Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Forensic Toolmark Analysis on Bone and Cartilage
: An Evidence-Based Approach to Maceration and Preservation

  • Mohammad Alshamsi

Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis › Doctor of Philosophy

Abstract

The forensic examination of toolmarks on bone and cartilage is a critical component of criminal investigations, yet it lacks standardized, evidence-based protocols for the preparation and analysis of such evidence. This dissertation aims to fill this gap by developing quantitative, evidence-based recommendations to enhance the reliability and reproducibility of toolmark examination on skeletal and cartilaginous tissues.

A multi-stage research approach was employed, beginning with a scoping literature review to identify existing practices and a subsequent international survey of forensic practitioners to establish a global baseline of current methods. The core of the research comprised two quantitative experimental studies evaluating the effects of common maceration and degreasing techniques on toolmarks created on porcine bone and costal cartilage. A novel cascading assessment framework was developed and validated, utilizing microscopic quality scoring and three-dimensional (3D) surface scanning with the normalized cross-correlation function (CCF) to objectively measure toolmark preservation.

The results revealed a distinction based on substrate type. For bone, all tested water-based maceration methods caused significant degradation of microscopic detail, resulting in an 84.6% reduction in the total accumulated Consecutive Matching Striae (CMS) quality score (from 13 to 2), with subsequent degreasing resulting in further measurable loss. For cartilage, which was not subjected to maceration, degreasing protocols were found to significantly improve the visibility and quantity of identifiable toolmarks by removing obscuring tissue, with the number of toolmarks meeting the CMS criteria increasing from 2 before
degreasing to 9 after. For bone, the triple-casting technique was identified as the recommended method for documenting toolmarks prior to maceration, yielding a higher mean CCF max (0.380 ± 0.170, n = 7) compared to the acetone method (0.284 ± 0.117, n = 7). For cartilage, the manual degreasing (triple-casting) method also proved superior, yielding a higher mean CCF max (0.325 ± 0.055, n = 4) compared to the chemical degreasing (acetone) method (0.277 ± 0.036, n = 5), 20 proving superior for improving the microscopic quality of striations. The microscopic assessment protocol demonstrated high intra-observer reliability for both substrates: κ = 0.83–1.00 for bone (Chapter 6) and κ = 0.78–1.00 for cartilage (Chapter 7), validating its use in a forensic setting.

The international survey of forensic practitioners (n = 103 respondents across 31 countries) revealed that fewer than half of responding countries conduct toolmark examinations on bone and cartilage, and that the majority of laboratories lack standardised protocols for this type of analysis, confirming the absence of a global baseline and the urgent need for internationally agreed guidelines. This thesis concludes that a ‘one-size-fits-all’ approach to processing suspected toolmarked skeletal and cartilaginous evidence is scientifically unsupported. It provides the first quantitative evidence for substrate-specific protocols, establishing that toolmarks on bone must be cast using the triple-casting method prior to any maceration. For cartilage, triple-casting was also identified as the optimal method for enhancing toolmark quality through degreasing. By providing a validated assessment framework and data-driven guidelines, this research offers a robust foundation for the development of international standards by organisations such as OSAC and AFTE. Most significantly, the identification of substrate-specific protocols and the discovery of critical tool-side asymmetry provide immediate, actionable improvements for forensic practitioners, ultimately strengthening the scientific rigor, reproducibility, and legal admissibility of toolmark analysis in the criminal justice system.
Date of Award2026
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • University of Dundee
SupervisorDiana Swales (Supervisor) & Lucina Hackman (Supervisor)

Cite this

'