The politics and ethics of research into ‘wicked’ social problems: The case of Jimmy Savile at Duncroft

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

Abstract

While research is rarely neutral, some research topics are more sensitive than others. Child sexual abuse (CSA) is one such topic. With reference to a piece of research funded by the UK Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) to collate a database of information on the Savile case, drawing on a range of data sources such as social media content, official reports and interviews with former pupils and staff members from Duncroft, factors that were considered in conducting the research will be discussed. These are the role of reflexivity in thinking about one’s position in relation to research topic, how cultural scripts impact on what can and cannot be discussed as well as the power of stories or narratives in acceptance of a particular viewpoint. The act of engaging in such research can be represented as calling into question and further dismissing the accounts of those claiming abuse. Alternatively the project confronts major issues of justice related to the presumption of innocence, which need to be addressed by researchers.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationDesigning and Conducting Research in Social Science, Health and Social Care
EditorsFiona McSweeney, Dave Williams
PublisherTaylor & Francis
Chapter11
Number of pages13
Edition1
ISBN (Print)9781351245418
Publication statusPublished - 30 Jul 2019

Fingerprint

Social Problems
moral philosophy
politics
economic research
reflexivity
social media
social research
sexual violence
pupil
abuse
acceptance
justice
staff
narrative
interview

Cite this

Smith, M. (2019). The politics and ethics of research into ‘wicked’ social problems: The case of Jimmy Savile at Duncroft. In F. McSweeney, & D. Williams (Eds.), Designing and Conducting Research in Social Science, Health and Social Care (1 ed.). Taylor & Francis.
Smith, Mark. / The politics and ethics of research into ‘wicked’ social problems : The case of Jimmy Savile at Duncroft. Designing and Conducting Research in Social Science, Health and Social Care. editor / Fiona McSweeney ; Dave Williams. 1. ed. Taylor & Francis, 2019.
@inbook{4f21aecb7883498ba1dee6ea4fff74ab,
title = "The politics and ethics of research into ‘wicked’ social problems: The case of Jimmy Savile at Duncroft",
abstract = "While research is rarely neutral, some research topics are more sensitive than others. Child sexual abuse (CSA) is one such topic. With reference to a piece of research funded by the UK Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) to collate a database of information on the Savile case, drawing on a range of data sources such as social media content, official reports and interviews with former pupils and staff members from Duncroft, factors that were considered in conducting the research will be discussed. These are the role of reflexivity in thinking about one’s position in relation to research topic, how cultural scripts impact on what can and cannot be discussed as well as the power of stories or narratives in acceptance of a particular viewpoint. The act of engaging in such research can be represented as calling into question and further dismissing the accounts of those claiming abuse. Alternatively the project confronts major issues of justice related to the presumption of innocence, which need to be addressed by researchers.",
author = "Mark Smith",
year = "2019",
month = "7",
day = "30",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781351245418",
editor = "McSweeney, {Fiona } and Williams, {Dave }",
booktitle = "Designing and Conducting Research in Social Science, Health and Social Care",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
address = "United Kingdom",
edition = "1",

}

Smith, M 2019, The politics and ethics of research into ‘wicked’ social problems: The case of Jimmy Savile at Duncroft. in F McSweeney & D Williams (eds), Designing and Conducting Research in Social Science, Health and Social Care. 1 edn, Taylor & Francis.

The politics and ethics of research into ‘wicked’ social problems : The case of Jimmy Savile at Duncroft. / Smith, Mark.

Designing and Conducting Research in Social Science, Health and Social Care. ed. / Fiona McSweeney; Dave Williams. 1. ed. Taylor & Francis, 2019.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

TY - CHAP

T1 - The politics and ethics of research into ‘wicked’ social problems

T2 - The case of Jimmy Savile at Duncroft

AU - Smith, Mark

PY - 2019/7/30

Y1 - 2019/7/30

N2 - While research is rarely neutral, some research topics are more sensitive than others. Child sexual abuse (CSA) is one such topic. With reference to a piece of research funded by the UK Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) to collate a database of information on the Savile case, drawing on a range of data sources such as social media content, official reports and interviews with former pupils and staff members from Duncroft, factors that were considered in conducting the research will be discussed. These are the role of reflexivity in thinking about one’s position in relation to research topic, how cultural scripts impact on what can and cannot be discussed as well as the power of stories or narratives in acceptance of a particular viewpoint. The act of engaging in such research can be represented as calling into question and further dismissing the accounts of those claiming abuse. Alternatively the project confronts major issues of justice related to the presumption of innocence, which need to be addressed by researchers.

AB - While research is rarely neutral, some research topics are more sensitive than others. Child sexual abuse (CSA) is one such topic. With reference to a piece of research funded by the UK Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) to collate a database of information on the Savile case, drawing on a range of data sources such as social media content, official reports and interviews with former pupils and staff members from Duncroft, factors that were considered in conducting the research will be discussed. These are the role of reflexivity in thinking about one’s position in relation to research topic, how cultural scripts impact on what can and cannot be discussed as well as the power of stories or narratives in acceptance of a particular viewpoint. The act of engaging in such research can be represented as calling into question and further dismissing the accounts of those claiming abuse. Alternatively the project confronts major issues of justice related to the presumption of innocence, which need to be addressed by researchers.

M3 - Chapter (peer-reviewed)

SN - 9781351245418

BT - Designing and Conducting Research in Social Science, Health and Social Care

A2 - McSweeney, Fiona

A2 - Williams, Dave

PB - Taylor & Francis

ER -

Smith M. The politics and ethics of research into ‘wicked’ social problems: The case of Jimmy Savile at Duncroft. In McSweeney F, Williams D, editors, Designing and Conducting Research in Social Science, Health and Social Care. 1 ed. Taylor & Francis. 2019