Unit manager perspectives of a trauma-specific programme across Scotland’s secure estate

Ian Barron (Lead / Corresponding author), David Mitchell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
98 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Purpose
The current case study sought to assess unit manager perspectives on the introduction of a group-based trauma-specific programme delivered across Scotland’s secure estate. As this was the first time such an estate-wide initiative had occurred, it was important to identify the benefits/challenges at a strategic level.

Design/methodology/approach
An exploratory qualitative case study was utilized involving semi-structured interviews with five senior unit managers in three secure units to discover their perceptions of the benefits and challenges of implementing Teaching Recovery Techniques. A quasi-qualitative analysis was used to quantify and give meaning to manager responses. Inter-rater reliability of analysis was assessed.

Findings
Unit managers perceived gains in trauma-informed knowledge for themselves, and knowledge and skills gains for programme workers, care staff and adolescents. Challenges involved: managing a shift in paradigm to include a trauma-specific programme; the limiting context of competitive tendering; short duration placements; and the need for psycho-education for staff, parents, and agencies.

Research limitations/implications
Large sample sizes are likely to identify further issues for unit managers. Manager perceptions need directly compared with staff and adolescent perceptions and included in randomised control trials of trauma-specific programmes.

Practical implications
Managers perceived TRT needed to be delivered within trauma-informed organizations and identified the need for manager training in traumatization, trauma recovery and organizational implications to guide strategic planning. Managers emphasised the need for psycho-education for families, staff and agencies.

Originality/value
The current study is the first in Scotland to explore unit manager experience of introducing a trauma-specific programme across the secure estate.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)271-287
Number of pages17
JournalJournal of Children’s Services
Volume12
Issue number4
Early online date2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

Scotland
trauma
manager
Wounds and Injuries
staff
Education
adolescent
Sample Size
Teaching
strategic planning
Parents
Organizations
Interviews
education
parents
paradigm
worker
Research
methodology
interview

Keywords

  • secure units
  • Traumatisation
  • youth
  • recovery
  • trauma-specific programmes
  • Managers

Cite this

@article{85fe60ce22a343b2b5a6e42be279d7f7,
title = "Unit manager perspectives of a trauma-specific programme across Scotland’s secure estate",
abstract = "PurposeThe current case study sought to assess unit manager perspectives on the introduction of a group-based trauma-specific programme delivered across Scotland’s secure estate. As this was the first time such an estate-wide initiative had occurred, it was important to identify the benefits/challenges at a strategic level.Design/methodology/approachAn exploratory qualitative case study was utilized involving semi-structured interviews with five senior unit managers in three secure units to discover their perceptions of the benefits and challenges of implementing Teaching Recovery Techniques. A quasi-qualitative analysis was used to quantify and give meaning to manager responses. Inter-rater reliability of analysis was assessed.FindingsUnit managers perceived gains in trauma-informed knowledge for themselves, and knowledge and skills gains for programme workers, care staff and adolescents. Challenges involved: managing a shift in paradigm to include a trauma-specific programme; the limiting context of competitive tendering; short duration placements; and the need for psycho-education for staff, parents, and agencies.Research limitations/implicationsLarge sample sizes are likely to identify further issues for unit managers. Manager perceptions need directly compared with staff and adolescent perceptions and included in randomised control trials of trauma-specific programmes.Practical implicationsManagers perceived TRT needed to be delivered within trauma-informed organizations and identified the need for manager training in traumatization, trauma recovery and organizational implications to guide strategic planning. Managers emphasised the need for psycho-education for families, staff and agencies.Originality/valueThe current study is the first in Scotland to explore unit manager experience of introducing a trauma-specific programme across the secure estate.",
keywords = "secure units, Traumatisation, youth, recovery, trauma-specific programmes, Managers",
author = "Ian Barron and David Mitchell",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.1108/JCS-04-2017-0012",
language = "English",
volume = "12",
pages = "271--287",
journal = "Journal of Children’s Services",
issn = "1746-6660",
publisher = "Emerald",
number = "4",

}

Unit manager perspectives of a trauma-specific programme across Scotland’s secure estate. / Barron, Ian (Lead / Corresponding author); Mitchell, David.

In: Journal of Children’s Services, Vol. 12, No. 4, 2017, p. 271-287.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Unit manager perspectives of a trauma-specific programme across Scotland’s secure estate

AU - Barron, Ian

AU - Mitchell, David

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - PurposeThe current case study sought to assess unit manager perspectives on the introduction of a group-based trauma-specific programme delivered across Scotland’s secure estate. As this was the first time such an estate-wide initiative had occurred, it was important to identify the benefits/challenges at a strategic level.Design/methodology/approachAn exploratory qualitative case study was utilized involving semi-structured interviews with five senior unit managers in three secure units to discover their perceptions of the benefits and challenges of implementing Teaching Recovery Techniques. A quasi-qualitative analysis was used to quantify and give meaning to manager responses. Inter-rater reliability of analysis was assessed.FindingsUnit managers perceived gains in trauma-informed knowledge for themselves, and knowledge and skills gains for programme workers, care staff and adolescents. Challenges involved: managing a shift in paradigm to include a trauma-specific programme; the limiting context of competitive tendering; short duration placements; and the need for psycho-education for staff, parents, and agencies.Research limitations/implicationsLarge sample sizes are likely to identify further issues for unit managers. Manager perceptions need directly compared with staff and adolescent perceptions and included in randomised control trials of trauma-specific programmes.Practical implicationsManagers perceived TRT needed to be delivered within trauma-informed organizations and identified the need for manager training in traumatization, trauma recovery and organizational implications to guide strategic planning. Managers emphasised the need for psycho-education for families, staff and agencies.Originality/valueThe current study is the first in Scotland to explore unit manager experience of introducing a trauma-specific programme across the secure estate.

AB - PurposeThe current case study sought to assess unit manager perspectives on the introduction of a group-based trauma-specific programme delivered across Scotland’s secure estate. As this was the first time such an estate-wide initiative had occurred, it was important to identify the benefits/challenges at a strategic level.Design/methodology/approachAn exploratory qualitative case study was utilized involving semi-structured interviews with five senior unit managers in three secure units to discover their perceptions of the benefits and challenges of implementing Teaching Recovery Techniques. A quasi-qualitative analysis was used to quantify and give meaning to manager responses. Inter-rater reliability of analysis was assessed.FindingsUnit managers perceived gains in trauma-informed knowledge for themselves, and knowledge and skills gains for programme workers, care staff and adolescents. Challenges involved: managing a shift in paradigm to include a trauma-specific programme; the limiting context of competitive tendering; short duration placements; and the need for psycho-education for staff, parents, and agencies.Research limitations/implicationsLarge sample sizes are likely to identify further issues for unit managers. Manager perceptions need directly compared with staff and adolescent perceptions and included in randomised control trials of trauma-specific programmes.Practical implicationsManagers perceived TRT needed to be delivered within trauma-informed organizations and identified the need for manager training in traumatization, trauma recovery and organizational implications to guide strategic planning. Managers emphasised the need for psycho-education for families, staff and agencies.Originality/valueThe current study is the first in Scotland to explore unit manager experience of introducing a trauma-specific programme across the secure estate.

KW - secure units

KW - Traumatisation

KW - youth

KW - recovery

KW - trauma-specific programmes

KW - Managers

U2 - 10.1108/JCS-04-2017-0012

DO - 10.1108/JCS-04-2017-0012

M3 - Article

VL - 12

SP - 271

EP - 287

JO - Journal of Children’s Services

JF - Journal of Children’s Services

SN - 1746-6660

IS - 4

ER -