Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

The mental health of neurodivergent adolescents attending mainstream education comparatively to online education
: a mixed methods study

  • Zoe Searle

Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis › Doctor of Educational Psychology

Abstract

Recent research highlights the challenges that neurodivergent adolescents face within a mainstream education environment, particularly those with Autism Spectrum Conditions (ASC). These difficulties can include sensory overwhelm, difficulties navigating social relationships in a school environment, exhaustively trying to fit in, and inconsistently applied educational support practices, all of which may negatively affect the mental health of the students. Although current English educational policy supports inclusive educational practices for autistic students, emerging research questions whether mainstream settings are in the best interests of neurodivergent learners.
This mixed methods study uses established measures to explore the mental health of autistic adolescents educated in mainstream versus online schooling environments. Specifically, it examines the lived experience of participating students and the specific benefits and challenges of both academic environments.
A pragmatic mixed methods approach was adopted, combining quantitative and qualitative data from a small sample of neurodivergent students (n=10) based in English schools. Quantitative data was gathered using the Revised Child Anxiety and Depression Scale (RCADS), which measures six domains of mental health, including anxiety and depression. Six students attended mainstream schools, and four attended online education settings. Semi-structured interviews were conducted via MS Teams to capture participants’ lived experiences, and a Braun and Clark thematic analysis approach was used to develop themes from the qualitative data.
Overall findings suggest that neurodivergent students in mainstream education presented with more complex and severe mental health difficulties than their online educated peers. RCADS data suggested that mainstream pupils experienced higher levels of anxiety, depression, and symptoms consistent with obsessive-compulsive disorder, social phobia, and panic disorder. In contrast, students educated in an online school reported fewer and less severe mental health difficulties.

Qualitative findings supported the quantitative data. Participants from mainstream school settings reported high levels of social stress, overstimulating sensory environments, bullying, and inconsistent application of strategies designed to support the students. Alternatively, students in online education described feeling safer, more emotionally regulated, and better able to manage their environment and pace of learning. Yet there were also highlighted challenges of an online facility, with some online students identifying social isolation as a significant drawback.
Despite a limited sample size, this study offers early evidence that current inclusive education policies may not fully address the needs of neurodivergent adolescents. The findings suggest the potential value of expanded, flexible education models that prioritise student choice and mental health and reflect a need for carefully designed hybrid models that balance structure and autonomy.

Future policy changes recommended include increasing state-funded access to online and hybrid provision, improving sensory regulation opportunities in mainstream schools, enhancing neurodiversity training for educators by neurodivergent practitioners, and adopting student-centred placement decisions by listening to students’ needs.

The overall findings contribute to a developing need for more personalised and flexible educational pedagogy to support the emotional wellbeing of neurodivergent learners and, indeed, all children. However, further research with a larger and more representative sample size is necessary to build on these preliminary findings and inform policy development.
Date of Award2026
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • University of Dundee
SupervisorBeth Hannah (Supervisor) & Tracey Colville (Supervisor)

Cite this

'