Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Living with Augmentative and Alternative Communication
: A mixed-methods exploration of family perspectives on AAC use involving children with Down syndrome who have limited speech or are nonspeaking

  • Elaine Scougal

Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis › Doctor of Philosophy

Abstract

Down syndrome is a chromosomal condition affecting around one in every 1000 live births in the UK. Many people with Down syndrome experience verbal communication challenges, presenting a barrier to being understood by others, particularly unfamiliar communication partners. These challenges can often limit participation and autonomy, making communication support vital. One important approach is the use of Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC); that is, ways of communicating other than or alongside speech. While AAC has strong evidence supporting its effectiveness, much less is known about how families of children and young people (C&YP) with Down syndrome perceive, adapt, and use AAC in everyday life and how they experience related support. This thesis addresses this gap by examining such experiences involving C&YP with Down syndrome who have limited speech or are nonspeaking.

The primary goal of the thesis is to understand the barriers and facilitators that shape their use of aided and unaided AAC, and how these factors influence their functional communication and social participation. To achieve this, the thesis draws directly on the perspectives of C&YP with Down syndrome and their family members, offering rich insight into what supports or constrains meaningful communication in real-world contexts. A secondary goal is to explore how caregivers experience the support they receive around communication and AAC. Understanding their perspectives is essential given the central role families play in enabling and promoting AAC use in everyday life.

An exploratory online questionnaire gathered responses from 264 caregivers across the UK relating to experiences of communication and AAC use involving C&YP with Down syndrome. The findings revealed widespread speech-related communication challenges in addition to limitations involving aided AAC (e.g. symbols and powered (voice output) communication aids) and the use of Key Word Signing (KWS). Challenges were highlighted related to communication support, contextual barriers impacting AAC use, and limited narrative communication for those requiring or using AAC. Sparse use of powered AAC was also reported relative to other AAC modalities.

To explore the above issues in more depth, further research included a multiple-case study of seven C&YP with Down syndrome who used aided AAC and KWS to support their communication, utilising field notes and reflections relating to their AAC use in the home. Additionally, Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis was used to explore the experiences of sixteen caregivers of these children. Together, these studies provided critical insights into the barriers and facilitators experienced in accessing and implementing AAC in everyday life, in addition to experiences of support.

Overall, the research highlights significant challenges related to communication support and AAC, underscoring the need for systemic and environmental changes to promote functional communication and social participation for this population. These changes involve both speech and language development and AAC use. The findings also inform the development of recommendations aimed at improving AAC provision and support for C&YP with Down syndrome and their caregivers.
Date of Award2026
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • University of Dundee
SponsorsCarnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland
SupervisorAnnalu Waller (Supervisor) & Alissa Melinger (Supervisor)

Cite this

'