The Legal Effect of the ‘Paris Rulebook’ under the Doctrine of Treaty Interpretation

Petra Minnerop (Lead / Corresponding author)

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

Abstract

This part of the book examines the legal effect of the so called Paris Rulebook under the doctrine of treaty interpretation. The Paris Rulebook is a composition of decisions and annexes, adopted by the ‘Conference of Parties serving as the Meeting of the Parties under the Paris Agreement’ (CMA) in Katowice in 2018. These further decisions play a significant role for the implementation of the Paris Agreement, which in itself does not explain in sufficient detail how Parties intend to achieve the ambitious temperature goal of holding the increase in the global average temperature to well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels, and more ambitiously, to 1.5°C. The role of the Paris Rulebook will be much greater if it can be shown that it has a decisive legal effect in accordance with general international law. In this chapter, the legal effect that the Paris Rulebook has for the implementation of the Paris Agreement is looked at on the basis of a conceptual analysis of Art. 31 of the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT). The International Law Commission (ILC) of the United Nations has adopted draft conclusions to establish the legal effect of subsequent agreements of Parties for the interpretation of a treaty, based on Art. 31 and Art. 32 of the VCLT. These draft conclusions offer analytical tools derived from state practice and international jurisprudence under Art. 31 VCLT. The interpretative effect of subsequent agreement of Parties on key parts of the Paris Agreement can thus be examined with these criteria recognised in international law and a legal effect on Parties’ nationally determined contributions (NDCs), their accounting for and reporting of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and the operation of the Paris Agreement’s oversight mechanism such as the so called ‘global stocktake’ and the compliance procedure can be identified.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationGlobal Energy in Transition
Subtitle of host publicationTowards rules-based multilateral governance of generation, markets and investment
EditorsP. Cameron, Y. Mu, V. Roeben
Chapter4
Number of pages32
Publication statusPublished - 2020

Fingerprint

treaty
doctrine
interpretation
Vienna
international law
Law
jurisprudence
UNO

Keywords

  • Paris Agreement
  • Paris Rulebook
  • Treaty Interpretation
  • Nationally Determined Contribution
  • Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties
  • International Law Commission

Cite this

Minnerop, P. (2020). The Legal Effect of the ‘Paris Rulebook’ under the Doctrine of Treaty Interpretation. In P. Cameron, Y. Mu, & V. Roeben (Eds.), Global Energy in Transition: Towards rules-based multilateral governance of generation, markets and investment
Minnerop, Petra . / The Legal Effect of the ‘Paris Rulebook’ under the Doctrine of Treaty Interpretation. Global Energy in Transition: Towards rules-based multilateral governance of generation, markets and investment. editor / P. Cameron ; Y. Mu ; V. Roeben. 2020.
@inbook{80b34545bf1a4c4482d6e9c4eb1b4f5d,
title = "The Legal Effect of the ‘Paris Rulebook’ under the Doctrine of Treaty Interpretation",
abstract = "This part of the book examines the legal effect of the so called Paris Rulebook under the doctrine of treaty interpretation. The Paris Rulebook is a composition of decisions and annexes, adopted by the ‘Conference of Parties serving as the Meeting of the Parties under the Paris Agreement’ (CMA) in Katowice in 2018. These further decisions play a significant role for the implementation of the Paris Agreement, which in itself does not explain in sufficient detail how Parties intend to achieve the ambitious temperature goal of holding the increase in the global average temperature to well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels, and more ambitiously, to 1.5°C. The role of the Paris Rulebook will be much greater if it can be shown that it has a decisive legal effect in accordance with general international law. In this chapter, the legal effect that the Paris Rulebook has for the implementation of the Paris Agreement is looked at on the basis of a conceptual analysis of Art. 31 of the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT). The International Law Commission (ILC) of the United Nations has adopted draft conclusions to establish the legal effect of subsequent agreements of Parties for the interpretation of a treaty, based on Art. 31 and Art. 32 of the VCLT. These draft conclusions offer analytical tools derived from state practice and international jurisprudence under Art. 31 VCLT. The interpretative effect of subsequent agreement of Parties on key parts of the Paris Agreement can thus be examined with these criteria recognised in international law and a legal effect on Parties’ nationally determined contributions (NDCs), their accounting for and reporting of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and the operation of the Paris Agreement’s oversight mechanism such as the so called ‘global stocktake’ and the compliance procedure can be identified.",
keywords = "Paris Agreement, Paris Rulebook, Treaty Interpretation, Nationally Determined Contribution, Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, International Law Commission",
author = "Petra Minnerop",
year = "2020",
language = "English",
editor = "P. Cameron and Y. Mu and V. Roeben",
booktitle = "Global Energy in Transition",

}

Minnerop, P 2020, The Legal Effect of the ‘Paris Rulebook’ under the Doctrine of Treaty Interpretation. in P Cameron, Y Mu & V Roeben (eds), Global Energy in Transition: Towards rules-based multilateral governance of generation, markets and investment.

