“They are not going to be able to copy this”: Fighting the cooperative corner and creating third spaces of cooperation in food and farming

Raquel Ajates Gonzalez (Lead / Corresponding author)

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

4 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Cooperatives can be deconstructed into four components: legal form, governance model, social movement and informal cooperative behaviours that predate all other layers. In the case of agricultural cooperatives, this multifaceted character is increasingly being fragmented by the mainstream food system that is co-opting the less radical elements of cooperativism that can be easily absorbed without requiring a wider transformation of neoliberal industrial practices. This paper explores the activities of niche cooperatives in the UK and Spain experimenting with creative models of governance, finance and multilevel crosscutting collaborations attempting to fight back and reduce the risk of appropriation by the dominant regime. Using case study methodology, data from document analysis and over 40 interviews are presented. Drawing from the anthropological concept of “third space” and the permaculture principle that commends us to “use edges and value the marginal”, I argue that these initiatives are creating both real and symbolic spaces that foster growers’ and consumers’ self-efficacy to construct more inclusive and sustainable cooperative models. These social experiments not only disrupt and reframe the “professional agricultural cooperative” imaginary, but also reaffirm the infinite creativity of people to reinvent their food systems.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress
Subtitle of host publicationPlaces of Possibility? Rural Societies in a Neoliberal World
EditorsL-A. Sutherland, K. Brown, M. Currie, R. do Carmo, J. Duncan, M. Kohe, A. Koutsouris, R. B. Larsen, D. Maye, E. Noe, T. Oedl-Wieser, L. Philip, P. Pospěch, E. D. Rasch, M. J. Rivera, M. Schermer, S. Shortall, P. Starosta, S. Sumane, R. Wilkie, M. Woods
Place of PublicationAberdeen
PublisherJames Hutton Institute
Pages1-2
Number of pages2
ISBN (Electronic)9780902701144
Publication statusPublished - 18 Aug 2015
EventThe XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress: Places of Possibility? Rural Societies in a Neoliberal World - James Hutton Institute, Abeerden, United Kingdom
Duration: 18 Aug 201521 Aug 2015
http://esrs2015.hutton.ac.uk/places-possibility-rural-societies-neoliberal-world

Conference

ConferenceThe XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityAbeerden
Period18/08/1521/08/15
Internet address

Fingerprint

agricultural cooperative
food
governance
legal form
cooperative behavior
document analysis
social movement
self-efficacy
creativity
finance
Spain
regime
experiment
methodology
interview
Values

Keywords

  • third space
  • cooperative
  • social movements
  • alternative food networks
  • co-optation
  • deviant mainstreaming
  • incremental radicalism

