south at the expense of historical precision. This facilitated a broader statecentred and statist historiography, mirroring the Republic’s desire to re-orientate its nationalism away from irredentism, toward the conscious accommodation of partition. Reconciliation of southern nationalist identities with its state represents a singular political achievement, as well as a concomitant historiographical problem.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)197-223
    Number of pages27
    JournalHistorical Journal
    Volume50
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Mar 2007

    Fingerprint

    Irish Nationalism
    Nationalists
    Nationalism
    Revolution
    Historian
    Historiography
    Government
    Counterinsurgency
    Mirroring
    Republicanism
    Rhetoric
    Accommodation
    Misrepresentation
    State Formation
    Irredentism
    Conscious
    Nomenclature
    Historicization
    Methodological Problems
    Civil War

    Cite this

    @article{21802aa0b74149a48ceeeeb09f7752cc,
    title = "Southern Irish nationalism as a Historiographical Problem",
    abstract = "To what extent has the recent war in Northern Ireland influenced Irish historiography ? Examining the nomenclature, periodization, and the use of democracy and state legitimization as interpretative tools in the historicization of the Irish Civil War (1922–3), the influence of a southern nationalist ideology is apparent. A dominating southern nationalist interest represented the revolutionary political elite’s realpolitik after 1920, though its pan-nationalist rhetoric obscured this. Ignoring southern nationalism as a cogent influence has led to the misrepresentation of nationalism as ethnically homogeneous in twentiethcentury Ireland. Once this is identified, historiographical and methodological problems are illuminated, which may be demonstrated in historians’ work on the revolutionary period (c. 1912–23). Following the northern crisis’s emergence in the late 1960s, the Republic’s Irish governments required a revised public history that could reconcile the state’s violent and revolutionary origins with its counterinsurgency against militarist-republicanism. At the same time many historians adopted constitutional, later democratic, state formation narratives for the south at the expense of historical precision. This facilitated a broader statecentred and statist historiography, mirroring the Republic’s desire to re-orientate its nationalism away from irredentism, toward the conscious accommodation of partition. Reconciliation of southern nationalist identities with its state represents a singular political achievement, as well as a concomitant historiographical problem.",
    author = "Regan, {John M.}",
    note = "dc.publisher: Cambridge University Press",
    year = "2007",
    month = "3",
    doi = "10.1017/S0018246X06005978",
    language = "English",
    volume = "50",
    pages = "197--223",
    journal = "Historical Journal",
    issn = "0018-246X",
    publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
    number = "1",

    }

    Southern Irish nationalism as a Historiographical Problem. / Regan, John M.

    In: Historical Journal, Vol. 50, No. 1, 03.2007, p. 197-223.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Southern Irish nationalism as a Historiographical Problem

    AU - Regan, John M.

    N1 - dc.publisher: Cambridge University Press

    PY - 2007/3

    Y1 - 2007/3

    N2 - To what extent has the recent war in Northern Ireland influenced Irish historiography ? Examining the nomenclature, periodization, and the use of democracy and state legitimization as interpretative tools in the historicization of the Irish Civil War (1922–3), the influence of a southern nationalist ideology is apparent. A dominating southern nationalist interest represented the revolutionary political elite’s realpolitik after 1920, though its pan-nationalist rhetoric obscured this. Ignoring southern nationalism as a cogent influence has led to the misrepresentation of nationalism as ethnically homogeneous in twentiethcentury Ireland. Once this is identified, historiographical and methodological problems are illuminated, which may be demonstrated in historians’ work on the revolutionary period (c. 1912–23). Following the northern crisis’s emergence in the late 1960s, the Republic’s Irish governments required a revised public history that could reconcile the state’s violent and revolutionary origins with its counterinsurgency against militarist-republicanism. At the same time many historians adopted constitutional, later democratic, state formation narratives for the south at the expense of historical precision. This facilitated a broader statecentred and statist historiography, mirroring the Republic’s desire to re-orientate its nationalism away from irredentism, toward the conscious accommodation of partition. Reconciliation of southern nationalist identities with its state represents a singular political achievement, as well as a concomitant historiographical problem.

    AB - To what extent has the recent war in Northern Ireland influenced Irish historiography ? Examining the nomenclature, periodization, and the use of democracy and state legitimization as interpretative tools in the historicization of the Irish Civil War (1922–3), the influence of a southern nationalist ideology is apparent. A dominating southern nationalist interest represented the revolutionary political elite’s realpolitik after 1920, though its pan-nationalist rhetoric obscured this. Ignoring southern nationalism as a cogent influence has led to the misrepresentation of nationalism as ethnically homogeneous in twentiethcentury Ireland. Once this is identified, historiographical and methodological problems are illuminated, which may be demonstrated in historians’ work on the revolutionary period (c. 1912–23). Following the northern crisis’s emergence in the late 1960s, the Republic’s Irish governments required a revised public history that could reconcile the state’s violent and revolutionary origins with its counterinsurgency against militarist-republicanism. At the same time many historians adopted constitutional, later democratic, state formation narratives for the south at the expense of historical precision. This facilitated a broader statecentred and statist historiography, mirroring the Republic’s desire to re-orientate its nationalism away from irredentism, toward the conscious accommodation of partition. Reconciliation of southern nationalist identities with its state represents a singular political achievement, as well as a concomitant historiographical problem.

    U2 - 10.1017/S0018246X06005978

    DO - 10.1017/S0018246X06005978

    M3 - Article

    VL - 50

    SP - 197

    EP - 223

    JO - Historical Journal

    JF - Historical Journal

    SN - 0018-246X

    IS - 1

    ER -