Unpacking Willpower in Unassisted Smoking Cessation: A Qualitative Analysis Reveals a Systematic Profile of Situational and Cognitive Strategies

TY - JOUR

T1 - Unpacking Willpower in Unassisted Smoking Cessation

T2 - A Qualitative Analysis Reveals a Systematic Profile of Situational and Cognitive Strategies

AU - Marathia, Effie

AU - Duffy, Sheila

AU - Stephen, Abigail

AU - More, Kimberly R.

AU - Saunders, Blair

N1 - Copyright: © 2026 The Author(s).

PY - 2026/3/14

Y1 - 2026/3/14

N2 - Background: Over half of those who quit smoking do so without formal assistance, yet the psychological processes supporting unassisted cessation remain little understood. Success is often attributed to willpower, an umbrella term that lacks explanatory precision and obscures the underlying tractable processes. Drawing on the Process Model of Self-Regulation and the Behavior Change Technique (BCT) Taxonomy, this study aimed to identify the concrete strategies that enable individuals to quit smoking unassisted, thereby clarifying what willpower might look like in practice.Materials and methods: Thirty-two participants who had successfully quit smoking without formal support participated in semi-structured interviews. Inductive content analysis identified key challenges, while deductive coding mapped strategies addressing these challenges to the Process Model of Self-Regulation and the BCT Taxonomy.Results: Participants’ accounts reflected a diverse range of strategies, averaging seven distinct BCTs, spanning the Situation Selection and Modification, Attention Redeployment, and Cognitive Change stages from the Process Model. Common BCTs included avoiding environmental triggers, substituting smoking with alternative behaviors, and seeking social support. In contrast, Response Modulation (e.g. ‘just say no’) accounted for only 1% of the data.Conclusion: Unassisted quitters drew from a sophisticated repertoire of strategies that are actionable, teachable, and embedded within the individual’s physical and social environment. The qualitative methodology used in this study offers an understanding of the lived experiences of self-quitters, potentially informing public health interventions that integrate individual and system-level approaches to behavior change that extend beyond brute-force willpower.

AB - Background: Over half of those who quit smoking do so without formal assistance, yet the psychological processes supporting unassisted cessation remain little understood. Success is often attributed to willpower, an umbrella term that lacks explanatory precision and obscures the underlying tractable processes. Drawing on the Process Model of Self-Regulation and the Behavior Change Technique (BCT) Taxonomy, this study aimed to identify the concrete strategies that enable individuals to quit smoking unassisted, thereby clarifying what willpower might look like in practice.Materials and methods: Thirty-two participants who had successfully quit smoking without formal support participated in semi-structured interviews. Inductive content analysis identified key challenges, while deductive coding mapped strategies addressing these challenges to the Process Model of Self-Regulation and the BCT Taxonomy.Results: Participants’ accounts reflected a diverse range of strategies, averaging seven distinct BCTs, spanning the Situation Selection and Modification, Attention Redeployment, and Cognitive Change stages from the Process Model. Common BCTs included avoiding environmental triggers, substituting smoking with alternative behaviors, and seeking social support. In contrast, Response Modulation (e.g. ‘just say no’) accounted for only 1% of the data.Conclusion: Unassisted quitters drew from a sophisticated repertoire of strategies that are actionable, teachable, and embedded within the individual’s physical and social environment. The qualitative methodology used in this study offers an understanding of the lived experiences of self-quitters, potentially informing public health interventions that integrate individual and system-level approaches to behavior change that extend beyond brute-force willpower.

KW - Unassisted smoking cessation

KW - self-regulation strategies

KW - behavior change techniques

KW - public health policy

U2 - 10.1080/21642850.2026.2644658

DO - 10.1080/21642850.2026.2644658

M3 - Article

C2 - 41847217

SN - 2164-2850

VL - 14

JO - Health Psychology and Behavioral Medicine

JF - Health Psychology and Behavioral Medicine

IS - 1

M1 - 2644658

ER -