Urgent need to clarify the definition of chronic critical limb ischemia - a position paper from the European Society for Vascular Medicine

European Society for Vascular Medicine, Joël Constans (Lead / Corresponding author), Alessandra Bura-Rivière, Adriana Visona, Marianne Brodmann, Pierre Abraham, Dan-Mircea Olinic, Juraj Madaric, Sabine Steiner, Isabelle Quéré, Lucia Mazzolai, Jill Belch

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Summary: Chronic critical lower limb ischemia (CLI) has been defined as ischemia that endangers the leg. An attempt was made to give a precise definition of CLI, based on clinical and hemodynamic data (Second European Consensus). CLI may be easily defined from a clinical point of view as rest pain of the distal foot or gangrene or ulceration. It is probably useful to add leg ulcers of other origin which do not heal because of severe ischemia, and to consider the impact of frailty on adverse outcome. From a hemodynamic viewpoint there is no consensus and most of the existing classifications are not based upon evidence. We should thus propose a definition and then validate it in a prospective cohort in order to define the patients at major risk of amputation, and also to define the categories of patients whose prognosis is improved by revascularisation. From to-day’s available data, it seems clear that the patients with a systolic toe pressure (STP) below 30 mmHg must be revascular-ised whenever possible. However other patients with clinically suspected CLI and STP above 30 mmHg must be evaluated and treated in specialised vascular units and revascularisation has to be discussed on a case by case basis, taking into account other data such as the WiFi classification for ulcers.In conclusion, many useful but at times contradictory definitions of CLI have been suggested. Only a few have taken into account evidence, and none have been validated prospectively. This paper aims to address this and to give notice that a CLI registry within Europe will be set up to prospectively validate, or not, the previous and suggested definitions of CLI.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)223-227
Number of pages5
JournalVASA
Volume48
Issue number3
Early online date19 Nov 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 19 May 2019

Fingerprint

Cardiology
Ischemia
Extremities
Lower Extremity
Toes
Consensus
Hemodynamics
Blood Pressure
Leg Ulcer
Gangrene
Amputation
Ulcer
Blood Vessels
Registries
Foot
Leg
Pain

Keywords

  • Critical limb ischemia
  • ankle pressure
  • definition
  • oxygen transcutaneous pressure
  • peripheral arterial disease
  • toe pressure

Cite this

European Society for Vascular Medicine, Constans, J., Bura-Rivière, A., Visona, A., Brodmann, M., Abraham, P., ... Belch, J. (2019). Urgent need to clarify the definition of chronic critical limb ischemia - a position paper from the European Society for Vascular Medicine. VASA, 48(3), 223-227. https://doi.org/10.1024/0301-1526/a000764
European Society for Vascular Medicine ; Constans, Joël ; Bura-Rivière, Alessandra ; Visona, Adriana ; Brodmann, Marianne ; Abraham, Pierre ; Olinic, Dan-Mircea ; Madaric, Juraj ; Steiner, Sabine ; Quéré, Isabelle ; Mazzolai, Lucia ; Belch, Jill. / Urgent need to clarify the definition of chronic critical limb ischemia - a position paper from the European Society for Vascular Medicine. In: VASA. 2019 ; Vol. 48, No. 3. pp. 223-227.
@article{bb09d2b831224b4f97c2a67ce006fbc5,
title = "Urgent need to clarify the definition of chronic critical limb ischemia - a position paper from the European Society for Vascular Medicine",
abstract = "Summary: Chronic critical lower limb ischemia (CLI) has been defined as ischemia that endangers the leg. An attempt was made to give a precise definition of CLI, based on clinical and hemodynamic data (Second European Consensus). CLI may be easily defined from a clinical point of view as rest pain of the distal foot or gangrene or ulceration. It is probably useful to add leg ulcers of other origin which do not heal because of severe ischemia, and to consider the impact of frailty on adverse outcome. From a hemodynamic viewpoint there is no consensus and most of the existing classifications are not based upon evidence. We should thus propose a definition and then validate it in a prospective cohort in order to define the patients at major risk of amputation, and also to define the categories of patients whose prognosis is improved by revascularisation. From to-day’s available data, it seems clear that the patients with a systolic toe pressure (STP) below 30 mmHg must be revascular-ised whenever possible. However other patients with clinically suspected CLI and STP above 30 mmHg must be evaluated and treated in specialised vascular units and revascularisation has to be discussed on a case by case basis, taking into account other data such as the WiFi classification for ulcers.In conclusion, many useful but at times contradictory definitions of CLI have been suggested. Only a few have taken into account evidence, and none have been validated prospectively. This paper aims to address this and to give notice that a CLI registry within Europe will be set up to prospectively validate, or not, the previous and suggested definitions of CLI.",
keywords = "Critical limb ischemia, ankle pressure, definition, oxygen transcutaneous pressure, peripheral arterial disease, toe pressure",
author = "{European Society for Vascular Medicine} and Jo{\"e}l Constans and Alessandra Bura-Rivi{\`e}re and Adriana Visona and Marianne Brodmann and Pierre Abraham and Dan-Mircea Olinic and Juraj Madaric and Sabine Steiner and Isabelle Qu{\'e}r{\'e} and Lucia Mazzolai and Jill Belch and Christian Heiss and Zsolt P{\'e}csv{\'a}rady and Karel Roztocil and Mary-Paula Colgan and Dragan Vasic and Anders Gotts{\"a}ter and Evangelos Dimakakos and Ali Chraim and Pavel Poredoš and Carpentier, {Patrick H.} and Jean-Claude Wautrecht and Agata Stanek and Vinco Boc",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
day = "19",
doi = "10.1024/0301-1526/a000764",
language = "English",
volume = "48",
pages = "223--227",
journal = "VASA",
issn = "0301-1526",
publisher = "Hogrefe Verlag",
number = "3",

