The Latent Structure of Personality Functioning: Investigating Criterion A From the Alternative Model for Personality Disorders in DSM-5

Johannes Zimmermann, Jan R Böhnke, Rhea Eschstruth, Alessa Mathews, Kristin Wenzel, Daniel Leising

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    41 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    The alternative model for the classification of personality disorders (PD) in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.; DSM–5) Section III comprises 2 major components: impairments in personality functioning (Criterion A) and maladaptive personality traits (Criterion B). In this study, we investigated the latent structure of Criterion A (a) within subdomains, (b) across subdomains, and (c) in conjunction with the Criterion B trait facets. Data were gathered as part of an online study that collected other-ratings by 515 laypersons and 145 therapists. Laypersons were asked to assess 1 of their personal acquaintances, whereas therapists were asked to assess 1 of their patients, using 135 items that captured features of Criteria A and B. We were able to show that (a) the structure within the Criterion A subdomains can be appropriately modeled using generalized graded unfolding models, with results suggesting that the items are indeed related to common underlying constructs but often deviate from their theoretically expected severity level; (b) the structure across subdomains is broadly in line with a model comprising 2 strongly correlated factors of self- and interpersonal functioning, with some notable deviations from the theoretical model; and (c) the joint structure of the Criterion A subdomains and the Criterion B facets broadly resembles the expected model of 2 plus 5 factors, albeit the loading pattern suggests that the distinction between Criteria A and B is somewhat blurry. Our findings provide support for several major assumptions of the alternative DSM–5 model for PD but also highlight aspects of the model that need to be further refined. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)532-548
    Number of pages17
    JournalJournal of Abnormal Child Psychology
    Volume124
    Issue number3
    Early online date8 Jun 2015
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Aug 2015

    Fingerprint

    Personality Disorders
    Personality
    Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
    Theoretical Models
    Joints

    Keywords

    • maladaptive personality traits
    • personality functioning
    • item response theory
    • exploratory structural equation model
    • personality disorder

    Cite this

    Zimmermann, Johannes ; Böhnke, Jan R ; Eschstruth, Rhea ; Mathews, Alessa ; Wenzel, Kristin ; Leising, Daniel. / The Latent Structure of Personality Functioning: Investigating Criterion A From the Alternative Model for Personality Disorders in DSM-5. In: Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology. 2015 ; Vol. 124, No. 3. pp. 532-548.
    @article{cb9862713fb94e219d4242134f94a3e7,
    title = "The Latent Structure of Personality Functioning: Investigating Criterion A From the Alternative Model for Personality Disorders in DSM-5",
    abstract = "The alternative model for the classification of personality disorders (PD) in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.; DSM–5) Section III comprises 2 major components: impairments in personality functioning (Criterion A) and maladaptive personality traits (Criterion B). In this study, we investigated the latent structure of Criterion A (a) within subdomains, (b) across subdomains, and (c) in conjunction with the Criterion B trait facets. Data were gathered as part of an online study that collected other-ratings by 515 laypersons and 145 therapists. Laypersons were asked to assess 1 of their personal acquaintances, whereas therapists were asked to assess 1 of their patients, using 135 items that captured features of Criteria A and B. We were able to show that (a) the structure within the Criterion A subdomains can be appropriately modeled using generalized graded unfolding models, with results suggesting that the items are indeed related to common underlying constructs but often deviate from their theoretically expected severity level; (b) the structure across subdomains is broadly in line with a model comprising 2 strongly correlated factors of self- and interpersonal functioning, with some notable deviations from the theoretical model; and (c) the joint structure of the Criterion A subdomains and the Criterion B facets broadly resembles the expected model of 2 plus 5 factors, albeit the loading pattern suggests that the distinction between Criteria A and B is somewhat blurry. Our findings provide support for several major assumptions of the alternative DSM–5 model for PD but also highlight aspects of the model that need to be further refined. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)",
    keywords = "maladaptive personality traits, personality functioning, item response theory, exploratory structural equation model, personality disorder",
    author = "Johannes Zimmermann and B{\"o}hnke, {Jan R} and Rhea Eschstruth and Alessa Mathews and Kristin Wenzel and Daniel Leising",
    year = "2015",
    month = "8",
    doi = "10.1037/abn0000059",
    language = "English",
    volume = "124",
    pages = "532--548",
    journal = "Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology",
    issn = "0091-0627",
    publisher = "International Society for Research in Child and Adolescent Psychopathology",
    number = "3",

