The validity of the Spelling and Grammar Waiver as a reasonable accommodation in Leaving Certificate examinations in Ireland

Kate James (Lead / Corresponding author), Elizabeth F. S. Hannah

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)
78 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

In Ireland, dyslexic students can apply for reasonable accommodations in Leaving Certificate examinations. One such accommodation is the Spelling and Grammar Waiver (SGW). Questions have been raised regarding its validity, and it has been suggested that it gives an unfair advantage. Mock Leaving Certificate English paper scripts were collected from 31 dyslexic students who had been granted an SGW and 31 nondyslexic students who had not been granted any accommodations. All scripts were marked twice, eight weeks apart, by the same marker, once in the standard fashion and once with an SGW. Dyslexic students’ scripts marked with an SGW had a significantly higher mean score than when marked in the standard way, and it was similar to the mean unaccommodated score of nondyslexic students. However, nondyslexic students also received a similar boost in scores when accommodated. Two-way repeated measures ANOVA showed no “differential boost” for the dyslexic group, but a significant boost for both groups when accommodated. Results suggest that the SGW is not a valid accommodation but confers an advantage to those that have it. This study needs replication using larger numbers, with real Leaving Certificate scripts and examiners, and the reasons for the increase in scores also need investigation.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)138-147
Number of pages10
JournalInternational Journal of School and Educational Psychology
Volume6
Issue number2
Early online date9 Jun 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

Ireland
accommodation
certification
grammar
Students
examination
student
examiner
Analysis of Variance
Group

Keywords

  • Spelling and Grammar Waiver
  • assessment
  • dyslexia
  • reasonable accommodation
  • validity

Cite this

@article{5fe867b1d0314f07a8245b1a75c9b4fc,
title = "The validity of the Spelling and Grammar Waiver as a reasonable accommodation in Leaving Certificate examinations in Ireland",
abstract = "In Ireland, dyslexic students can apply for reasonable accommodations in Leaving Certificate examinations. One such accommodation is the Spelling and Grammar Waiver (SGW). Questions have been raised regarding its validity, and it has been suggested that it gives an unfair advantage. Mock Leaving Certificate English paper scripts were collected from 31 dyslexic students who had been granted an SGW and 31 nondyslexic students who had not been granted any accommodations. All scripts were marked twice, eight weeks apart, by the same marker, once in the standard fashion and once with an SGW. Dyslexic students’ scripts marked with an SGW had a significantly higher mean score than when marked in the standard way, and it was similar to the mean unaccommodated score of nondyslexic students. However, nondyslexic students also received a similar boost in scores when accommodated. Two-way repeated measures ANOVA showed no “differential boost” for the dyslexic group, but a significant boost for both groups when accommodated. Results suggest that the SGW is not a valid accommodation but confers an advantage to those that have it. This study needs replication using larger numbers, with real Leaving Certificate scripts and examiners, and the reasons for the increase in scores also need investigation.",
keywords = "Spelling and Grammar Waiver, assessment, dyslexia, reasonable accommodation, validity",
author = "Kate James and Hannah, {Elizabeth F. S.}",
note = "No funding info",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1080/21683603.2017.1302848",
language = "English",
volume = "6",
pages = "138--147",
journal = "International Journal of School and Educational Psychology",
issn = "2168-3603",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The validity of the Spelling and Grammar Waiver as a reasonable accommodation in Leaving Certificate examinations in Ireland

AU - James, Kate

AU - Hannah, Elizabeth F. S.

N1 - No funding info

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - In Ireland, dyslexic students can apply for reasonable accommodations in Leaving Certificate examinations. One such accommodation is the Spelling and Grammar Waiver (SGW). Questions have been raised regarding its validity, and it has been suggested that it gives an unfair advantage. Mock Leaving Certificate English paper scripts were collected from 31 dyslexic students who had been granted an SGW and 31 nondyslexic students who had not been granted any accommodations. All scripts were marked twice, eight weeks apart, by the same marker, once in the standard fashion and once with an SGW. Dyslexic students’ scripts marked with an SGW had a significantly higher mean score than when marked in the standard way, and it was similar to the mean unaccommodated score of nondyslexic students. However, nondyslexic students also received a similar boost in scores when accommodated. Two-way repeated measures ANOVA showed no “differential boost” for the dyslexic group, but a significant boost for both groups when accommodated. Results suggest that the SGW is not a valid accommodation but confers an advantage to those that have it. This study needs replication using larger numbers, with real Leaving Certificate scripts and examiners, and the reasons for the increase in scores also need investigation.

AB - In Ireland, dyslexic students can apply for reasonable accommodations in Leaving Certificate examinations. One such accommodation is the Spelling and Grammar Waiver (SGW). Questions have been raised regarding its validity, and it has been suggested that it gives an unfair advantage. Mock Leaving Certificate English paper scripts were collected from 31 dyslexic students who had been granted an SGW and 31 nondyslexic students who had not been granted any accommodations. All scripts were marked twice, eight weeks apart, by the same marker, once in the standard fashion and once with an SGW. Dyslexic students’ scripts marked with an SGW had a significantly higher mean score than when marked in the standard way, and it was similar to the mean unaccommodated score of nondyslexic students. However, nondyslexic students also received a similar boost in scores when accommodated. Two-way repeated measures ANOVA showed no “differential boost” for the dyslexic group, but a significant boost for both groups when accommodated. Results suggest that the SGW is not a valid accommodation but confers an advantage to those that have it. This study needs replication using larger numbers, with real Leaving Certificate scripts and examiners, and the reasons for the increase in scores also need investigation.

KW - Spelling and Grammar Waiver

KW - assessment

KW - dyslexia

KW - reasonable accommodation

KW - validity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85050749044&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/21683603.2017.1302848

DO - 10.1080/21683603.2017.1302848

M3 - Article

VL - 6

SP - 138

EP - 147

JO - International Journal of School and Educational Psychology

JF - International Journal of School and Educational Psychology

SN - 2168-3603

IS - 2

ER -