Cite this

Ajates Gonzalez, R. (2015). “They are not going to be able to copy this”: Fighting the cooperative corner and creating third spaces of cooperation in food and farming. In L-A. Sutherland, K. Brown, M. Currie, R. do Carmo, J. Duncan, M. Kohe, A. Koutsouris, R. B. Larsen, D. Maye, E. Noe, T. Oedl-Wieser, L. Philip, P. Pospěch, E. D. Rasch, M. J. Rivera, M. Schermer, S. Shortall, P. Starosta, S. Sumane, R. Wilkie, ... M. Woods (Eds.), Proceedings of the XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress: Places of Possibility? Rural Societies in a Neoliberal World (pp. 1-2). Aberdeen: James Hutton Institute.
Ajates Gonzalez, Raquel. / “They are not going to be able to copy this” : Fighting the cooperative corner and creating third spaces of cooperation in food and farming. Proceedings of the XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress: Places of Possibility? Rural Societies in a Neoliberal World. editor / L-A. Sutherland ; K. Brown ; M. Currie ; R. do Carmo ; J. Duncan ; M. Kohe ; A. Koutsouris ; R. B. Larsen ; D. Maye ; E. Noe ; T. Oedl-Wieser ; L. Philip ; P. Pospěch ; E. D. Rasch ; M. J. Rivera ; M. Schermer ; S. Shortall ; P. Starosta ; S. Sumane ; R. Wilkie ; M. Woods. Aberdeen : James Hutton Institute, 2015. pp. 1-2
@inproceedings{6d9f430c831e46ae8480bebd3cce0290,
title = "“They are not going to be able to copy this”: Fighting the cooperative corner and creating third spaces of cooperation in food and farming",
abstract = "Cooperatives can be deconstructed into four components: legal form, governance model, social movement and informal cooperative behaviours that predate all other layers. In the case of agricultural cooperatives, this multifaceted character is increasingly being fragmented by the mainstream food system that is co-opting the less radical elements of cooperativism that can be easily absorbed without requiring a wider transformation of neoliberal industrial practices. This paper explores the activities of niche cooperatives in the UK and Spain experimenting with creative models of governance, finance and multilevel crosscutting collaborations attempting to fight back and reduce the risk of appropriation by the dominant regime. Using case study methodology, data from document analysis and over 40 interviews are presented. Drawing from the anthropological concept of “third space” and the permaculture principle that commends us to “use edges and value the marginal”, I argue that these initiatives are creating both real and symbolic spaces that foster growers’ and consumers’ self-efficacy to construct more inclusive and sustainable cooperative models. These social experiments not only disrupt and reframe the “professional agricultural cooperative” imaginary, but also reaffirm the infinite creativity of people to reinvent their food systems.",
keywords = "third space, cooperative, social movements, alternative food networks, co-optation, deviant mainstreaming, incremental radicalism",
author = "{Ajates Gonzalez}, Raquel",
note = "Winner of Sociologia Ruralis Student Paper Competition",
year = "2015",
month = "8",
day = "18",
language = "English",
pages = "1--2",
editor = "L-A. Sutherland and K. Brown and M. Currie and {do Carmo}, R. and J. Duncan and M. Kohe and A. Koutsouris and Larsen, {R. B.} and D. Maye and E. Noe and T. Oedl-Wieser and L. Philip and P. Pospěch and Rasch, {E. D.} and Rivera, {M. J.} and M. Schermer and S. Shortall and P. Starosta and S. Sumane and R. Wilkie and M. Woods",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress",
publisher = "James Hutton Institute",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

Ajates Gonzalez, R 2015, “They are not going to be able to copy this”: Fighting the cooperative corner and creating third spaces of cooperation in food and farming. in L-A Sutherland, K Brown, M Currie, R do Carmo, J Duncan, M Kohe, A Koutsouris, RB Larsen, D Maye, E Noe, T Oedl-Wieser, L Philip, P Pospěch, ED Rasch, MJ Rivera, M Schermer, S Shortall, P Starosta, S Sumane, R Wilkie & M Woods (eds), Proceedings of the XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress: Places of Possibility? Rural Societies in a Neoliberal World. James Hutton Institute, Aberdeen, pp. 1-2, The XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress, Abeerden, United Kingdom, 18/08/15.

“They are not going to be able to copy this” : Fighting the cooperative corner and creating third spaces of cooperation in food and farming. / Ajates Gonzalez, Raquel (Lead / Corresponding author).

Proceedings of the XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress: Places of Possibility? Rural Societies in a Neoliberal World. ed. / L-A. Sutherland; K. Brown; M. Currie; R. do Carmo; J. Duncan; M. Kohe; A. Koutsouris; R. B. Larsen; D. Maye; E. Noe; T. Oedl-Wieser; L. Philip; P. Pospěch; E. D. Rasch; M. J. Rivera; M. Schermer; S. Shortall; P. Starosta; S. Sumane; R. Wilkie; M. Woods. Aberdeen : James Hutton Institute, 2015. p. 1-2.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - “They are not going to be able to copy this”

T2 - Fighting the cooperative corner and creating third spaces of cooperation in food and farming