    }

    The Latent Structure of Personality Functioning: Investigating Criterion A From the Alternative Model for Personality Disorders in DSM-5. / Zimmermann, Johannes; Böhnke, Jan R; Eschstruth, Rhea; Mathews, Alessa; Wenzel, Kristin; Leising, Daniel.

    In: Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, Vol. 124, No. 3, 08.2015, p. 532-548.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - The Latent Structure of Personality Functioning: Investigating Criterion A From the Alternative Model for Personality Disorders in DSM-5

    AU - Zimmermann, Johannes

    AU - Böhnke, Jan R

    AU - Eschstruth, Rhea

    AU - Mathews, Alessa

    AU - Wenzel, Kristin

    AU - Leising, Daniel

    PY - 2015/8

    Y1 - 2015/8

    N2 - The alternative model for the classification of personality disorders (PD) in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.; DSM–5) Section III comprises 2 major components: impairments in personality functioning (Criterion A) and maladaptive personality traits (Criterion B). In this study, we investigated the latent structure of Criterion A (a) within subdomains, (b) across subdomains, and (c) in conjunction with the Criterion B trait facets. Data were gathered as part of an online study that collected other-ratings by 515 laypersons and 145 therapists. Laypersons were asked to assess 1 of their personal acquaintances, whereas therapists were asked to assess 1 of their patients, using 135 items that captured features of Criteria A and B. We were able to show that (a) the structure within the Criterion A subdomains can be appropriately modeled using generalized graded unfolding models, with results suggesting that the items are indeed related to common underlying constructs but often deviate from their theoretically expected severity level; (b) the structure across subdomains is broadly in line with a model comprising 2 strongly correlated factors of self- and interpersonal functioning, with some notable deviations from the theoretical model; and (c) the joint structure of the Criterion A subdomains and the Criterion B facets broadly resembles the expected model of 2 plus 5 factors, albeit the loading pattern suggests that the distinction between Criteria A and B is somewhat blurry. Our findings provide support for several major assumptions of the alternative DSM–5 model for PD but also highlight aspects of the model that need to be further refined. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)

    AB - The alternative model for the classification of personality disorders (PD) in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.; DSM–5) Section III comprises 2 major components: impairments in personality functioning (Criterion A) and maladaptive personality traits (Criterion B). In this study, we investigated the latent structure of Criterion A (a) within subdomains, (b) across subdomains, and (c) in conjunction with the Criterion B trait facets. Data were gathered as part of an online study that collected other-ratings by 515 laypersons and 145 therapists. Laypersons were asked to assess 1 of their personal acquaintances, whereas therapists were asked to assess 1 of their patients, using 135 items that captured features of Criteria A and B. We were able to show that (a) the structure within the Criterion A subdomains can be appropriately modeled using generalized graded unfolding models, with results suggesting that the items are indeed related to common underlying constructs but often deviate from their theoretically expected severity level; (b) the structure across subdomains is broadly in line with a model comprising 2 strongly correlated factors of self- and interpersonal functioning, with some notable deviations from the theoretical model; and (c) the joint structure of the Criterion A subdomains and the Criterion B facets broadly resembles the expected model of 2 plus 5 factors, albeit the loading pattern suggests that the distinction between Criteria A and B is somewhat blurry. Our findings provide support for several major assumptions of the alternative DSM–5 model for PD but also highlight aspects of the model that need to be further refined. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)

    KW - maladaptive personality traits

    KW - personality functioning

    KW - item response theory

    KW - exploratory structural equation model

    KW - personality disorder

    U2 - 10.1037/abn0000059

    DO - 10.1037/abn0000059

    M3 - Article

    VL - 124

    SP - 532

    EP - 548

    JO - Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology

    JF - Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology

    SN - 0091-0627

    IS - 3

    ER -