}

European Society for Vascular Medicine, Constans, J, Bura-Rivière, A, Visona, A, Brodmann, M, Abraham, P, Olinic, D-M, Madaric, J, Steiner, S, Quéré, I, Mazzolai, L & Belch, J 2019, 'Urgent need to clarify the definition of chronic critical limb ischemia - a position paper from the European Society for Vascular Medicine', VASA, vol. 48, no. 3, pp. 223-227. https://doi.org/10.1024/0301-1526/a000764

Urgent need to clarify the definition of chronic critical limb ischemia - a position paper from the European Society for Vascular Medicine. / European Society for Vascular Medicine; Constans, Joël (Lead / Corresponding author); Bura-Rivière, Alessandra; Visona, Adriana; Brodmann, Marianne; Abraham, Pierre; Olinic, Dan-Mircea; Madaric, Juraj; Steiner, Sabine; Quéré, Isabelle; Mazzolai, Lucia; Belch, Jill.

In: VASA, Vol. 48, No. 3, 19.05.2019, p. 223-227.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Urgent need to clarify the definition of chronic critical limb ischemia - a position paper from the European Society for Vascular Medicine

AU - European Society for Vascular Medicine

AU - Constans, Joël

AU - Bura-Rivière, Alessandra

AU - Visona, Adriana

AU - Brodmann, Marianne

AU - Abraham, Pierre

AU - Olinic, Dan-Mircea

AU - Madaric, Juraj

AU - Steiner, Sabine

AU - Quéré, Isabelle

AU - Mazzolai, Lucia

AU - Belch, Jill

AU - Heiss, Christian

AU - Pécsvárady, Zsolt

AU - Roztocil, Karel

AU - Colgan, Mary-Paula

AU - Vasic, Dragan

AU - Gottsäter, Anders

AU - Dimakakos, Evangelos

AU - Chraim, Ali

AU - Poredoš, Pavel

AU - Carpentier, Patrick H.

AU - Wautrecht, Jean-Claude

AU - Stanek, Agata

AU - Boc, Vinco

PY - 2019/5/19

Y1 - 2019/5/19

N2 - Summary: Chronic critical lower limb ischemia (CLI) has been defined as ischemia that endangers the leg. An attempt was made to give a precise definition of CLI, based on clinical and hemodynamic data (Second European Consensus). CLI may be easily defined from a clinical point of view as rest pain of the distal foot or gangrene or ulceration. It is probably useful to add leg ulcers of other origin which do not heal because of severe ischemia, and to consider the impact of frailty on adverse outcome. From a hemodynamic viewpoint there is no consensus and most of the existing classifications are not based upon evidence. We should thus propose a definition and then validate it in a prospective cohort in order to define the patients at major risk of amputation, and also to define the categories of patients whose prognosis is improved by revascularisation. From to-day’s available data, it seems clear that the patients with a systolic toe pressure (STP) below 30 mmHg must be revascular-ised whenever possible. However other patients with clinically suspected CLI and STP above 30 mmHg must be evaluated and treated in specialised vascular units and revascularisation has to be discussed on a case by case basis, taking into account other data such as the WiFi classification for ulcers.In conclusion, many useful but at times contradictory definitions of CLI have been suggested. Only a few have taken into account evidence, and none have been validated prospectively. This paper aims to address this and to give notice that a CLI registry within Europe will be set up to prospectively validate, or not, the previous and suggested definitions of CLI.

AB - Summary: Chronic critical lower limb ischemia (CLI) has been defined as ischemia that endangers the leg. An attempt was made to give a precise definition of CLI, based on clinical and hemodynamic data (Second European Consensus). CLI may be easily defined from a clinical point of view as rest pain of the distal foot or gangrene or ulceration. It is probably useful to add leg ulcers of other origin which do not heal because of severe ischemia, and to consider the impact of frailty on adverse outcome. From a hemodynamic viewpoint there is no consensus and most of the existing classifications are not based upon evidence. We should thus propose a definition and then validate it in a prospective cohort in order to define the patients at major risk of amputation, and also to define the categories of patients whose prognosis is improved by revascularisation. From to-day’s available data, it seems clear that the patients with a systolic toe pressure (STP) below 30 mmHg must be revascular-ised whenever possible. However other patients with clinically suspected CLI and STP above 30 mmHg must be evaluated and treated in specialised vascular units and revascularisation has to be discussed on a case by case basis, taking into account other data such as the WiFi classification for ulcers.In conclusion, many useful but at times contradictory definitions of CLI have been suggested. Only a few have taken into account evidence, and none have been validated prospectively. This paper aims to address this and to give notice that a CLI registry within Europe will be set up to prospectively validate, or not, the previous and suggested definitions of CLI.

KW - Critical limb ischemia

KW - ankle pressure

KW - definition

KW - oxygen transcutaneous pressure

KW - peripheral arterial disease

KW - toe pressure

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85065390176&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1024/0301-1526/a000764

DO - 10.1024/0301-1526/a000764

M3 - Article

C2 - 30451092

VL - 48

SP - 223

EP - 227

JO - VASA

JF - VASA

SN - 0301-1526

IS - 3

ER -

European Society for Vascular Medicine, Constans J, Bura-Rivière A, Visona A, Brodmann M, Abraham P et al. Urgent need to clarify the definition of chronic critical limb ischemia - a position paper from the European Society for Vascular Medicine. VASA. 2019 May 19;48(3):223-227. https://doi.org/10.1024/0301-1526/a000764