AU - Ajates Gonzalez, Raquel

N1 - Winner of Sociologia Ruralis Student Paper Competition

PY - 2015/8/18

Y1 - 2015/8/18

N2 - Cooperatives can be deconstructed into four components: legal form, governance model, social movement and informal cooperative behaviours that predate all other layers. In the case of agricultural cooperatives, this multifaceted character is increasingly being fragmented by the mainstream food system that is co-opting the less radical elements of cooperativism that can be easily absorbed without requiring a wider transformation of neoliberal industrial practices. This paper explores the activities of niche cooperatives in the UK and Spain experimenting with creative models of governance, finance and multilevel crosscutting collaborations attempting to fight back and reduce the risk of appropriation by the dominant regime. Using case study methodology, data from document analysis and over 40 interviews are presented. Drawing from the anthropological concept of “third space” and the permaculture principle that commends us to “use edges and value the marginal”, I argue that these initiatives are creating both real and symbolic spaces that foster growers’ and consumers’ self-efficacy to construct more inclusive and sustainable cooperative models. These social experiments not only disrupt and reframe the “professional agricultural cooperative” imaginary, but also reaffirm the infinite creativity of people to reinvent their food systems.

AB - Cooperatives can be deconstructed into four components: legal form, governance model, social movement and informal cooperative behaviours that predate all other layers. In the case of agricultural cooperatives, this multifaceted character is increasingly being fragmented by the mainstream food system that is co-opting the less radical elements of cooperativism that can be easily absorbed without requiring a wider transformation of neoliberal industrial practices. This paper explores the activities of niche cooperatives in the UK and Spain experimenting with creative models of governance, finance and multilevel crosscutting collaborations attempting to fight back and reduce the risk of appropriation by the dominant regime. Using case study methodology, data from document analysis and over 40 interviews are presented. Drawing from the anthropological concept of “third space” and the permaculture principle that commends us to “use edges and value the marginal”, I argue that these initiatives are creating both real and symbolic spaces that foster growers’ and consumers’ self-efficacy to construct more inclusive and sustainable cooperative models. These social experiments not only disrupt and reframe the “professional agricultural cooperative” imaginary, but also reaffirm the infinite creativity of people to reinvent their food systems.

KW - third space

KW - cooperative

KW - social movements

KW - alternative food networks

KW - co-optation

KW - deviant mainstreaming

KW - incremental radicalism

UR - http://esrs2015.hutton.ac.uk/news/final-congress-proceedings

UR - http://esrs2015.hutton.ac.uk/places-possibility-rural-societies-neoliberal-world

M3 - Conference contribution

SP - 1

EP - 2

BT - Proceedings of the XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress

A2 - Sutherland, L-A.

A2 - Brown, K.

A2 - Currie, M.

A2 - do Carmo, R.

A2 - Duncan, J.

A2 - Kohe, M.

A2 - Koutsouris, A.

A2 - Larsen, R. B.

A2 - Maye, D.

A2 - Noe, E.

A2 - Oedl-Wieser, T.

A2 - Philip, L.

A2 - Pospěch, P.

A2 - Rasch, E. D.

A2 - Rivera, M. J.

A2 - Schermer, M.

A2 - Shortall, S.

A2 - Starosta, P.

A2 - Sumane, S.

A2 - Wilkie, R.

A2 - Woods, M.

PB - James Hutton Institute

CY - Aberdeen

ER -

Ajates Gonzalez R. “They are not going to be able to copy this”: Fighting the cooperative corner and creating third spaces of cooperation in food and farming. In Sutherland L-A, Brown K, Currie M, do Carmo R, Duncan J, Kohe M, Koutsouris A, Larsen RB, Maye D, Noe E, Oedl-Wieser T, Philip L, Pospěch P, Rasch ED, Rivera MJ, Schermer M, Shortall S, Starosta P, Sumane S, Wilkie R, Woods M, editors, Proceedings of the XXVI European Society for Rural Sociology Congress: Places of Possibility? Rural Societies in a Neoliberal World. Aberdeen: James Hutton Institute. 2015. p. 1-2