The Legal Effect of the ‘Paris Rulebook’ under the Doctrine of Treaty Interpretation. / Minnerop, Petra (Lead / Corresponding author).

Global Energy in Transition: Towards rules-based multilateral governance of generation, markets and investment. ed. / P. Cameron; Y. Mu; V. Roeben. 2020.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

TY - CHAP

T1 - The Legal Effect of the ‘Paris Rulebook’ under the Doctrine of Treaty Interpretation

AU - Minnerop, Petra

PY - 2020

Y1 - 2020

N2 - This part of the book examines the legal effect of the so called Paris Rulebook under the doctrine of treaty interpretation. The Paris Rulebook is a composition of decisions and annexes, adopted by the ‘Conference of Parties serving as the Meeting of the Parties under the Paris Agreement’ (CMA) in Katowice in 2018. These further decisions play a significant role for the implementation of the Paris Agreement, which in itself does not explain in sufficient detail how Parties intend to achieve the ambitious temperature goal of holding the increase in the global average temperature to well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels, and more ambitiously, to 1.5°C. The role of the Paris Rulebook will be much greater if it can be shown that it has a decisive legal effect in accordance with general international law. In this chapter, the legal effect that the Paris Rulebook has for the implementation of the Paris Agreement is looked at on the basis of a conceptual analysis of Art. 31 of the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT). The International Law Commission (ILC) of the United Nations has adopted draft conclusions to establish the legal effect of subsequent agreements of Parties for the interpretation of a treaty, based on Art. 31 and Art. 32 of the VCLT. These draft conclusions offer analytical tools derived from state practice and international jurisprudence under Art. 31 VCLT. The interpretative effect of subsequent agreement of Parties on key parts of the Paris Agreement can thus be examined with these criteria recognised in international law and a legal effect on Parties’ nationally determined contributions (NDCs), their accounting for and reporting of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and the operation of the Paris Agreement’s oversight mechanism such as the so called ‘global stocktake’ and the compliance procedure can be identified.

AB - This part of the book examines the legal effect of the so called Paris Rulebook under the doctrine of treaty interpretation. The Paris Rulebook is a composition of decisions and annexes, adopted by the ‘Conference of Parties serving as the Meeting of the Parties under the Paris Agreement’ (CMA) in Katowice in 2018. These further decisions play a significant role for the implementation of the Paris Agreement, which in itself does not explain in sufficient detail how Parties intend to achieve the ambitious temperature goal of holding the increase in the global average temperature to well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels, and more ambitiously, to 1.5°C. The role of the Paris Rulebook will be much greater if it can be shown that it has a decisive legal effect in accordance with general international law. In this chapter, the legal effect that the Paris Rulebook has for the implementation of the Paris Agreement is looked at on the basis of a conceptual analysis of Art. 31 of the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT). The International Law Commission (ILC) of the United Nations has adopted draft conclusions to establish the legal effect of subsequent agreements of Parties for the interpretation of a treaty, based on Art. 31 and Art. 32 of the VCLT. These draft conclusions offer analytical tools derived from state practice and international jurisprudence under Art. 31 VCLT. The interpretative effect of subsequent agreement of Parties on key parts of the Paris Agreement can thus be examined with these criteria recognised in international law and a legal effect on Parties’ nationally determined contributions (NDCs), their accounting for and reporting of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and the operation of the Paris Agreement’s oversight mechanism such as the so called ‘global stocktake’ and the compliance procedure can be identified.

KW - Paris Agreement

KW - Paris Rulebook

KW - Treaty Interpretation

KW - Nationally Determined Contribution

KW - Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties

KW - International Law Commission

UR - https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3491775

M3 - Chapter (peer-reviewed)

BT - Global Energy in Transition

A2 - Cameron, P.

A2 - Mu, Y.

A2 - Roeben, V.

ER -

Minnerop P. The Legal Effect of the ‘Paris Rulebook’ under the Doctrine of Treaty Interpretation. In Cameron P, Mu Y, Roeben V, editors, Global Energy in Transition: Towards rules-based multilateral governance of generation, markets and investment. 2020